Verified Document

Utilitarianism Applies To The Utility Of The Essay

Utilitarianism applies to the utility of the end result. There are, at least, two models that are similar in content: Mill and Benthams's Principle of Utility. Mill stated that it was the consequences of the good or bad action to the individual that determined morality of that action, whilst Bentham proposed moral consequence arising from "the greatest good for the greatest number of people." Pain and pleasure, he wrote, are our masters; and the hedonistic (or 'felicific') calulus should be used to determine this greatest happiness principle (Dinwiddy, 1989). Both Mill and Bentham advocate a system of ethics that depended on dissemination of the greatest amount of good to the largest quantity of people. In this case we have at least three individuals to consider: the psychologist himself, the students, and the department chair. Each -according to utilitarianism -- will need to consider the best that is (a) for the recipient, (b) for the greatest majority of people. The greatest majority of people and the recipients in this case would be the students: they either receive a course on physiological psychology or do not. One can theoretically add to this ' greatest' amount of people / recipients by adding the clinical psychologist's family to the list: they would certainly benefit by his earning more money. Likewise, the department chair and his or her family too would benefit by the added compensation achieved by smooth ongoing of course.

Utilitarianism would balance this by considering the scenario of the course being dropped and of the students receiving no instruction in physiological psychology whatsoever.

The fact that it is a clinical psychologist, rather than anyone else outside the psychology discipline, who is offered the course shows that he or she is not as ignorant of psychological physiology as heretofore supposed. Psychology is his expertise and any course...

Moreover, the individual's expertise in the clinical section may well have associations with the physiological area in at least one element, particularly so if the psychologist deals with the brain, with intelligence, with hearing and so forth. One would need to know more about the individual's particular expertise in order to decide whether a connection exists, and if a connection does exist the individual can easily connect the course to his expertise providing the students with illuminating and informative instruction. Either way, the psychologist is not as ignorant as heretofore supposed and the course, being, anyways, an introductory course, will benefit from the professor's input. Being that the majority, in this case, would benefit from existence of the course, utilitarianism suggests that the clinical psychologist proceed in instructing the material.
Kant's Formalist Theory

Ethical formalism, in specific, Kant's formalist theory applies universal laws to ethics. If something is wrong, it is wrong all the time. And the reverse too: a meritorious prescription -- something that is right -- is right all the time regardless of circumstance, place, and time. If death for instance is wrong, then it is a universal law that the wrongness of death applies to each and every situation, but if kindness is just, one should be kind to each and every individual regardless of specific case. Logical laws or 'universal prescriptions', rather than the specific content of the situation, define ethical judgment and reaction.

In the case of the clinical psychologist teaching the class, overt application of Kant's law seems to denote that the department chair would be wrong in asking the psychologist to lead the class, and likewise the psychologist would be wrong in…

Sources used in this document:
References

Dinwiddie, J.R. Bentham Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.

Modern Library classics. Ethics: the essential writings, New York: Modern Library, 2010.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives a Comparison of
Words: 1076 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives A Comparison of the Theories of Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives The principles of Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives contradict each other on many fronts. Both provide a rational for making moral decisions, both have benefits and flaws. A compelling argument can be made for each. From my perspective the principal's of Kant exemplify a more ethical way to conduct life. Utilitarianism Utilitarianism as a specific school of thought is generally credited

Utilitarianism Utilitarian Ethics Was First
Words: 1748 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Report

Today's laws consider human life the highest of all rights. Hence also the ethical difficulty relating to abortion. Although abortion might be the utilitarian course of action; the mother does not have the finances to support a baby: there is no husband; the baby will not have access to his or her basic rights as a person, the ethical viewpoint of many fundamentalists is that it simply cannot be

Utilitarianism the Philosophy of Utilitarianism
Words: 1787 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Lastly, it runs counter to the view that morality is essentially related to the concept of justice. Many critics of this theory argue that, "morality is not based on consequences of actions. Instead, it is based on the fundamental concept of justice" (Lee). In the final analysis, the dilemma in utilitarianism is that it unable to deal with a wide range of moral issue and actins and, as such, tends

Utilitarianism, Deontology, Virtue Ethics Essay: The Similarities
Words: 710 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Utilitarianism, Deontology, Virtue Ethics Ethics essay: The similarities and differences between utilitarianism, deontological ethics, and virtue ethics Utilitarianism is the philosophy that all ethical decisions must strive to do 'the greatest good for the greatest number of people.' In this ethical system, the ethical actor functions as a moral observer, dispassionately making decisions without regard to him or herself or his or her personal investment in the decision. Utilitarianism is a system

Utilitarianism As It Relates to Sports
Words: 1347 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Utilitarianism as it Relates to Sports There are many philosophies that make up the social and political structures of nations around the world. Many of these philosophies can also be applied to sports and sports related activities. The purpose of this discussion is to explore the concept of Utilitarianism. We will begin by defining the philosophy and addressing the beliefs of Utilitarians. We will then discuss how Utilitarian beliefs relate to sports. Utilitarianism Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism the Fall of Utilitarianism
Words: 1684 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

The satisfaction derived from that is by reason of good will towards the common man and not some universal pleasure felt by all men. But what about pain? Is Mills seems to be stating that happiness is the absence of pain. But is not some pain beneficial? Our reaction to spoiled milk that prevents us from drinking it for example. Wait, perhaps there are levels of pain that need to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now