Verified Document

Workplace Deviance Counterproductive And Productive Behaviors Defining Essay

¶ … Workplace Deviance Counterproductive and Productive Behaviors

Defining Counterproductive and Productive Work Behavior

Counterproductive work behavior (CWB) is defined by an employee's actions causing harm to either a coworker or their employer (reviewed by Krischer, Penney, and Hunter, 2010). The forms of CWB can vary considerably, from arguing with or ignoring coworkers, damaging equipment to sabotage the work of others, and reducing the amount of time spent at work. Researchers have proposed a number of theories that attempt to explain the psychological roots of CWB and these include an employee reacting emotionally to a perceived negative workplace event or condition, or simply seeking a desired outcome (manipulation).

Krischer, Penney, and Hunter (2010) argue that organizational psychology research has focused almost exclusively on an employee's affective response to negative events, to the exclusion of internal or instrumental motivations. Instrumental motivations for engaging in CWB could arise from an employee's attempts to cope with a stressful situation at work, by something as simple as minimizing the amount of time spent at work.

The theoretical polar opposite of CWB is voluntary cooperative behavior above and beyond what's normally required by an employee-employer contract (reviewed by Koster and Sanders, 2006). A common term used to describe this type of behavior is organizational citizen behavior (OCB). The outcome of such behavior has an overall positive effect on the organization and character traits such as altruism and conscientiousness have been proposed as the primary motivations (reviewed in Vigoda-Gadot, 2006).

Rather than OCB arising...

The interpersonal structure thus created between an OCB employee and other members of the organization has been termed organizational solidarity (Koster and Sanders, 2006). In contrast to the reciprocity theory of OCB, or in combination with it, Vigoda-Gadot (2006) argued that OCB can arise out of workplace pressures and expectations that can cross the line into abusive and coercive management styles, which drive the employee to go beyond what is required. In these situations OCB would be compulsory, rather than voluntary. Together, these theories suggest that the psychological factors precipitating OCB may be just as complex as those for CWB.
The Relationship between OCB and CWB

The ability to define OCB or CWB is not always easy, because the context must be understood before a determination of whether an employee's behavior is productive or counterproductive. For example, Krischer, Penney, and Hunter (2010) argue that employees who withdraw in order to limit exposure to a stressful situation at work may actually be productive over the long run. Such coping strategies could mitigate potential burnout and therefore help minimize the costs associated with a high employee turnover rate.

Krischer, Penney, and Hunter (2010) also discuss the differences between problem-focused and emotion-focused coping and how the former is more commonly seen as productive. An example of problem-focused coping would be an employee limiting distractions, such as coworker interactions (withdrawal), in order to cope with a more demanding…

Sources used in this document:
References

Bennett, Rebecca J. And Robinson, Sandra L. (2000). Development of a measure of workplace deviance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85, 349-360.

Fodchuk, Katherine M. (2007). Work environments that negate counterproductive behaviors and foster organizational citizenship: Research-based recommendations for managers. Psychologist-Manager Journal, 10, 27-46.

Koster, Ferry and Sanders, Karin. (2006). Organizational citizens or reciprocal relationships? An empirical comparison. Personnel Review, 35, 519-537.

Krischer, Mindy M., Penney, Lisa M., and Hunter, Emily M. (2010). Can counterproductive work behaviors be productive? CWB as emotion-focused coping. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 15, 154-166.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Counterproductive & Productive Behaviors in Organizations in
Words: 1015 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Counterproductive & Productive Behaviors in Organizations In every organization that are some behaviors that are counterproductive, and also there are productive behaviors to be found in every organization. What are those behaviors, what impact to they have on job performance and what strategies would be best to ensure a maximum number of workers are engaged in productive behaviors? This paper reviews those issues and provides answers to the questions. Productive Behaviors Productive behaviors

Productive Org Productive and Counter-Productive Work Behaviors
Words: 769 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Productive Org Productive and Counter-Productive Work Behaviors Organizational success is predicated on the abilities and efforts demonstrated by personnel. With respect to matters such as job performance and productivity, a company's long-term prospects will rest significantly on the shoulders of day-to-day employees. This denotes the importance of identifying behaviors that promote productivity and eliminating those which are counterproductive. The discussion hereafter offers a concise consideration of how to achieve this balance. Productive and

Validity and Reliability Questions of
Words: 392 Length: 1 Document Type: Thesis

Presumably, the reliability of the responses between a monitored study and an unmonitored study could be validated by consistent reportage from the peer and the incumbent. This method was also used to control for the study's overall validity: the study would be a more valid measure of counterproductive work actions and their relationship to work stressors if an outside source validated the incumbent's responses. The study's authors still acknowledge a

Raise to the Authors Regarding
Words: 498 Length: 1 Document Type: Research Proposal

It seems as if personally asking individuals to participate increased the likelihood of responses -- following up with non-respondents, approaching members of the survey group personally beforehand, or even including incentives to participate like a free drawing of all respondents for a prize would ensure greater compliance in a wide range of industries, rather than a concentrated response. Only personally requesting individuals from several industry sectors decreases the reliability of

Deployed Parents with School Children
Words: 36892 Length: 123 Document Type: Multiple Chapters

MILITARY DEPLOYED PARENT PERCEPTIONS OF INVOLVEMENT IN THE EDUCATION OF THEIR CHILDREN: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDYbyEder G. BennettLiberty UniversityA Dissertation Presented in Partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements for the DegreeDoctor of EducationLiberty University2021MILITARY DEPLOYED PARENT PERCEPTIONS OF INVOLVEMENT IN THE EDUCATION OF THEIR CHILDREN: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDYby Eder G. BennettA Dissertation Presented in Partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements for the DegreeDoctor of EducationAPPROVED BY:James Eller, Ed.D., Committee ChairMichael-Chadwell Sharon, Ed.D., Committee MemberAbstractThe purpose

The Involvement of Childrens Education Military Deployed Parents...
Words: 34918 Length: 116 Document Type: Multiple Chapters

MILITARY DEPLOYED PARENT PERCEPTIONS OF INVOLVEMENT IN THE EDUCATION OF THEIR CHILDREN: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDYbyEder G. BennettLiberty UniversityA Dissertation Presented in Partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements for the DegreeDoctor of EducationLiberty University2021MILITARY DEPLOYED PARENT PERCEPTIONS OF INVOLVEMENT IN THE EDUCATION OF THEIR CHILDREN: A PHENOMENOLOGICAL STUDYby Eder G. BennettA Dissertation Presented in Partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements for the DegreeDoctor of EducationAPPROVED BY:James Eller, Ed.D., Committee ChairMichael-Chadwell Sharon, Ed.D., Committee MemberABSTRACTThe purpose

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now