Verified Document

Weber's Science As A Vocation And Politics As A Vocation Term Paper

Weber's Analysis Of Vocation In The Modern, Secular Protestant World In both his essays on "Science as a Vocation" and "Politics as a Vocation," the father of sociology Max Weber advances the idea that the development of a Protestant religious ideology created modern, secular notions of what constituted a vocation. At the time of his writing, Weber stated, it had become increasingly accepted that there was an equal validity of the vocations of science and politics, as opposed to the sole existence of a vocation of faith in service of God. Before Protestantism, religious dogma and religious bureaucratic institutions alone determined scientific truth. Religious internal politics also influenced national politics and political affairs. Now, Protestantism allowed for the creation of a private, religious sphere of the sacred that was intrinsically separate from a public, secular sphere of academic or political thought.

This rendering science and politics as potentially respectable vocations and also severed much of the religious meddling of past eras in science and politics. Protestantism made God a personal matter, rather than a matter filtered between a believer, Church, and only finally conveyed to God. Yet Weber also saw an advancing danger -- much as he approved that religious persecutions of the past, of scientists and leaders, by the clergy had ended, he feared a new bureaucracy was being created within secular institutions that was equally stifling to good science and good government as the church had been in ages past.

According to Weber, academic bureaucracy and orthodoxy in science and ethical machinations for personal means in politics, even...

Bureaucracies within secular institutions were just as bad as the Church bureaucratic wrangling about dogma and appointments of specific cardinals. Likewise, although politics in the form of secular and civil administration became a legitimate vocation with the end of the "hero worship" style of leadership of the Renaissance, as Weber terms the worship of Popes and Machiavellian Princes, when poor administers rose merely because they knew 'the right people,' this was just as damaging, if not more so, than the rise of unethical cardinals in the Church.
Weber allows that unlike past systems of patronage, the modern state's creation of secular vocations was not measured in godliness but in the meeting of bureaucratic standards. But in "Science as a Vocation," Weber notes that a meritocracy in a bureaucracy is not enough to ensure excellence. Weber praises the modern academic system of the United States, "where the bureaucratic system exists, and the young academic man is paid from the very beginning. To be sure, his salary is modest; usually it is hardly as much as the wages of a semi-skilled laborer. Yet he begins with a seemingly secure position, for he draws a fixed salary." This salary confers intellectual and economic freedom to the academic apart from obedience to a bureaucracy.

Weber felt that most bureaucracies, particularly controlling bureaucracies such as that of the German academy, but also, to some extend in America as well, stifle the imagination rather than enable it. In this sense, quite often, secular vocations also have their similarities to the former criticized Church. Often,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Weber, Max. "Science as a Vocation" and "Religion as a Vocation." From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills. Translated and edited. New York: Oxford University Press, 1946. Retrieved from Dead Sociologist's Society Website at http://www2.pfeiffer.edu/~lridener/DSS/Weber/scivoc.html and http://www2.pfeiffer.edu/~lridener/DSS/Weber/polvoc.html.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Bureaucracy According to Weber and
Words: 2522 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Such resources will include proper funding for facilities, personnel, technological and communicational resources and other such elements required for an administrative capacity congruent with the needs of the public which it is designed to serve. It is thus that the bulk of Meier's book concerns the actual structure of a government based on the principle of bureaucracy. Here, he explores in detail the relationship between a variant of agencies and

Comparative Politics
Words: 4306 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Politics Although it is not perfect, the presidential system of government, as typified by the United States (U.S.) is the best system of government ever conceived. By creating a system where the public can remove administrations, without changing the legal basis for government, democracy aims at reducing political uncertainty and instability, and assuring citizens that however much they may disagree with present policies, they will be given a regular chance

Electoral Politics As Detailed Quite Eloquently in
Words: 1039 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Electoral Politics As detailed quite eloquently in Chapter 15 of Haywood's text, having political power is not simply getting one's way in a crude and overt manner, like passing or pushing a bill through congress. Rather, power also involves the task of agenda-setting itself, putting an idea upon the national platform of discourse. The author additionally cites Bacharatz and Baratz as critical in defining not simply making yes or no the

Sociology Is a Social Science
Words: 768 Length: 2 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

Then, there are sites like Just Answer! In which actual lawyers answer basic questions for under $50. While their advice is not legally binding, it nevertheless can steer a person onto the right course. The Federal Government even agrees that there are divergent needs within the legal profession -- simple legal documents, and then the services of a lawyer for more complex litigation, trademark law, complex housing or personal

Public Administration and Considers the Effect of
Words: 2154 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

public administration and considers the effect of their writings and theories on the field of public administration. It has 6 sources. An analysis of the core areas of public administration and how these areas interrelate with one another; taking into account the theories and writings of major players in the field of public administration and how their views shaped these areas. The principles of public administration are the clearest description of

Social and Political Theory
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Social and Political History How do the functionalist and conflict theories relate to the conceptualizations of government and sovereignty presented by Heywood? How much is enough government? What level of government do we need to get our collective business done? How much sovereignty is appropriate for the American government to have, particularly in view of terrorist threats in the post 9/11 environment? When does government and sovereignty interfere with the full

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now