Verified Document

Why God Can't Be Blamed For Evil Essay

¶ … Problem of Evil Natural Evil vs. Moral Evil

Natural evil is a term that embraces theodicy, in the sense that there are devastating earthquakes, and tornados, tsunamis, and hurricanes, and other terrible weather situations that harm people and communities (Philosophy of Religion). God created the planet and in doing so He never promised to always have fair weather with puffy white clouds and rays of sunshine every day. The planet is a natural world reality, and besides the frightening weather events, natural evil could also be seen in a child's birth defects, in a mother's breast cancer; one could argue that a woman got breast cancer from eating too much red meat or other foods that are not recommended, but nevertheless when she is stricken with this deadly disease, it can be considered a natural evil that has caused her pain -- and maybe taken her life as well.

On the other hand, moral evil is due to the bad behaviors of a person or organization (Flescher, 2013). Moral evil could be murder, could be mean-spirited unjustified public slandering of a person who does not deserve those attacks. Adultery is considered a moral evil and though it is not as serious as armed robbery, it nonetheless is committed by persons who break God's laws (The Ten Commandments).

Why must a Theodicy be internally consistent vis-a-vis the explanation of evil's existence? The other question that is normally linked to this questions is: since He is all-knowing and all-powerful, then why doesn't God prevent evil from happening?

A very good beginning for an answer to this question is provided by Elwell when the author discusses the contradiction inherent in the desire to have God stop evil, or at least to understand why God can't do that. Since apparently it is believed that God offers people...

He makes his decision to take that purse and run because he has the free will God has given him. So God can't put a notion in his head to not steal the purse and also grant him free will.
Another very different position can be arrived at when reviewing the idea presented by Gottfried Leibniz, which posits that because God has created only the "best world" -- or as Leibniz explains, "God is the only metaphysically necessary being." There are of course an infinite number of other kinds of worlds God could have created, but He chose the best world. Hence, it can be viewed as God being "morally praiseworthy," even though there is moral depravity and unending amounts of evil in the world. Leibniz may seem that he is rationalizing in a strange way or contradicting himself. But going back to free will, God chose to give humans free will and He gave them the best metaphysical world possible in which to make choices and judgments. So the fact that there is evil in the world, the best world that God can make, God is shown to be "just," Leibniz explains.

The Merits of Elwell's Position on the Problem of Evil and Free Will

Elwell does use some narrative that is perhaps too esoteric for the lay person to fully comprehend. Not that he does it purposefully, but using words like "nonconsequentialism" cause the reader to look that word up and try and fit it into the context that Elwell is building. That is, God has solved the problem of evil, which is a problem of "internal consistency"…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Elwell, Walter A., Evangelical Dictionary of Theology (Second Edition). Edited by Walter A.

Elwell. (Ada, MI: Baker Academic, 2001): 434-436.

Flescher, Andrew Michael. Moral Evil. Georgetown University Press. (October, 2013).

Retrieved June 28, 2014, from http://press.georgetown.edu.
Philosophy of Religion. "The Argument from Natural Evil." Retrieved June 28, 2014, from http://www.philosophyofreligion.info.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

God Exist The Debate As
Words: 760 Length: 2 Document Type: Journal

DNA instructs the cell. DNA is a three-billion-lettered program telling the cell to act in a certain way" [what authorized and created that system, if not God?] and e) "We know God exists because he pursues us… constantly initiating / seeking for us to come to him… [and] keep the question of His existence constantly before us" (Morse, 2010, p. 2). Meanwhile Oxford professor Anthony Flew argues against those who

Solaris, God and Ineffability the
Words: 1420 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

It can be argued that they have no way of knowing the outcome of their reactions. And indeed, nor does Chris. What differentiates Chris from the rest of the crew is the love he feels for Rheya. Love in the end is the essential force that enables him to forgive both Rheya and himself, and in the end love both redeems and kills him. This dichotomy furthers the ineffability

Genesis God As the Truth
Words: 1676 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

It was clear that Cain had murdered his brother, an offense that is unthinkable in today's modern context. When Cain refused to admit his sins, God punished him in the same manner as he had punished Adam and Eve. God had cast Cain out of his homeland, just as He had done with Adam and Eve; "And now art thou cursed from the earth, which hath opened her mouth

Tragic Events and God It
Words: 1128 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Time and again mankind has proven himself to be resourceful, skilled, and deliberate in taking on the forces of nature. When mankind acts in a way that is contrary to the forces of nature, such as building fixtures or structures in the path of well-known paths of natural destruction, then mankind is challenging the forces of nature that bind mankind to the earth - the domain that God created

Innocence of the Gods: A
Words: 1674 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

By taking part in his destiny, she somewhat disproves Zeus' claim that humans are wrong to suggest that the gods are to blame -- for without her interference, the many suitors would not have been slaughtered by Odysseus. Athena's speech here, which will fuel the eventual release of Odysseus and his long ride home, continues at this point to describe the situation in which (at the story's beginning) he is

Elements of the Heroic
Words: 2819 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Heroic The Nature of Evil Evil is portrayed in a variety of ways in Genesis A and B. Of the Junius Manuscript. Evil manifests despite God's attempt to give those who are loyal to him everything they need. The first manifestation of evil is in Heaven, when certain angels become proud and rebellious. When God decides to create Earth and human beings, evil also infests this. The phenomenon can then be

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now