Verified Document

Troops The Words 'Support Our Troops' Are Essay

¶ … Troops The words 'support our troops' are frequently said as a matter of routine, according to Roger Stahl's article entitled "Why We Support the Troops." The phrase has been used by supporters of American armed conflicts on the right to covertly suggest that they, and not the war's opponents, are 'for' the young men and women risking their lives to serve America abroad. Members of the left in recent years have likewise adopted the phrase to suggest that they support the troops, even if they do not support the war. Yet Stahl says that "such rhetoric ultimately works to foreclose debate rather than encourage its citizens and representatives to engage directly the reasons for killing, whether they are right or wrong, legal or illegal, effective or ineffective" (Stahl 535) [CENTRAL ARGUMENT]. It reduces the debate about war to a matter of who 'supports the troops' the most, rather than the real reasons that killing is going on abroad.

Focus was placed upon getting POWs home rather than ending the war together by the executive branch. Eventually this ideology progressed to the development of what Stahl calls the "anti-war, pro-soldier" film in which war is shown to be ugly, but individual soldiers are shown to be noble (Stahl 539). The fact that such films as Saving Private Ryan garnered the support of the Pentagon shows the subversively, subtly anti-intellectual message of nobility hidden between the lines of these works. It encourages identification with the soldier, as do the 'yellow ribbon' campaigns of support, which deflects criticism against the government who had the role in actually sending…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Words Under God in Pledge Allegiance in Schools
Words: 1761 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

God" in Pledge Allegiance in Schools The Alternative Would Be "One Nation Under a Flag." (Keeping our Alleigances in Order) The Pledge of Allegiance is one of the greatest symbols of our most wonderful and blessed nation. Just the mention of it stirs to mind images of young children developing an understanding of devotion as they together face the classroom flag and chant in unison, of diverse people of all colors and

Military -- Naval Support at
Words: 3000 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

[footnoteRef:32] This lack of forces for other Pacific struggles generally weakened the Japanese war effort, as the Japanese were forced to fight those battles with insufficient men, weapons, ammunition and other related materiel. [27: Eric Hammel. Guadalcanal: Decision at Sea: The Naval Battle of Guadalcanal, November 13-15, 1942. Pacifica, CA: Pacifica Military History, 1999, p. 346.] [28: Colin G. Jameson. "Battle of Guadalcanal: 11-15 November, 1942." www.history.navy.mil Web site. 1944.

Combat Supply Support Communications and
Words: 3763 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

In the 1999 report of William Cohen to the U.S. President and U.S. Congress reveals that the strategic vision sets out what the United States has on its agenda to accomplish in relation to technological and logistical strategies. Included in these strategies are modernization of intelligence processes as well as security, information operations, information assurance, and critical infrastructure protection. In a 2004 Department of Defense Submission - Joint Standing

U.S. Capability to Support Two
Words: 1658 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

Moreover, the lack of support from the American public brings to fore an issue raised by Grover (3) with the deployment of U.S. military personnel in various parts of the world. As many of these deployments have "the potential for violent conflict," this calls for "the need to respond quickly and decisively," which is hinged on the "unambiguous support of the American people." There is no other U.S. president

Media and Patriotism As Factors in Support for the Iraq Invasion
Words: 3214 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Public Opinion on the War in IraqBackgroundThe research question for this paper was: \\\"What is the public opinion over the war in Iraq during the last few administrations as well as the public opinion on the president handling in pulling troops out of Iraq.\\\" To answer this question, the Roper iPoll database was consulted, with a keyword search of �war in Iraq� from the years 2002 to 2022. Some background

American Troops
Words: 1804 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

war is often a result of conflict that arises out of major disagreement. This agreement can vary dramatically, but war does not. It results it massive casualties, deaths, ill will, and economic harm. Those who "win" a war often suffer many of the same consequences as the "loser." War, and in particular, minor battles, are largely influenced by strategy. Strategy and tactics, or lack thereof, can be the difference

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now