Verified Document

Unfunded Mandates Term Paper

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 was designed to keep the federal government from imposing expensive mandates on states and local governments without paying for them. In part, it requires federal agencies to prepare a written analysis of any especially costly mandates handed down to State, local or tribal governments. Unfunded mandates or regulatory burdens.

Unfunded mandates are handed down from the federal Government to states. More often than not the mandate is not what the state needs or wants. An example of an unfunded mandate regards a general aviation airport in Morristown, New Jersey. The airport tried to get permission to trim or remove trees, which were blocking the air traffic controller's view of the taxiways and the final approach. Of course, this was impacting safety at the airport.

The State environmental people said the airport was not allowed to trim the trees because the trees were located in a wetland. As hard as that is to believe, that kind of thing goes on. The State's environmental people said the solution was to move the tower, which would have cost several millions of dollars. Finally, after many months of fighting back and forth, the airport was allowed to cut down a few trees, but the whole process went on for over a year and cost the airport thousands of dollars. The airport director was told that rather than trim the treetops perhaps a new control tower should be built. It didn't seem to make much sense to us. In addition to environmental mandates, the Federal Government has imposed a number of security mandates imposed on airports.

This is just an example of the kind of over regulation and the bizarre guidelines that are laid on the airports, and for that matter on the various levels of both government and the private sector through unfunded mandates.

There are additional examples such as compliance with environmental regulations. Compliance costs run millions of dollars a year. For many airports, especially the smaller airports, these costs can be staggering. In addition to the costs airports are oftentimes frustrated by the lack of coordination between various arms of government. This is particularly true when it comes to balancing out safety mandates...

Federal aviation regulation part 77 requires airports to insure that there are no obstructions in the clear zones of a runway approach.
Again, another example, security access. Several years ago in response to an incident where a disgruntled former airline employee was able to gain access to an aircraft with a weapon, the government required that access to commercial aircraft be significantly tightened. The FAA estimated that compliance costs for the industry would be approximately a hundred million dollars, but the industry has already spent over $800 million in complying with that mandate.

Although some airports were able to use AIP funds to help with those installation costs, the yearly operations and maintenance costs of those systems are very expensive and are not eligible for Federal funding. In addition, at many airports AIP funds were committed for other capacity or safety-related items and there were not sufficient funds to allow the airport to utilize AIP money for the installation of this security access system.

Let me conclude with a certification example. In response to the recent commuter aircraft crashes the FAA, as we understand it, is prepared to send Congress legislation to require full part 139 compliance certification for all airports with scheduled air carrier service with 10 or more seats. The current law requires this for airports with carrier service of 30 or more seats.

Most airports in the country fall into this category. This would require some of the smallest airports in the country to purchase additional expensive equipment and add personnel at their airports. This would be extremely costly, particularly the personnel costs which are not eligible for Federal funding. Presumably the acquisition of fire trucks and other related safety equipment would be eligible, but the ongoing operating costs are staggering.

Furthermore, there is no accident or incident evidence to suggest that the recent commuter aircraft problems have had anything to do with the certification status of the airport. Additional mandatory regulations, particularly those without a Federal funding mechanism, are not the answer.

Like IBM's…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Eliza Newlin Carney, National Journal, Counter devolution, April 13, 1998

Special to The Washington Post, Wednesday, March 27, 2002; Page C01

Heritage Compilation http://www.heritage.org/Research/GovernmentReform
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Unfunded Mandate of NCLB and Title I
Words: 972 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Unfunded Mandate of NCLB and Title I The federal government contributes only a "relatively small share of school and district revenues" and in fact less than 10%, however, federal regulations that detail how funds are to be spent by the schools "exert a tremendous impact on school district management behavior and operations." (Center for American Progress, 2011) The Federal government contributes only a very small portion of funding for state schools however,

Unfunded Infrastructure of Canadian Municipalities
Words: 9168 Length: 33 Document Type: Term Paper

(Vander Ploeg, 2003) Key findings stated in the report of Vander Ploeg include the following: Unlike the overall indications of municipal infrastructure needs, which identify water and wastewater infrastructure as having the greatest investment needs, western cities biggest needs exist in the transportation sector. In each of the cities except Vancouver, roads, bridges, interchanges, sidewalks and public transit make up at least half of the annual infrastructure deficit; This may be related

Intergovernmental Relations Unfunded Federal Mandates:
Words: 1955 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

Still, state and local governments must realize that unfunded mandates will still occur, and when that happens, federal resources must be made available to state and local governments in order to help them make responsible financial decisions. Thus, an advisory board should be put into place to assist state and local governments in dealing with unfunded federal mandates as a further bridge in the communication gap between these two

Mandates and the Governments That Impose Them
Words: 706 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

NCLB Mandates And The Governments That Impose Them No Child Left Behind (NCLB): The fiscal and budgetary impact on public organizations Traditionally, public education has been left to the governance of state and local authorities. However, in creating the mandate of No Child Left Behind (NCLB), the federal government extended unprecedented authority over the ability of states to set minimal standards for student achievement and what was considered a failing school. Although not

Ernest Hemingway's Big Two-Hearted River
Words: 1478 Length: 4 Document Type: Literature Review

A 2002 research study determined that of 16 desirable character traits, JROTC students enrolled in an Atlanta public high school consistently displayed more of these traits and the behaviors associated with them than their counterparts who were not in the program (Bulach, 2002, p. 561). Behaviors included controlling oneself when one needs to, taking things that belong to others, and using drugs and alcohol. This sort of discipline is

HPV Is the Number One Sexually Transmitted
Words: 2000 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

HPV is the number one sexually transmitted disease in the U.S. The disease which used to be thought of as innocuous but annoying, which causes the growth of genital warts and other anomalies, has since been linked to abnormal tissue growth in the cervical area causing dysplasia and potentially cervical cancer among millions of women. The viral infection and more specifically HPV viral infection with one of only a few

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now