Verified Document

Water Sustainability What Is Your Essay

The case of the World Commission on Dams is a good example of how this tendency to centralize water resource management can be mitigated, if not completely eliminated. The political reality of the world is that government represents more than just laws and policies, just as management and governance has to be about more than just enacting laws and edicts, but should reflect the values of the community and the interests of the communities that will be summarily affected by those policies. In the case of water resource management, this means that it must be a prerequisite to involve a wider variety of community stakeholders as part of the decision-making process in order to make more "equitable and sustainable use of rivers. But in most countries, the cards are stacked heavily against an inclusive and more balanced process. Patterns of governance for the most part still reflect the utilitarian mind-set of the twentieth century, which focused on the engineering challenges of bringing rivers under control for society's economic advancement" (Postel and Richter 168). Accordingly, the issue that governments traditionally consider with regard to water resource management has been how to accomplish specific tasks that will, presumably, benefit the political or economic landscape. Little thought has been traditionally given to how such decisions would impact the people who actually have to live with those decisions: in the case of dam construction, those individuals whose lives and livelihoods might be displaced permanently by the presence of an enormous lake where there once was a river.

The World Commission on Dams, sponsored by the World Bank, found that this traditional model is rife with failings and invariably fails to take into account local and regional social and environmental impacts, focusing instead on technical or political benefits instead. After two years of intense study, the WCD found that diversifying stakeholder involvement throughout the communities that would be affected by dam-related decisions needed to be a project requirement. Referencing the WCD Knowledge Base of Dams, the Commission recognized a failure to include the interests of affected people in the planning process or, when involved, the political power and right to participate in the process and ensure that their voices were considered. The WCD found that "in terms of the social impacts of dams, [...] negative effects were neither adequately assessed nor accounted for [and that the] range of these impacts is substantial, including on the lives, livelihoods, and health of the affected communities dependent on the riverine environment" ("Dams and Development" 16-19).

To break from this tradition of neglect in dam and water resource management, the WCD attempted to undermine the traditional model and involve a wide range of stakeholders in an effort to involve the people who would ultimately be affected. In particular, the WCD stood out in the way in which it selected participants on the commission. Rather than following the "eminent persons model" or distinguished politicians, the WCD sought out and comprised itself of "active practitioners whose personal legitimacy derived from their prominence in international networks of stakeholders" (Dubash et al. 2). The intent, which was somewhat successful, was to involve individuals that...

Their efforts were successful and helped to create a more active process of participants who might engage the issues in ways dramatically different than politicians otherwise would.
Of course, the WCD still selected from amongst the most privileged and knowledgeable on the subject: a requirement for actually getting things done, but not necessarily conducive to actually reaching the people who would be affected by any decision that was made. Nonetheless, the World Bank encourages this kind of local participation, even amongst the "poor, indigenous people, and disadvantaged groups -- in the water-related operations it supports" (Bauer, "Water Resources Management" 16). Throughout the world, this has been an increasing trend as local and global grassroots efforts have emerged to help the people who are directly affected by these water management issues voice their concerns and issues in a forum that could actually affect the decision making process. Such initiatives have emerged in Chile's river basin management, and in World Bank projects throughout the world (Briscoe, Salas, and Pena 10; Postel and Richter 169).

The guiding principle, and a noble one in theory if not always in execution, behind these movements is the idea that water resource management should happen as close to the actual people who will be affected by the decisions as possible (Bauer, "Water Resources Management" 15). Top-down hierarchical decision making will only marginalize and create continuing problems associated with dams and water management that could be avoided or at least alleviated in those cases where it would have been otherwise possible to connect local people with the resources they could have used to manage the issue themselves.

Works Cited

Bates, Sarah F., Getches, David H., MacDonnell, Lawrence J., and Wilkinson, Charles F. Searching out the Headwaters: Change and Rediscovery in Western Water Policy. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993.

Bauer, Carl J. Siren Song: Chilean Water Law as a Model for International Reform. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future, 2004.

