Verified Document

Whistleblowers, Men Of Courage, But Term Paper

Related Topics:

Teaching the theory of evolution to broaden the minds of the young people of his community likewise not only destroys the life of the teacher Bertram Cates, but also the life of his fiancee, and ruins the reputation of Hillsboro, where the national presses tar and feather the town as a place populated by narrow-minded religious zealots. Although the play may sympathize with Cates' desire to open up his students' minds, it shows that not every supporter of evolution is as equally high-minded. There is also: "E. K. Hornbeck of the Baltimore Herald, who has championed Cates in his columns and is greatly and haughtily amused at the spectacle of ignorance and bigotry before him" (Iannone, 1997). Hornbeck simply wants to sell newspapers at Hillsboro's expense.

Unlike Stockmann, Drummond sways the opinion larger public support of the nation, if not the jury of Hillsboro and contributes to wider public's perception of Hillsboro as a backwater. "Though the jury brings in the inevitable guilty verdict, it is clear that Drummond has triumphed -- and along with him, freedom of thought. The judge charges Cates a token fine of one hundred dollars" (Iannone, 1997). But there clearly is a social and financial loss to the sense of community of the town. "In discussing Brady's death after the trial, Drummond repudiates the journalist Hornbeck's scathing ridicule. As Drummond sees it, Brady was a once-great man who had ceased to move forward....In its closing scenes, the play emphasizes again what it suggested throughout: Brady's fundamentalism is wrong, but so is Hornbeck's godless cynicism" (Iannone, 1997).

Narrow-mindedness, the play suggests,...

Drummond as an attorney must focus on winning in the courtroom, or at least in the courtroom of American popular opinion, not upon showing two sides of the issue. He calls for progress and for Hillsboro to "abandon our faith in the pleasant poetry of Genesis," thus reinforcing Hornbeck's portrayal of Hillsboro and Brady as behind the times, even if Drummond personally sees merit in the town's way of life and Brady's point-of-view. But there is no 'pure' way to win a political battle, without hurting someone. If someone is too single-minded, they risk harming and alienating people like Stockmann harms his family's livelihood, and like Brady at the end of "Inherit the Wind," who alienates most of the newspaper-reading American public. To gain a moral victory like Drummond for his client, an advocate must sometimes act against his own better, moral impulses, like making his courtroom opponent seem like a fanatic in the interests of persuasion.
Works Cited

Iannone, Carol. "The Truth About Inherit the Wind." First Things. Feb 1997.

http://www.firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=3645

Ibsen, Henrik. "An Enemy of the People." 1880. Project Gutenberg's Etext. 2002.

http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext00/aeotp10.txt

Lawrence, Jerome & Robert E. Lee. "Inherit the Wind." Originally published in1950.

New York: Bantam, 1983.

Moi, Toril. "Dr. Stockmann's Ambiguities." 17 Aug 2000. Asides Magazine.

http://www.shakespearetheatre.org/plays/articles.aspx?&id=497

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Iannone, Carol. "The Truth About Inherit the Wind." First Things. Feb 1997.

http://www.firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=3645

Ibsen, Henrik. "An Enemy of the People." 1880. Project Gutenberg's Etext. 2002.

http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/etext00/aeotp10.txt
http://www.shakespearetheatre.org/plays/articles.aspx?&id=497
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Whistleblower of Them All: Daniel
Words: 661 Length: 2 Document Type: Thesis

"The Pentagon Papers were political dynamite because they told what had really been going on in Vietnam. That was in contrast with the official line, regularly presented by top government and military officials, who blatantly lied to the public about the Vietnam War. For example, the official line was that the war was going well, when actually there was plenty of inside information that it wasn't," for many years

Whistleblowers Are in the Minority in a University Study of Behaviors...
Words: 683 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

disobedience between individuals and it deals with unjust authority. An experimental scenario was set up by the authors in order to see -- from a group of 149 individuals -- how many of them would obey an "unethical request" and how many would not obey, and would instead blow the whistle on the request. The authors did this study because they believe that there has not been enough research into

British Petroleum: Leadership Case Study
Words: 4490 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

leadership is crucial for organizational success in a competitive marketplace. Gaps in leadership or conduct that could be interpreted as ineffective could have adverse effects on the reputation and overall competitiveness of a company. One company that suffered the adverse effects of poor leadership was British Petroleum, during and in the years leading up to the 2010 explosion and oil spill in the Gulf. Research has since shown that

US Army Corps of Engineer Plan Review
Words: 3820 Length: 12 Document Type: Chapter

United States Army Corps of Engineers issued a report in 2012 that was known as the Human Capital Strategic Plan. It was meant to serve as a benchmark and projection for what was to come from 2012 through 2017. Of course, the United States Army Corps of Engineers is a public safety-oriented organization and their plan will be analyzed in terms of resource allocation, budgeting efficacy and overall quality.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now