Verified Document

Vaccination Policies Essay

Ethics of Public Health Policies Public health concerns necessarily introduce a tension between the individual and the greater good, which may have different resolutions depending on the ethical perspective that one uses to assess them. As a society, the United States has determined that certain public health policies so promote the greater good that they should be considered even if they infringe upon private liberties, or, in some cases, pose a threat to individual health or welfare. One widely discussed example of this type of policy is universal healthcare or affordable healthcare for the impoverished; others are forced to subsidize healthcare costs for those who can least afford it because it is believed to be in the best interest of overall public health. However, some public health policies are even more controversial. Vaccinations to prevent the spread of communicable illnesses, particularly childhood vaccinations, may be one of the most controversial public health policies. Although childhood vaccinations have been demonstrated to reduce childhood mortality, there are health risks associated with vaccines that can make requiring vaccinations a difficult ethical issue. What type of vaccination policy a country should have may depend on whether the country approaches the issue from a utilitarian, distributive justice, or paternalistic perspective.

Childhood Vaccinations

Childhood vaccinations consist of a series of vaccines to prevent certain childhood illnesses, given at a certain schedule, so that, by the time a child enters into the public school system, he or she is fully vaccinated. There are some risks associated with vaccines and some small percentage of children have adverse reactions to those vaccines. Moreover, for children who are high risk, vaccines may not be recommended or may be postponed from the usual childhood schedule. The result is that, in order to provide maximum effectiveness, most children should be vaccinated, which provides herd immunity even to children...

Vaccines have been proven as an effective and life-saving preventative health measure. However, falsified research linking childhood vaccinations to Autism resulted in a substantial portion of people refusing to vaccinate their children, and helped lead to the resurgence of childhood diseases, such as measles, which had been virtually eradicated in the United States.
While the risk from vaccinations may have been grossly overstated, the reality is that there is some risk associated with vaccines. This risk seems to directly conflict with the principles of autonomy. Autonomy refers to the right to self-determination regarding heath decisions and discourages conduct that would prevent people from taking autonomous action (Anonymous, 2011). As a result, whether it is acceptable to force or compel people to vaccinate their children in order to promote overall public health remains one of the most controversial ethical issues in public health.

Utilitarianism

The utilitarian perspective supports not only a vaccination policy, but also compulsory vaccinations with very few exceptions. In utilitarianism, "the morally justifiable act is that which produces the greatest amount of value over disvalue" (Anonymous, 2011). Furthermore, the relative worth is determined by the consequences of actions, not the intentions behind those actions. Because vaccinations provide herd immunity in addition to individual immunity and do result in lower death rates from communicable diseases, vaccinations clearly provide the greatest amount of value over disvalue for the community, as a whole. Moreover, the individual risk from vaccinations is relatively small, while the potential reward can literally be life-saving, suggesting that promoting a vaccination policy, even at an individual level, would fit within the utilitarian perspective.

Distributive Justice

The theory of distributive justice may seem to have little to do with vaccination…

Sources used in this document:
References

Anonymous. (2011). Ethical Theories and Principles [PowerPoint slides].

Buchanan, D. (2008). Autonomy, Paternalism, and Justice: Ethical Priorities in Public Health.

American Journal of Public Health, 98(1), 15-21. Available via ProQuest.

Selgelid, M.J. (2009). A Moderate Pluralist Approach to Public Heath Policy and Ethics. Public Health Ethics, 2(2), 195-205. Available via EBSCO.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Policy Analysis Critique Rationale for the Chosen
Words: 3283 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Policy Analysis Critique Rationale for the chosen policy Avian influenza is a virus causing lethal infection in human beings (Sims et al., 2003). It can be transmitted from patients to other human beings. It is a deadly virus with track record of 6 deaths in Hong Kong in 1997. That incident was just the start of this health issue. The virus spread enormously and caused H5N1 infection numerous times in Hong Kong.

Vaccines
Words: 2345 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Historical Impact of Vaccines on Global Health:     This essay would explore the development and historical significance of vaccines in controlling and eradicating infectious diseases. It would examine the milestones in vaccine technology and the global collaboration efforts, such as the eradication of smallpox, the reduction of polio cases, and the impact of the measles vaccine. Additionally, it would discuss how vaccines have shaped population health over the

Vaccines and Autism the Work
Words: 2097 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

V. ANALYSIS The work of Maxwell McCombs entitled: "The Agenda-Setting Function of the Press" relates the fact that the press plays a primary role in the life of the public and influences the focus of attention of individuals and makes provision of the "facts and opinions that shape perspectives on topics of the day." (2005) McCombs explains that 'agenda-setting' of the press works to influence the issues in the news and

Health Policy HPV Vaccine
Words: 3489 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) in the United States of America. It also discusses its association with different diseases. It highlights the role played by federal and state government to control this disease from preventing. In addition to that this paper also discusses whether the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) vaccination should be made mandatory for girls entering sixth grade or not. Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) can be defined as a group

Why Drug Testing and Vaccine Mandates Are Legal and Appropriate
Words: 741 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Employee Privacy � Drug Testing vs. Mandatory VaccinationsMandatory vaccinations and various drug-testing regimens have long been used in the American workplace as a condition of employment in an effort to protect organizations as well as individual employees. Many Americans, however, are adamantly opposed to Covid-19 vaccine mandates, some to the point of resigning or even becoming violent in response to them despite having been already vaccinated for a laundry list

Nursing Ethics and Vaccination Debate
Words: 1658 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

The Vaccination Dilemma The rights of individuals to refuse vaccinations, and the rights of parents to refuse their children vaccinations, has been increasingly called into question because of the way individual autonomy conflicts directly with the rights of the general public. For example, outbreaks of vaccine-preventable illnesses have increased, with serious outbreaks of measles in the United States being a prime example. Although the United States Centers for Disease Control and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now