Verified Document

Universal Healthcare The Pros And Thesis

Doctors who are not paid based on their quality may be more likely to perform at a lower quality, some hypothesize. This argument is also used to support the fact that having national health insurance may dissuade those who would be good doctors from going into the medical field, as they may opt for better paying positions. Paying doctors, and healthcare workers as a whole, is another major issue that those opposed to universal healthcare site. They wonder how the economy can support such a policy, believing that it will be paid for by a hike in taxes, so that the benefit from universal healthcare will be overshadowed by the literal cost. John O'Shea, a practicing general surgeon and a prominent conservative, takes this view. He argues that government-run health care is inefficient, and that people have to wait for a long amount of time before they can receive the benefits that they need (para. 1). The problem of the wait time has been one of the most used attacks against universal health care, as some wonder whether health insurance would matter at all if one has to wait a great deal of time for it. In addition, O'Shea argues that a better answer would be to use the government to subsidize low-income healthcare, but still allow low-income persons to make decisions regarding where they will go for care. O'Shea argues that "the fundamental flaw un universal health-care systems is a misplacement of incentives" (para. 3). This means that O'Shea believes patients and doctors, not the government, should be making decisions about...

Finally, O'Shea also argues that spending money on universal health care programs would mean raising taxes and diverting funds away from other important sectors, such as education, defense, and medical research (para. 1).
Thus, both sides in the argument regarding universal healthcare, but the American people must be considered in the debate. Recent trends have Americans favoring universal healthcare like never before. In a 2007 CBS-New York Times poll, 54% thought that the healthcare system needed fundamental changes, and 36% argued that it should be completely rebuilt. Of those surveyed, 98% believed that some change needed to be made (Roberts paras. 1-4). Although the switch to universal health care has major implications for the government, medical industry, and economic status of the country, most Americans are ready to see it happen. Further, recent trends have also seem universal health care implemented in states, or at least states that offer some kind of option to those who cannot afford health insurance. Massachusetts has a government-run healthcare system, and although the system has met criticism from conservatives like Tom Blumer, who argues that the system is failing, it was recently ranked the state with the third-best healthcare quality in the nation (Boulton para. 4). What these trends and implications suggest is that universal healthcare is an important issue that must be deeply considered before it is implemented. Still, health care plans like the ones Obama is proposing, which offer cooperation between the government and the private sector, offer a unique alternative.

Works Cited

Blumer, Tom. "Boston Globe Story Describes MA's State-Run Health Care as 'Trailblazing' As Its Problems Deepen; Will OBC/ABC Notice?" News Busters. 24 June 2009. 27 June 2009.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Blumer, Tom. "Boston Globe Story Describes MA's State-Run Health Care as 'Trailblazing' As Its Problems Deepen; Will OBC/ABC Notice?" News Busters. 24 June 2009. 27 June 2009. <http://newsbusters.org/blogs/tom-blumer/2009/06/24/boston-globe-story-describes-mas-state-run-health-care-trailblazing-its

Boulton, Guy. "State ranks first in health care quality." Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. 26

June 2009. 27 June 2009. <http://www.jsonline.com/business/49290287.html>

Messerli, Joe. "Should the Government Provide Universal Healthcare for All
Americans?" Balanced Politics. 25 March 2009. 27 June 2009. <http://www.balancedpolitics.org/universal_health_care.htm>
Against." My Family Doctor Magazine. 2009. 27 June 2009. <http://familydoctormag.com/doctors-office/194-doctors-debate-universal-health-care-pros-and-cons-from-the-experts.html>
<http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/03/01/opinion/polls/main2528357.shtml>
Whelan, Patrick. "Doctors Debate Universal Healthcare: Pros and Cons from the Experts: For." My Family Doctor Magazine. 2009. 27 June 2009. <http://familydoctormag.com/doctors-office/194-doctors-debate-universal-health-care-pros-and-cons-from-the-experts.html>
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Universal Healthcare Pros and Cons
Words: 648 Length: 2 Document Type: Discussion Essay

Discussion Board 5Question 1: Discuss whether the presence of therapeutic misconceptions impacts the internal validity of a medical research study, that is, the extent to which no other variables other than the ones being studied contributed to the result.Therapeutic misconception could, in basic terms, be conceptualized as patient belief that decisions made in relation to the study in which they participate in are meant to benefit them and are tailored

Universal Health Care - Literature Review Universal
Words: 2158 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Universal Health Care - Literature Review Universal Health Care Universal health care is a hot-button topic for many people, especially since "Obamacare" was passed into law. However, there has been some discussion of a health care bill of some kind for the United States for many years before President Obama took office. The debate is nothing new, but there are two sides to the issue - both of which are very significant

Universal Health Care System Also Termed As
Words: 4965 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

Universal health care system also termed as single-payer system in intended for all individuals irrespective of their financial standing. No procedure is considered perfect for the universal or single healthcare system. Several nations are adopting various procedures for attaining the objective of providing insurance facilities to its individuals. Soviet Union is considered as the premier nation engaged in guaranteeing the system of universal health care to its citizens. After prolonged

Universal Healthcare
Words: 1290 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Universal healthcare is certainly an intriguing prospect. There are a number of proponents for this form of healthcare and, within the United States, at least, perhaps an equal (as well as equally vociferous) amount of dissidents. Nonetheless, universal healthcare is a reality throughout Europe. In North America, it has long been implemented in Canada with effective results and little reason for disparagement. When one considers these two examples, as well

Universal Health Care in the U.S. There
Words: 963 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

universal health care in the U.S. There are numerous compelling arguments in favor of establishing universal health care access in the U.S.; this essay surveys the literature on this topic and presents these arguments. Providing universal health care would benefit the country as a whole. According to Reuters, Harvard Medical School researchers found that each year nearly 45,000 people, or one every 12 minutes, die because they cannot get medical

Universal Healthcare Be Implemented As
Words: 1927 Length: 7 Document Type: Thesis

(Universal Healthcare: The Debate Rages On, 2009) The solution must be one that is more than just an effort to attempt to imitate the system of Europe but instead must be, as cited in this specific report, one that "...undergoes a radical change - beginning with the medical schools..." (Universal Healthcare: The Debate Rages On, 2009) Indeed, it appears that a fundamental change is the only method of change that

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now