Verified Document

What Was The Romantic Movement  Essay

Romanticism There are many way to approach the concept (or movement) known as romanticism, and over the many years romanticism has been perceived and defined in wildly different ways. Scholars and historians have spent tens of thousands of words dissecting, describing, and trying to come to terms with what romanticism really means. The truth is there are many ways to approach romanticism, and this paper looks into scholarly approaches to romanticism in 1925, 1949, and 1990. How is the approach to romanticism in 1925 different -- but also similar -- to another approach in 1990? That question and others that are germane to this topic will be presented in this paper. The three scholarly articles that will be critiqued in this paper are: Paul Kaufman's "Defining Romanticism" (1925); Morse Peckham's "Theory of Romanticism" (1951); and David Perkins' "The Romantic Movement" (1990).

Three scholarly articles from three periods in the twentieth century

Kaufman, 1925. History shows us that 1925 was the year in which Adolf Hitler published his manifesto, Mein Kampf -- the antithesis of romanticism -- and F. Scott Fitzgerald published The Great Gatsby, not representative of romanticism either. It was also the year an article was published by Paul Kaufman suggesting that there had been, since 1890, an "engrossing concern" as to the true meaning of romanticism. Kaufman also termed the number of attempts to categorize romanticism as "bewildering" (Kaufman 193). Kaufman goes into the interpretations by various scholars, adding to the mystery of just what romanticism truly represents to the scholar.

When Kaufman uses the word "bewildering" he is apparently responding to the fact that notwithstanding the many "formulas" that had been in the mix as to what romanticism means, the "widely divergent views" are increasing, adding to the confusion (194). The author quotes Professor P.R. Frye (from a book published in 1922) who asserts that romanticism is "anything which 'tends to disrupt or disturb the balance of the faculties'" (194). That is likely the most obscure attempt at defining romanticism available;...

Another quote that Kaufman offers is from Professor H.J.C. Grierson, who, in 1923, explained that when it comes to romanticism, "…the spirit counts for more than the form" (Kaufman 194). Grierson didn't exactly hit the nail on the head, but he is certainly on the right track because we have learned in this class that romanticism is less about content and more about how and why the piece was painted.
It is clear that in the early 1920s scholars such as Kaufman were frustrated and nearly fed up trying to come up with a workable definition of romanticism. On page 196 of his essay Kaufman uses words like "futility," "crisis," "hopeless," "intolerable," and "chaos" to describe previous attempts at coming up with a more precise description. Nevertheless he seeks to reinvent a definition by searching for the historical meaning vis-a-vis "romantic" (198). I'm not sure he accomplishes what he set out to do because in his final paragraph he admits that the "present laissez-faire attitude" towards the task of defining romanticism is "demoralizing to criticism" (204). Moreover, he concludes, in an age of "wayward and troubled thought," any attempt to come to a workable understanding is "the greatest service criticism can render…" (204).

Peckham, 1951. Twenty-six years after Kaufman's essay, Morse Peckham digs into the same troubling issue, with a bit more success than his scholarly predecessor. Peckham, seemingly less bewildered, is certainly more pragmatic than Kaufman in that he begins his scholarship with what romanticism is not. Peckham asserts that romanticism should not be viewed as having been spawned by the "political revolutions" in Europe, or of the industrial revolution (Peckham 1951). Yes, the great push in Europe for political reform comes into play in romanticism, Peckham agrees; however, the two are not "the same thing" (5).

Peckham references the 1949 attempt by Jacques Barzun to define romanticism as part of "the great revolution which drew the intellect of Europe…from the expectation and desire of fixity into…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Kaufman, Paul. "Defining Romanticism: A Survey and a Program." Modern Language Notes,

40.4. (1925)" 193-204.

Peckham, Morse. "Toward a Theory of Romanticism." PMLA, 66.2 (1951): 5-23.

Perkins, David. "The Construction of 'The Romantic Movement' as a Literary Classification."
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Romantic Movement Explored in the
Words: 1321 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

The winds are "driven, like ghosts from an enchanter fleeing" (4) and the poet's thoughts are like "winged seeds" (7) of each passing season. The poet writes, "Wild Spirit, which art moving everywhere; / Destroyer and preserver; hear, oh, hear!" (13-4). Critic Jeanine Johnson notes that "Ode to the West Wind" "returns to the idea that human development and nature follow parallel cycles. If the seasons correspond to the

Orient West Minoan and Romantic Movements Describe
Words: 1422 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Orient West Minoan and Romantic movements Describe the earlier historical art period, characteristics of the style, and social conditions that may have contributed to the advent of this style. Within the history of the Ancients, the story of Classical Greek art and architecture is prefaced by the earliest epoch of the seafaring Cretan civilization, Minos. The Palace of King Minosis is a magical structure reflective of this early world of classical lyricism. It

Romantic and Modern Design Styles Comparing the
Words: 1568 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Romantic and Modern Design Styles Comparing the Ornate and the Natural: A Study of Two Theories of Design History often dictates societal mentality more so than current climate, yet in times of peace, it seems that the beautiful and the artful flourish. This very concept is debatable, especially in interior design, where the fashions of the time very often have a much-felt impact upon design theories and the way in which they

Romantic Era the Romantic Period
Words: 1400 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

They brought a new sense of "free experimentation" to composition, while advancing realistic techniques that emphasized the use of "local color" in literature. This style in the literary world helps to define the Romantic Era and has shaped writing to this day. Science: Of equal importance to literary pursuits during the Romantic era were achievements in science. By the 1830's, activity in science and technology was rapidly increasing and becoming a source

Romantic Period
Words: 1848 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

British and German Romanticism: Revolutionary art, counterrevolutionary politics The Romantic Movement has become part of our cultural consciousness to such a degree that its assumptions regarding the centrality of the individual, its elegiac idealization of the pastoral, and its belief in human spirituality that could not be understood with pure rationality have become associated with the essence of art itself. While the birth of the Romantic movement is associated with the French

Romantic Period
Words: 2677 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Music-Romantic Period 'ROMANTICISM' is a concept that can be easily recognized but is probably just as difficult to define. Like all other movements, Romanticism also emerged as a reaction to general idea, practices, social norms and political problems of the time. The general concept of romanticism sees music as an expression of intimate and sublime emotions. The period that can be categorized as romantic varies but generally covers the decades from

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now