Verified Document

Truth In Sentencing Efficacy Truth In Sentencing Research Proposal

Truth in Sentencing Efficacy Truth in Sentencing Research Proposal

Researchers who study the economics of crime are interested in whether specific anti-crime legislation or initiatives can increase the 'cost' of committing criminal acts, thereby reducing crime rates (reviewed by Ross, 2012). The basic premise is that most criminals will use a rational process when deciding when and where to offend and that effective anti-crime efforts will displace criminal activity. For example, implementing Lo-Jack tracking in some states in Mexico caused a shift in car theft to neighboring states lacking Lo-Jack tracking services. In the U.S., the implementation of a 'three-strikes' law in California shifted the criminal activity of offenders with one or two offenses already on record to neighboring states. By comparison, increasing the number of police officers patrolling the streets had little impact on the geographic distribution of criminal activity.

Amanda Ross (2012) examined the impact of truth-in-sentencing (TIS) laws on the geographic distribution of criminal activity within the United States. TIS laws generally minimize or eliminate probation and other considerations that effectively reduce the amount of time an offender spends in prison. The goal is to make sentencing...

When Ross looked at crime distributions after TIS laws were enacted by state legislatures throughout the 1990s, she found that TIS laws had shifted the geographic distribution of crime away from TIS states.
Ross's (2012) research was based on 59 urban municipalities that crossed state lines, thereby eliminating many potential confounding factors. Overall, the municipality located in the TIS state experienced an average crime reduction of 8.7% and the neighboring non-TIS municipality experienced an 8.6% increase in crime. When both states enacted a TIS law then both municipalities experienced an average crime reduction of 14.9%. Rather than simply rest on these results, Ross validated these finding by showing an inverse relationship between crime rates and police expenditures locally.

The findings of Ross suggest that TIS laws represent a cost-effective means for reducing criminal activity, especially when both states enact TIS laws. What Ross ignores is whether TIS laws also increased spending on state corrections due to a geographic shift in criminal activity and longer sentences (reviewed by…

Sources used in this document:
References

Ortega, Bob. (2011, Oct. 9). Arizona prison sentences among toughest for many crimes. The Arizona Republic. Retrieved 5 Oct. 2013 from http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2011/10/09/20111009arizona-prison-tough-sentencing.html.

Ross, Amanda. (2012). Crime, police, and truth-in-sentencing: The impact of state sentencing policy on local communities. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 42, 144-152.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Prison Reduction of Prison Population Current Impact
Words: 5174 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Prison Reduction of Prison Population Current impact Population affected Government Policies. Effectiveness of Policies Efficacy of the strategies This paper highlights the prison system and relates multiple factors to it. It gives a brief background of the topic and then describes the U.S. crises of prison system. In addition to this, it highlights various factors related to the prison population of Indiana. After that, this paper focuses on the present situation of the prison system and then

Evidence in General Reciprocal Discovery
Words: 1386 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Mirfield 356) The purpose of the exclusionary rule is to afford the defendant all his or her rights of privacy and to maintain fair proceedings in the gathering of evidence. Unlawful search and seizure is a serious offence, committed by investigators and regardless of the value of the evidence recovered there is no clear acceptance of the principle as a tactic in a "fair" proceeding. If the police and/or prosecution was

Criminology the Beginnings of Criminology
Words: 2905 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

VI. DURKHEIM'S ANOMIE Another theory in criminology is known as 'Durkheim's Anomie' which was conceived by Emile Durkheim, a French sociologist who first introduced the anomie in the work entitled: "The Division of Labor in Society" in which the anomie was utilized in provides a description of a "condition of deregulation that was occurring in society." (Criminological Theory, 2001) This anomie was used to describe how that the mores' of behavior

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for
Words: 6266 Length: 20 Document Type: Capstone Project

Criminal Justice: The Death Penalty Reasons for topic selection Causes of racial prejudice and discrimination Juvenile in delinquent society theory Culture and values Official and unofficial values The effectiveness of the death penalty The death penalty is irreversible The death penalty is barbaric Changes to the death sentence Implemented changes Sentencing guidelines Bifurcated trials Automatic appellate conviction review Proportionality review The importance of proposed changes Anticipated outcome Life imprisonment; alternative to death sentences The costs Decency standards Overall efficiency Policies in support of incarceration Conclusion References Background Despite the controversy over how effective it is

Phoenix Program Lessons to Iraq
Words: 19225 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

(MACV Dir 381-41) This document is one of the first confidential memorandums associated with the Phoenix Program, which details in 1967 the mostly U.S. involvement in counterinsurgency intelligence and activities and discusses the future training and development of South Vietnam forces to serve the same function, that had been supported by the U.S. In civilian (mostly CIA) and military roles. The document stresses that the U.S. role is to

History Plea Bargaining When 2. What
Words: 994 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

history plea bargaining? When ? 2. What recent statistics plea bargaining U.S. ( current year)? What Bargaining With Pleas The history of plea bargaining can be traced back to the end of the colonial era in the United States. Plea bargaining was known to exist in this country since at least 1780, a fact that is corroborated by author George Fisher. Fisher dedicated a significant amount of research to the history

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now