Bauer, Carl. "Water Resources Management." A World Bank Policy Paper. Washington, DC: The World Bank, 1993.

Briscoe, John, Salas, Pablo Anguita, and Pena, Humberto. "Managing Water as an Economic Resource: Reflections on the Chilean Experience." Environmental Economics Series. Washington, DC: The World Bank, April 1998.

Brown, F. Lee. "Water Markets and Traditional Water Values: Merging Commodity and Community Perspectives." Water International 22.1 (1997): pp. 2-5.

Dubash, Navroz K., Dupar, Mairi, Kothari, Smitu, and Lissu, Tundu. A Watershed in Global Governance? An Independent Assessment of the World Commission on Dams. World Resources Institute, Lokayan, and Lawyers' Environmental Action Team, 2001.

Postel, Sandra and Richter, Brian. Rivers for Life: Managing Water for People and Nature. Washington, DC: Island Press, 2003.

"Dams and Development: A New Framework for Decision-Making." The Report of the World Commission on Dams: An Overview. 16 Nov. 2000.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Bates, Sarah F., Getches, David H., MacDonnell, Lawrence J., and Wilkinson, Charles F. Searching out the Headwaters: Change and Rediscovery in Western Water Policy. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993.

Bauer, Carl J. Siren Song: Chilean Water Law as a Model for International Reform. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future, 2004.

Bauer, Carl. "Water Resources Management." A World Bank Policy Paper. Washington, DC: The World Bank, 1993.

Briscoe, John, Salas, Pablo Anguita, and Pena, Humberto. "Managing Water as an Economic Resource: Reflections on the Chilean Experience." Environmental Economics Series. Washington, DC: The World Bank, April 1998.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Water Sustainability
Words: 636 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Sustainability of the Water Supply in the Caribbean Water sustainability is not merely an environmental problem. It is a political and social issue as well. Research articles such as "Challenges to manage the risk of water scarcity and climate change in the Mediterranean" by Iglesias (et al. 2007) focus on issues which specifically impact environmental changes such as global warming but do so in a manner to suggest specific policy prescriptions

Water Sustainability in the Developing World
Words: 884 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Water Delivery Water sustainability has been of increasing concern in academia as a political as well as an environmental problem. My dissertation will specifically focus on water sustainability in the Caribbean and how to improve methods of delivery. Water is a finite, not an infinite resource, and must be treated as such. Additional research is needed to see how best to improve current quality and availability in the region. One useful

Sustainability Science
Words: 2946 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Sustainability Science Phase 4 Discussion Board The article that I will be reviewing is "Key competencies in sustainability: a reference framework for academic program development." This article was published in the journal Sustainability Science and directly covers the development of the academic discipline. The authors note that as the discipline matures into a full-fledged academic discipline, there is a need to understand the nature of sustainability science and what the key competencies

Water in Sub-Saharan Africa
Words: 2389 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Water in Sub-Saharan Africa is of special interest because of my background but water is a fascinating issue in general, one that I think will play an increasingly large role in the 21st century, as the effects of population growth and climate change bring about significant changes to our water usage and availability. A lack of water in particular has a substantial destabilizing effect. Water as a social issue combines a

Water Resources Development and Improving Access to Clean Water Worldwide...
Words: 1099 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Clean Water An Analysis of Worldwide Efforts to Bring About Clean Water Sustainability The concept of clean water for everyone is very normal in the United States. There is nothing foreign about this concept, and nothing out of the ordinary. In fact, it is a given that all should have clean water in this country and it is because all people do have clean water, and an abundance of it. Yet there

Sustainability in Business Sustainability Powerpoint® Presentation...
Words: 2009 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Sustainability in Business Sustainability PowerPoint® Presentation and Paper Sustainability refers to the capacity of a business to have no significant negative impact on the local or global community, environment, society or the economy. These businesses strive to meet the triple bottom line (TBL) which consists of people, planet and profit. This means that the businesses demonstrate their commitment to CSR through catering for people, the planet and profit. For people, it means

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now