When Carlos Ghosn was appointed chief operating officer of Nissan in 1999 in an effort to turn the company’s fortunes around, he was face with several significant problems, including a weak distribution network, declining sales, inefficient production methods, inordinately high purchase costs and poor design decisions, all of which combined to create a complex situation that demanded complex solutions. To determine how Ghosn succeeded where his predecessors had failed, this paper provides a review of the relevant literature concerning the successful turnaround at Nissan that was engineered by Ghosn followed by a summary of the research and important findings about the organizational behavior and leadership practices necessary to implement changes in the conclusion.
An overview of the case
Despite manufacturing well-performing vehicles, Nissan was faced with bankruptcy in 1999 following 8 successive years of declining sales and profits. This situation was the cumulative result of several suboptimal practices, including paying higher prices for its purchases than the industry average, unused production capacity, poor vehicle design, and a weak distribution network. Moreover, Nissan’s executive leadership team had failed to address these issues, allowing them to become actual threats to the viability of the company.
Describe the conditions that led to merger with Renault
In response to Nissan’s predicament, Renault’s management team agreed to step in and help Nissan resolve the numerous problems that were adversely affecting its ability to compete by assigning Carlos Ghosn as Nissan’s chief operating officer.
Identify and discuss the driving and resisting forces for change at Nissan in 1999
The overarching sources for the resistance to change at Nissan were the Japanese cultural forces at work that influenced Nissan’s human resource practices as well as the manner in which the company sourced its purchasing needs and its distribution network as discussed further below.
Describe were the cultural challenges Ghosn faced
With a Brazilian-Lebanese-French heritage, Ghosn was clearly out of his cultural element when he assumed the chief operating officer position at Nissan in 1999. For instance, Gold and Hirano (2001) point out that
The former Michelin and Renault executive, best known for his cost-cutting skills, is trying to do more than restructure a respected but money-losing industrial giant. He is doing so in Japan, where social convention limits his flexibility in making big, fast cost reductions. Moreover, he is a foreigner, one of the few to lead a Japanese company” (p. 95)
Not surprisingly, Ghosn assignment to Nissan was initially met with skepticism and derision by many stakeholders, including most especially Nissan employees who viewed the new corporate leader as an outsider who could not comprehend the subtleties of Japanese society. By 2003, though, those attitudes had changed due to the consistency of Ghosn leadership and his success in turning Nissan around. As Pesek (2003) points out, “In 1999,...
References
Gold, A. R. & Hirano, M. (2001, Winter). An outsider takes on Japan. The McKinsey Quarterly, 93.
Lalanne, B. (2003, Spring). Samurai man: EBF talks to Carlos Ghosn, Nissan President and CEO. European Business Forum, 13, 84-86.
Pesek, W. (2003, May). Will Ghosn leave Nissan with a local? Business Asia, 11(4), 4.
Spitzer, D. R. (2007). Transforming performance measurement: Rethinking the way we measure and drive organizational success. New York: AMACOM.
Wolfram, H. J. & Mohr,G. (2009, February). Transformational leadership, team goal Fulfillment, and follower work satisfaction: The moderating effects of deep-level similarity in leadership dyads. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 15(3), 260-266.
Although Carlos Ghosn's leadership abilities cannot be contested, there are certain aspects that must be taken into consideration when analyzing his leadership style. He is considered a successful leader, given the results reported by Nissan and Renault and the recognition pachieved from his peers. However, the democratic and laissez-faire style imposed by Ghosn can lead to negative effects on medium term and on long-term. This is because this relaxed attitude
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now