Verified Document

Why Management Cannot Terminate Employment Unjustly Case Study

¶ … Discharge for Off-Duty Conduct The rules regarding discharge for off-duty conduct are as stated: Under 661.53, employees are prohibited from engaging in "unacceptable conduct" such as "criminal, dishonest, notoriously disgraceful or immoral conduct, or other conduct prejudicial to the Postal Service" and the conviction "maybe be grounds for disciplinary action" (Holley 626). These rules are important for providing the context for the dismissal of Lee by the Postal Service management. Whether or not his criminal conduct could be deemed prejudicial to the Postal Service is a matter of dispute, according to the Union.

Thus, the Union emphasizes the "nexus" as used in labor arbitration. This term means the focus or central point of the activity as well as its relation to the Postal Service. The Union claims that the nexus was not related to the Postal Service and therefore did not impact or fall within the jurisdiction of the rules. This is also known as the "nexus principle" in labor arbitration (Secunda).

The nexus principle is important here because it plays a significant role in how the issue should be considered: the context of whether or not Lee engaged in mail fraud is discussed by the Union, which shows that Lee did not engage in this nor was he charged with this -- that it was a false charge leveled by the Postal Service, which essentially tainted the investigation from the beginning.

Following the logic of the nexus principle, the issue of equal treatment arises and the Union plays this card rather well by citing six different cases in which Postal Service workers were either charged or convicted of crimes far more heinous than Mr. Lee's, which in all likelihood could have been accidental even though he pled guilty (sometimes pleading guilty is a better and less costly alternative to fighting for one's innocence). The equal treatment issue is important because it illustrates...

These cases set a precedent, which is clear: Lee's grievance should have been upheld in the light of these preceding cases.
The rule concerning the employer's submission of the unemployment compensation claim in the labor arbitration proceedings is that the employee must not be engaged in any activity that is prejudicial to the Postal Service and it is alleged that this is what Lee engages in -- although the Union points out that the management does not prove this charge and in fact levels a false claim. So the fact that Lee is denied unemployment compensation is another factor in the arbitration that must be considered.

The amount of weight that should be given to Lee's job performance after his conviction should be equal to that given to his performance prior conviction, since his conviction is not related to the job or the performance of the job. Essentially, Lee is an employee against him no disciplinary action has ever been brought in his 13 years of service, neither before nor after his conviction -- until his termination. Thus, if anything is to be considered it should be that Lee has indeed been a suitable employee for the Postal Service.

The arbitrator should consider the union's submission of evidence of the continued employment of Ms. Edwards for a number of reasons. First, the information regarding Ms. Edward's continued employment was not made known to the union until proceedings were already underway. The management protested that the union had plenty of time prior to the proceedings to draw comparison between Edwards and Lee but failed to do so. This is not true, as the example of Edwards being allowed to continue her employment was evidence that came…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Holley, William. The Labor Relations Process. OH: South-Western, 2012. Print.

Mayhew, Ruth. "Can a Union Employee File a Charge of Wrongful Termination?"

Chron. Web. 3 October 2015.

Secunda, Paul. "Getting to the Nexus of the Matter: A Sliding Scale Approach to Faculty-Student Consensual Relationship Policies in Higher Education." Syracuse Law Review, vol. 55 (2004): 55-85.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Termination of Employment Contract in
Words: 3122 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Proposal

Request must be made in writing by the employee within 15 working days of termination. The employer has 10 working days from receipt of the request to give a truthful reason in writing for the termination." (P 1). Despite that many employers have been very careful in terminating the contract employment agreement based on justifiable cause; there are still series of cases where employees challenge the termination of their employment

Policy for XYZ
Words: 1914 Length: 6 Document Type: Business Proposal

Employment Law Policies for XYZ Describe and explain all the possible employment laws that could govern the employment at XYZ. Job discrimination. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits hiring, firing or pay discrimination based solely upon a person's race, religion, sex or national origin. It also prohibits sexual harassment. Employees and applicants must be treated equally and harassment will not be tolerated. Age discrimination. The Age Discrimination in Employment

Labor Relations Manager Interview Synopsis
Words: 2106 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Labor Relations Manager Interview Synopsis Labor relations can be defined as the study of managing employees who are under the union. This division is normally found in the Human Resource area and mainly complies of the history of labor, the union involved, and contracts that have been signed. Labor regulations are normally regulated by law or sometimes traditions. Labor relations can be termed as the relation between workers and management on

Leaders Handling Anger and Conflict
Words: 23221 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

If it is just generally assumed that these employees are lazy or do not care about their job, they will often be the object of anger from other employees. If other employees and management would talk to these employees and determine what could be done to help them, it is quite possible that simple accommodations can be made that will keep everyone happy and help to dissipate the anger

Immigration - Drawing the Line
Words: 7210 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

There is no question, however, that immigration issues will remain in the forefront of our national policy debates. Deportation Factors and Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude Research indicates that since the late 1980s, Congress had been tightening the substantive provisions of the immigration laws, to make it far less likely that a convicted criminal alien can find a way to be relieved of expulsion. For many years the basic statutory pattern was

Internet Profiling and Privacy This
Words: 3885 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics is an essential part of the individual condition. As an important person who starts up a large business as well as deals on a daily basis with other corporation at all arena of expansion so basically business ethics is lively and glowing plus hotly chat about in boardrooms all over the world. Furthermore for the majority of administration and boards know their accountability goes well beyond periodical results.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now