Verified Document

Vision And Strategic Direction Visionaries, Article Critique

The biggest failure of this article is the lack of directness and candor the authors call out CEOs for not having a consistency of vision and direction to support their organizations, and in so doing, create effective incentive and compensation programs. The authors have proposed no metrics despite a wealth of theorems and theoretical constructs, further distancing their analysis from the immediate, pragmatic needs of companies who require a very consistent vision in order to succeed. References

Rotemberg, J.J., & Saloner, G. (2000). Visionaries, Managers, and Strategic Direction. The Rand Journal of Economics, 31(4), 693-716.

Wilson, I. (1992). Realizing the power of strategic vision. Long-Range Planning, 25(5), 18-18.

Leading Change Critique

Body of the Critique and Summary

The foundation of Leading Change (Gebhart, 1996) is the eight phases of the Kotter Model of Change. The author has carefully defined each of the eight stages of the Kotter Model of Change, making the first, which is increase urgency, a foundational element of their analysis (Gebhart, 1996). The author says that "leaders can alleviate the complacency that grips organizations by concentrating more on having a compelling sense of urgency that change is necessary for improvement" and the attainment of a challenging objectives and goals (Gebhart, 1996).

Defining the steps of building guiding teams, getting the vision right, communication for buy-in and enabling action are what the author indicates as being critical for long-term change to become the new normal of an organization (Gebhart, 1996). Juxtaposing these steps with the need for creating short-term wins, don't let up in terms of intensity to change, and finally, making change stock as being all critically important for the long-term change management to occur (Gebhart, 1996). The author delineates the past three phases of creating short-term wins, not letting up, and making it stick (or making change last) as all being critical...

While celebrating short-term gains, leaders also need to produce more change and keep up the momentum"(Gebhart, 1996). These are essential strategies for change management and must be orchestrated well across all eight phases, regardless of the duration of the change being attempted, which is a key point Dr. Kotter has made in commentary before of the Kotter Model of Change (Iveroth, 2012).
The author has taken a very organized, methodical approach to defining the eight steps of the Kotter Model of Change. In so doing, they haven't provided enough analysis of each step, and have failed to show how a sense of urgency can fuel the entire process, and in fact must if lasting change is going to occur. The most significant shortcoming of the overall article is the isolation of urgency as a factor in overall success of all eight factors. Second, the rewarding of employees for "creating short-term wins by rewarding the change agents" is not enough to bring a high level of internalization for goals and objectives. The author fails to describe how lasting change is attained by not addressing this specific point.

Third and most significant there is no correlating analysis to other frameworks which could have provided a much greater level of insight into managing change. One is the reliance in Information Technologies (it) organizations on change management processes and methodologies that can provide greater risk mitigation and long-term planning flexibility (Iveroth, 2012). Another is the use of autonomy, mastery and purpose as a means to create greater levels of long-term motivation. Neither of these frameworks is discussed, which is a major shortcoming of the analysis.

References

Gebhart, J. (1996). Leading Change. Sloan Management Review, 38(1), 119-119.

Iveroth, E. (2012). Leading…

Sources used in this document:
References

Gebhart, J. (1996). Leading Change. Sloan Management Review, 38(1), 119-119.

Iveroth, E. (2012). Leading global it-enabled change across cultures. European Management Journal, 30(4), 340.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Strategic Leadership at Coca-Cola the
Words: 1114 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

They assumed fewer risks and focused more on consolidating the strategies which had already been implemented, and which proved successful. In other words then, Robert Goizueta is understood as a visionary leader, who had the courage to assume risks and to implement his vision of the Coca Cola Company. The managers that followed were more of strategic leaders, who focused on the implementation of the vision through strategic efforts

Strategic Planning for Business the Objective of
Words: 1261 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Strategic Planning for Business The objective of this study is to examine the importance of strategic planning for business. Toward this end, this study will conduct a review of the literature in this area of inquiry. Zuckerman (nd) writes that the concept of strategy 'has roots in both political and military history, from Sun Tzu to Homer and Euripides. The word 'strategy' comes from the Greek 'stratego', which means to 'plan

Strategic Leadership
Words: 1216 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Leadership There are a number of different approaches to leadership development. At different leadership levels, the skills and tasks required to excel can be quite different, but an organization should have a pathway that recognizes these differences while allowing for skills development and personal growth to move leaders from one level to another. A first-line supervisor is learning the basics of organization and motivation, and typically does so within a tight

Strategic Plan
Words: 10476 Length: 38 Document Type: Term Paper

Reviving a Company: How to Bring New Life to a Mature Business An Independent Learning Project Poly-Metal Finishing, Inc. is a company that has had a successful history of more than thirty years in the metal-working industry, providing complete anodic service to the aerospace, military and commercial sectors. I have worked for this company for eight years and am now part of the management team. With a change in management has come the

Strategic Analysis: The Coca-Cola Company This Paper
Words: 1771 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Strategic Analysis: The Coca-Cola Company This paper examines the Coca Cola Company, and whether its mission, vision, and values statements reflect the company's actual approach to business. While the paper concludes that, taken individually, the mission, vision, and values statements are insufficient to apprise stakeholders of Coca Cola's future goals; taken together they form a strong picture of where Coca Cola is and where it wants to be in the future.

Strategic Management in Business Development
Words: 2332 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Strategic Management in Business Development The term "strategic planning" is generally used in the narrow sense, namely the application of management tools to address areas such as, profitability, efficiency, growth and competitive advantage. Ultimately, to address concerns of stakeholders for increase shareholder value and long-term competitiveness. Business development is at the heart of strategic thinking and needs imagination and innovation. It should be proactive and anticipatory. It involves the creation of a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now