Verified Document

Wells Fargo And Business Case Study

Leadership Using the Hedgehog Concept Collins was not incorrect in the way he described the leadership at Wells Fargo. When Collins and his research team were carrying out the research, the relied on interviews and newspaper articles plus the performance of the company on the stock market. All this combined resulted in their assumption that the leadership and change in strategy by Wells Fargo was resulting in the increase in stock price. It is true that for a company to become a great company it needs to identify the three things pointed out by Collins (2001) namely what is the company good at, what drives the company, and what are employees passionate about? Wells Fargo managed to identify all these three things and discovered that in order for it to increase investor profits it needs to change its business strategy. Changing the business strategy did have the expected results, and the company experienced superior profits. However, all this was based on the performance of the company on the stock exchange. There was no tangible evidence that showed the company stock rose because of the changes implemented. In the book, there is no demonstration anywhere that the authors carried out any empirical research or capture any data directly related to the company's performance. All the information is based on published newspaper, and magazine articles and interviews conducted. This resulted in the bias of information collected since most of the interviews would paint the company is good light and the articles were all showing the improvements made at the company. Collins did the best he could to explain the situation at Wells Fargo and his findings at that time looked accurate. The measure employed by Collins to determine a company's greatness was stock market return....

This measure could be influenced by numerous factors and assuming that the measure was because of the transition only was wrong.
Collins did misinterpret the performance of the company from 2001. Mainly because the book was written and focused on what the company had done in the past and not what it was going to do in the future. The future is not so easy to predict, and one can only base their analysis on how the company has performed previously. This is a good measure for predicting and positioning the company to continue succeeding. Understanding the past is valuable in order for one to predict the future (Ortmeier & Meese, 2010), but in the case of Collins he never fully understood what was going on at Wells Fargo. What Collins wrote about was based on the past performance of the company, and he had hoped that since the company was performing well and it had performed so well during the research phase, it would continue to perform well in the future. Like earlier pointed out the research carried out did not involve looking into the business practices, and they only collected data from articles and interviews. The data collection methodology was itself skewed in that all the information was going to point out how well the Hedgehog Concept had worked for Wells Fargo. Since its CEO had opted to transform the business from being a per loan profit to a per employee profit, it looked the company was going to continue its growth trajectory. The mantra embraced by the company was 'run it like you own it.' This mantra meant that each employee would do their work as though they owned the company or as though the company was their own. The mantra was good, but it seemed it could not run for long. This was something that Collins had not foreseen. However, had he conducted a much intensive research and collected data by observing what and how the employees went about performing their jobs. The lack of such…

Sources used in this document:
References

Collins, J. (2001). Good to Great (illustrated ed.). Bishopbriggs, GLASGOW: HarperCollins.

Ortmeier, P., & Meese, E. (2010). Leadership, ethics, and policing: Challenges for the 21st century: Prentice Hall.

Schafer, L. (April 11, 2017). Schafer: Wells Fargo CEO didn't take 'run it like you own it' mantra to heart. Star Tribune. Retrieved from http://www.startribune.com/wells-fargo-ceo-didn-t-take-run-it-like-you-own-it-mantra-to-heart/419098944/

Staff Report. (April 21, 2017). Wells Fargo admits account scandal dates back to 2002. New York Post. Retrieved from http://nypost.com/2017/04/21/wells-fargo-admits-account-scandal-dates-back-to-2002/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Wells Fargo
Words: 730 Length: 2 Document Type: SWOT

SWOT Analysis: Its Uses for Wells Fargo As noted by Giesen (et al., 2010), one of the most difficult things for any business to know is when and how to alter its core business model. Technology businesses such as IBM have been forced to do this, as the physical product lines on which they based their successes have become obsolete. The consequences of failing to innovate are dire, as seen when

Wells Fargo Collateral Protection Insurance Scandal
Words: 1382 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Wells Fargo Scandal The Wells Fargo Collateral Protection Insurance (CPI) Scandal occurred as a result of the banking firm placing CPI on accounts even though the account holders did not ask for it or want it. It resulted in customers paying unnecessary and higher fees over a period of time. Wells Fargo was sued and agreed to settle the case out of court for approximately $400 million without admitting fault (Top

Wells Fargo Fraudulent Accounts Scandal
Words: 1539 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Wells Fargo Fake Account Crisis A crisis is defined as the perception of an unprecedented event/incident that threatens shareholders’ valuable expectations in relation to economic, health, environmental, and safety issues (Coombs, 2014). Since organizations operate in a challenging and highly competitive environment, they are likely to undergo crises. An example of an organization that has experienced a crisis in the recent past is Wells Fargo. The company recently experienced a scandal

Wells Fargo and Coach
Words: 3350 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Successful and Unsuccessful Leaders Coach K. and John Stumpf are leaders that have used differing styles of leadership. On one hand, Coach K. uses a transformational leadership style whilst Stumpf uses an authoritative style of leadership. Stumpf employed a controlling and intimidating technique whilst Coach K. uses a more interactive and relational approach. Coach K. has been a successful mentor and coach over the years by having good and healthy

Safeway and Wells Fargo Company Analysis Safeway
Words: 1483 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Safeway and Wells Fargo Company analysis Safeway Company remains a private company, which is listed on the New York stock Exchange being an American food and drug retailer. The firm is among the biggest supermarket chain retailers found in North America. The company has a solid supply chain of network partners, which facilitates manufacturing as well as distribution facilities. Presently the company seems to be operating under almost 13 unique brands found

How the VUCA Methodology Can Be Applied to the Wells Fargo Scandal...
Words: 1403 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Write a -4-page academic paper in which you describe a business situation, apply a critical thinking framework to the situation, and recommend evidence-based solutions to the situation. Explain how the concepts of VUCA (volatility, uncertainty, complexity, and ambiguity) could affect both the situation and the solutionIntroductionThe banking business is currently undergoing fundamental change. Since the financial crisis, a litany of new rules, regulations, and procedures have been imposed on the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now