Verified Document

What Are The Benefits Of A Union Shop

Union Organizing Issues What are the differences from the employer's viewpoint, in operating a union-free environment vs. A unionized environment?

Eric Dontigney, writing in the Houston Chronicle for Demand Media, explains that while unions do provide certain benefits to employees, including legal representation and pensions, unions do not "necessarily represent a panacea to all the woes of working life" (Dontigney, 2015). Non-unionized workplaces also provide advantages to business owners as well as employees, and in fact business owners operating in non-unionized workplaces enjoy what Dontigney calls "…considerably more freedom in the dismissal process."

When there is a union, there can be long-drawn-out formal processes involved in dismissing (firing) an employee. But without a union, Dontigney explains that business owners "avoid" those long drawn-out dismissal proceedings, and business owners can "…dismiss employees for contract violations" and owners can simply decide not to renew a worker's contract or "…simply end employment without specific reason" (p. 1). Because management can move "easily" to fire employees that have failed to be productive, or employees that are "disruptive" in the workplace, having a non-union workplace has its advantages for management and business owners.

Maintaining what Dontigney calls a "congenial work environment" is always important in terms of productivity and profitability for a business, and when there is no union this atmosphere is easier to create (p. 1). Moreover, a business owner in a non-union workplace doesn't have to deal with pre-determined raises and promotions...

For example, Dontigney mentioned that unions negotiate deals in which the person with the most time on a particular job gets the promotion, "rather than the person with the best chance of doing the job successfully" (p. 1). Hence, in a non-union environment management can promote a worker based on ability not longevity; "merit-based promotions can prove very effective in moving talent" into positions that the business management sees as most pivotal (p. 1).
Also, in a non-union shop employees can go directly to a manager or foreman or executive and be his or her own negotiator for a raise, for a better benefit package or for a more favorable position within the company. But unions "tie the hands of both employers and employees" when it comes to benefits, contracts and wages, because union leadership is the "sole representative for employees," and all interaction with management comes from union leaders, Dontigney (p. 2).

Pros and Cons -- Unions vs. Non-Unions: Journalist Flora Richards-Gustafson writes that in a unionized workforce, employees get higher wages as a general rule. The author of another article in the Houston Chronicle points out that the "increase in wages may come at the expense of fewer jobs"; that said, union workers are likely to get more benefits than workers in a non-union environment (p. 2). While it is true that union members are in general paid more than non-union workers, union workers pay dues, and those dues can be fairly steep so it can take away from the fact that union workers get higher wages.

Some union policies can "detract from worker satisfaction"…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Dontigney, E. (2015). The Advantages of a Non-Unionized Workplace. Demand Media.

The Chronicle. Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://smallbusiness.chron.com.

National Federation of Independent Business. (2013). Your Rights During a Union

Organizing Campaign. Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://www.nfib.com.
Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://www.nlrb.gov.
National Labor Relations Board (2010). Your Rights during Union Organizing. Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://www.nlrb.gov.
Workforce. Demand Media. Houston Chronicle. Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://smallbusiness.chron.com.
Relations Act. Retrieved January 30, 2015, from http://www.dol.gov.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

What Companies Must Know When a Union Tries to Organize
Words: 1108 Length: 3 Document Type: Corporate

Senior Management MEMO to Senior Management: What are the differences in operating a union-free workplace vs. A unionized workplace? Here is some background on the issue. A view that many observers express is that unions tend to raise "non-union wages" (Waschik, et al., 2010). The way the argument goes is that when there is a union shop, wages go up. Hence, non-union companies raise their salaries as well to complete with union

Labor and Union Studies in Washington and Oregon State
Words: 3095 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

Labor and Union Studies in Washington and Oregon States The United States labor movement has its roots in the complex trappings of the industrial revolution. Laborers were just starting to come to the United States from foreign countries because they had learned that there were many jobs available for even the most unskilled worker. People were also moving from rural areas in America to the cities in an attempt ti have

Preparing for a Union Negotiation
Words: 1095 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Negotiation, the company needs to have a set of objectives with which to focus negotiations. First, the company cannot afford a labor-related shutdown. If competition has intensified, the last thing Molloy needs is to give its customers an excuse to switch to someone else. A shutdown was eviscerate the business. The second thing is that the contract has to fit with the strategy that the company is going to undertake.

Marketing Strategies Challenges Faced by the Body Shop in Thailand...
Words: 3568 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

Business Breaking into the Asian Market: The Marketing Strategies of the Body Shop and Its Competitors We live in a global world. Technology, in particular television and the Internet, link together different peoples. They cross the barriers of oceans, mountains, and political frontiers. The decisions that governments make, the actions of environmental activists, and the marketing campaigns of large corporations affect hundreds of millions across the Planet. Time was when a retail operation

Labor and Union Studies Define
Words: 4045 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

All of the employees on an airplane, for example, could form themselves into a vertical bargaining unit if they chose, the unit including stewards and stewardesses, as well as pilots. Similarly, in a school, teachers, janitors, and office staff could all form a vertical unit. In contrast a horizontal bargaining unit unites all those who perform similar work. The fact that the pilots at Spirit Airlines belong to a

Economic and Environmental Benefits of
Words: 7982 Length: 29 Document Type: Dissertation

Cost and CO2 reduction analysis were performed using local data available from both commercial and professional bodies. A majority of current thermal rating programs require the equipment to be tested in accordance to a standard test under specified testing conditions. This approach provides reliable data because it is possible to replicate such tests within an accepted uncertainty band. There are, however, some rating programs which combine a standard test

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now