Verified Document

Whistle-Blowers:saints Or Sinners Whistle-Blowers: Are They Saints Essay

Whistle-Blowers:Saints or Sinners Whistle-Blowers: Are They Saints or Sinners?

Whistle-blowing is the professional form of playground tattling, jail house snitching, breaking the code of Omerta by a mafia kingpin. It is a socially discouraged practice and carries heavy sanctions - "unemployment, and often-times ridicule from [the] company." (Weinberg, March 14, 2005) Weinberg quotes David Stetler, a defense attorney who was part of the defense team for TAP, a pharmaceutical company whose prosecution was initiated by a whistle-blower. Stetler makes the claim that whistle-blowing is bad for a company as "just another form of extortion." (Weinberg, March 14, 2005) One must consider the source when deconstructing such a claim. Of course an attorney who is taking part in the defense of such a lawsuit will make the charge that whistle-blowing is an iniquitous practice; in fact, if one did not hear such statements from such an attorney, his commitment to his case and his own professional standards would be in question. Stetler is clearly defending his clients, as his job requires. Of course whistle-blowing is injurious to the company whose illegal pursuits are being revealed. But is whistle-blowing immoral, vindictive, selfish, as Stetler is inferring by his statement? This writer believes these are the relevant questions that need to be addressed.

Whistle-blowing is never good for a company that is harboring criminal workers or engaging in professionally-sanctioned illegal activity. However,...

Not to do so makes one complicit, not only from a moral standpoint, but from a legal standpoint as well. The fact that whistle-blowing - tattling, telling, snitching - is not only a serious social misstep but also professional suicide is the reason for offering formal financial incentive. If a worker blows the whistle on his company for incompetent, immoral, or illegal operations, he will immediately lose his job and is then subject to professional ostracism, making it impossible to obtain subsequent employment in order to support himself and possibly a family. Financial reward, the precedence for this being set in 1986 with the federal legislation know as the Whistle-Blower law (Weinberg, March 14, 2005), is necessary for the whistle-blower. This serves not only to encourage workers to report illegal job-related practices in the face of social penalties, but to compensate the whistle-blower for his loss of employment, and lost wages, health insurance, and savings and retirement plans that go along with that.
It is conceivable that some whistle-blowers are financially motivated. It is also possible that any worker who goes looking for illegal activity can either find it or fabricate it in the form of a whistle-blower's self-fulfilling prophecy. For example, Weinberg tells us how Douglas Durand's evidence against TAP…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Robbins, Stephen P. And Judge, Timothy A. Chapter Four: Personality and Values. Organizational Behavior. (2007) San Francisco: Prentice-Hall. Ed. 12. pp. 104-143.

Robbins, Stephen P. And Judge, Timothy A. Chapter Five: Perception and Individual Decision-Making. Organizational Behavior. (2007) San Francisco: Prentice-Hall. Ed. 12. pp. 144-183.

Weinberg, N. Whistle-Blowers: Saints or Sinners? The Dark Side of Whistle-Blowing. (March 14, 2005) Forbes. pp. 90-95.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Self-Fulfilling Prophecies and Communication
Words: 2623 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Self-Fulfilling Prophecies and Communication Does the full moon really effect one's behavior? Does Friday the 13th really deserve extra precaution? Is a Harvard professor wiser than say an Appalachian hermit? Or is someone who abandons their life of wealth and fame, suffering from mental illness? Is one race or gender more adept at a particular profession than another? There is no scientific evidence that proves the full moon has any effect

Self-Fulfilling Prophecy When I Was in High
Words: 680 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

self-fulfilling prophecy when I was in high school. I never thought I was very good at math. I could understand the concepts when I was in class, but would get very anxious about the tests. I was so convinced that I was going to fail the math tests that I would start panicking days ahead of time. This made studying absolutely impossible, and taking the test was agony. My

Folk Wisdom and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies
Words: 660 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Folk Wisdom and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies Folk Wisdom Eating fruits and vegetables on a daily basis has always been an important aspect of good nutrition and maintaining a healthy lifestyle. But amongst the various foods in these categories, the apple stood primus inter-pares and there is even the adage that states "an apple a day keeps the doctor away." This folk wisdom can well be proven by undergoing a scientific experimentation whereby several

Dating Is Related to Self-Fulfilling
Words: 1236 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Their partners have proved to express dissatisfaction when concerning the evolution of their relationship, and, thus, they've shown that HRS has a great importance in breaking up a relationship. Conflicts are generally more damaging for HRS women than they are for HRS men, and, subsequent to a conflict, HRS women are affected much more than LRS women. Without having experienced a conflict, the behavior of HRS women does not

Self-Destructive Behavior Depicted in Kafka's
Words: 4103 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

He does his share of complaining but he does little else to remedy the situation. The truth of the matter is that Gregor did not enjoy much of his life away from work. He never expresses a desire to have more in his life nor does he express any regret, until he is a bug. In "A Hunger Artist," our hunger artist chooses to live a considerable amount of

Self-Worth and Need to Belong
Words: 756 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Gang Recruitment Self-Worth and the Need to Belong Juvenile Delinquency Paper The self-help author Wayne Dyer once wrote that, "Self-worth comes from one thing…thinking that you are worthy." This quote captures the functional role of gangs: they exist because they serve a purpose. Gangs are attractive to recruits because they promise a variety of benefits. Though many members reap material benefits from joining, it is the psychological benefits which play a critical role

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now