Verified Document

Validity In Quantitative Research Designs Validity Quantitative Essay

Validity in Quantitative Research Designs Validity Quantitative Research Designs Validity research refers extent researchers confident effect identify research fact causal relationships. If low validity a study, means research design flawed results .

Threats to internal validity in quasi-experimental designs

Quasi-experimental studies have several issues that lead to lack of internal validity of the study. These occur as a result of the experimental conditions not being highly controlled or randomized. This leads to intervention and control groups being nonequivalent leading to issues with study design. This is what is evidenced in the study conducted by Yuan et al. (2009)

where five units assigned a number of 8 to 10 voluntary participants to either the experimental or control groups. There is thought to be a risk of bias in assigning participants to the two groups as a result of this. This comes from the random error that occurs on measurements across the two different groups. This random error also affects the statistical conclusion validity of the study since it creates an element of instability in the measurements making the results of the study to be highly unstable thus unreliable. Since there is a risk of bias with such quasi-experimental designs, there is the introduction of a constant source of error into the results which creates the instability in the results.

In a quasi-experimental design there is also the risk of self-selection effect. This occurs when participants choose the group which they want to join. In this study, it can be expected that those nurses who are more fit and willing to embrace physical fitness were more likely to opt for the intervention group rather than the control group. This creates an error since it becomes hard to estimate whether the effect of the intervention is as a result of the intervention itself or a preexisting factor in the participant which in this case is the likelihood of joining physical fitness programs Moss, 2007()

Another...

(2009)
is that of differential selection. This is where the study investigators are more likely to assign participants that fit a particular description to a particular group. For example it may be thought that those who were seen to be less fit were assigned to the intervention group in order to see if the intervention had any effect on this. This creates a variation in the groups that is much to the extreme Sireci, 2007()

Strategies to strengthen the study's internal validity

The best strategy to strengthen the study's internal validity is to have an experimental design where participants are randomly assigned into either the intervention or control groups. In this case, the investigators would have to come up with some sort of random code with which the study participants are then randomized to either the intervention or control group. They should stick to this randomization code despite issues with self-selection or differential selection. Additionally after using a randomization code, the code should be adequately concealed in order to prevent the investigators and the participants from being able to tell what the group that the next participant will land. The investigators should also make efforts to blind the participants, investigators and those involved in assessing outcomes. This generally ensures that there is no way in which the effect estimate can be influenced by external factors. In this study it may be difficult to ensure blinding Mislevy, 2007.

However, it may be attempted by choosing nurses in different shifts or those in different facilities who may not have time to meet and discuss about the study. Blinding of outcome assessors such as those performing fitness evaluations in this study can be ensured by making sure they test the participants without knowing which group they are in.

In order to improve the internal validity of the study, there is also need to design the control group as…

Sources used in this document:
References

Embretson, S.E. (2007). Construct Validity: A Universal Validity System or Just Another Test Evaluation Procedure? Educational Researcher, 36(8), 449-455. doi: 10.2307/4621099

Mislevy, R.J. (2007). Validity by Design. Educational Researcher, 36(8), 463-469. doi: 10.2307/4621101

Moss, P.A. (2007). Reconstructing Validity. Educational Researcher, 36(8), 470-476. doi: 10.2307/4621102

Sireci, S.G. (2007). On Validity Theory and Test Validation. Educational Researcher, 36(8), 477-481. doi: 10.2307/4621103
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Quantitative Research Designs Validity
Words: 692 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Validity, in essence, has got to do with the extent to which a given research study measures the accuracy of a specific concept – effectively meaning that a study can be said to have passed the validity test if it accurately mirrors that which the researchers set about to investigate. In quantitative research, as Polit and Beck (2012) point out, “researchers strive to design studies that are strong with respect

Research Design Issues in Education Dual Credit
Words: 945 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

The Challenges of Dual Credit: A Research Proposal Problem Statements Dual credit or dual enrollment programs “are designed to boost college access and degree attainment, especially for students typically underrepresented in higher education,” (United States Department of Education, 2017, p. 1). With this lofty goal set, it should seem that dual credit programs would be reducing the educational achievement gap. After all, dual credit programs by definition allow all students the opportunity

Validity in Quantitative Research Designs
Words: 782 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Validity in research is a term that refers to the extent with which researchers are confident that they have determined causal relationships through the cause and effect they identify in their study. As a result, validity is an important aspect of research since it helps in determining whether the research design is flawed and the credibility of research findings. There are various kinds of validity that are utilized in determining

Research Design in Public Administration
Words: 1032 Length: 3 Document Type: Creative Writing

Strengths/Weaknesses of the Quantitative ApproachIntroductionQuantitative research is a widely used approach in public administration research that involves the collection and analysis of numerical data. This approach has several strengths, including the ability to use probability sampling methods to select representative samples, the ability to replicate studies to verify findings, and the ability to collect large amounts of data quickly and efficiently. However, there are also limitations to quantitative research, such

Research Design Methods and Ethics in Psychology
Words: 957 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Although ethical values and principles guide all of the American Psychological Association’s (APA, 2017) ethical codes, there are different ways of interpreting and applying those ethical principles depending on the situation. Clinical and counseling psychologists have different ethical guidelines for their profession. For example, there are different ethical principles related to clients being treated by psychologists in counseling sessions versus the standards for conducting psychological research with human participants. Both

Research Design and Methods Used in Leadership
Words: 597 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Data Collection in Leadership As a social science, leadership research may involve any type of quantitative or qualitative data collection method. Qualitative research data collection methods include observation, participant-observation, interview, and document or content analysis (“Data Collection Methods,” n.d.). Quantitative data collection methods used in leadership research may include surveys and experiments, which allow for statistical analysis, the establishment of causality between independent and dependent variables, and the tracking of results

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now