Verified Document

Transformative Years That Were Many Essay

Perhaps the most memorable example of the cross-pollination of ideas, however, was that of the Chinese ten-meter-tall, Styrofoam "Goddess of Democracy" in Tiananmen Square. The Chinese demonstrations openly used Western symbols and quoted Western ideologues until they were silenced by the government. As with 1789, some of the 1989 revolts were successful, some unsuccessful, but all shared certain qualities in common, according to Manning. Manning concedes that all social movements draw upon pre-existing conflicts and debates, combined with a new intensification of flaring up of such issues but both years of multiple revolutions all show a common rhetoric between nations. In 1989 the "equivalent debates included rights to self-expression, freedom from government restraint, recognition of individual rights, renunciation of racial and ethnic discrimination, and recognition of communities" and a cross-cultural language of common cause, along with a desire for great change (Manning par. 66). The common, sympathetic language was non-specific and stressed the "rights of man" or "democracy" rather than a specific grievance to self-consciously illustrate the parallels between all oppressed people (Manning par. 66-67).

An interesting question not raised by Manning is if liberalization was a facilitator of revolt against these tyrannical 1989 governments. The fall of the Berlin Wall occurred after a policy of perestroika, glasnost, and arms reduction had been allowed by the U.S.S.R., not during the time of the worst Soviet repression. Similarly, China was also liberalizing its policies in 1989, allowing a greater influx of capitalism and greater freedom than had been enjoyed by the current, younger generation than their parents. Even before the Internet revolution, in 1989, young people were exposed to far more uncontrolled and uncensored mass media, which similarly created images of the potential for change and revolt to which they could relate.

However, Manning's analysis of the 1989 revolutions' non-specificity in terms of...

Although some of the demonstrators in Eastern Europe did call for democracy, many others were far more interested in advancing their personal ethnic or regional right to self-determination. The tragic consequences of nationalism were made manifest in the former nation of Yugoslavia and other areas of the region in the 1990s. Even Manning admits that the nationalism that later broke out in 1991 in Germany was very different in spirit than the initial, idealistic rhetoric that was generated during the fall of the Berlin Wall. And even in 1989, the revolution's slogans around the world cannot be blended into one without ignoring specific differences: In China, despite the fact that the students were protesting against the oppression of a communist regime, the language used was specifically pro-U.S., pro-Western. Thomas Jefferson was frequently quoted, for example. This was not the case, however, in other protest movements in 1989, which were often pro-nationalist and regional in character in the former USSR.
Manning's belief in internationalism, that "in 1789, while communications were far slower and technology far more elementary than in 1989, patterns of inspiration, imitation, and mobilization were remarkable in the degree to which they anticipated the struggles that broke out two centuries later" and showed "alternation between local concerns and broad human identity appears, in this perspective, as a recurring pattern in human affairs" ultimately does not stand the full test of historical scrutiny. Some of his examples, such as the specific transmission of anti-slavery messages in 1789, can be traced from one region to another in their images and language. But his claim for a vaguer, more common sense of international 'revolutionary spirit' is less convincing, particularly when paralleling the very different rhetoric, experiences, and outcomes in China and Eastern Europe.

Work Cited

Manning, Patrick. "1789-1792 and 1989-1992: Global Interaction of Social Movements."…

Sources used in this document:
Work Cited

Manning, Patrick. "1789-1792 and 1989-1992: Global Interaction of Social Movements." World

History Connected. May 12, 2010.

http://worldhistoryconnected.press.illinois.edu/3.1/manning.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Transformative Art the Artists That I Have
Words: 1928 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Transformative Art The artists that I have chosen to spotlight come from three continents and different ethnicities. They are actors, musicians, lyricists, rappers, poets, and comedians. They are also revolutionaries who are using art to transform the world that they live within into a better place. Saul Williams Saul Williams is an artist with many interests and abilities; he is hard to place in a single category. Saul Williams is a poet-both written

Transformative Learning and Higher Education
Words: 838 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Accordingly, the approach taken to academics will center on the refinement of more generally applicable skill sets such as interpersonal communication, team orientation and learning through practical usage of emergent skills. Accordingly, Moore points to instances of interdisciplinary learning as the manifestation of this set of values which is increasingly seen as essential to yielding the best results from one's higher education. Accordingly, Moore indicates that "new models of

Transformative Learning Theory in the
Words: 600 Length: 2 Document Type: Article Review

He attempts to show that this concept has emerged and is slowly developing in adult education to an extent that it has attracted both researchers and practitioners in the field. Actually, the author's main goal is to provide better understanding of the complexity of transformative learning through summarizing its main theoretical views in the field of adult learning. Generally, there are several adult learning theories that basically provide insights and

Transformative Learning the Merit of
Words: 2566 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

They are also learning new ideologies that transform their perspectives and broaden their viewpoints to gain a greater sense of understanding and awareness of the values of their jobs and how they subsequently change them as people -- which is the very essence of transformative learning. The proclivity for those who are in increasingly higher levels of education, particularly those in graduate school as opposed to undergraduate school to demonstrate

Transformative Change the Four Stages of Transformational
Words: 364 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

Transformative Change The Four Stages of Transformational Change The four stages of transformational change are (1) identifying issues with current situations or processes; (2) learning new frames of reference for those situations or processes; (3) changing specific points-of-view; and (4) transforming habits of mind and practice. More particularly, those four stages consist of seven phases: (1) experiencing a specific problem or dilemma; (2) self-examination; (3) critical analysis of fundamental assumptions; (4) appreciating

Transformative Adult Education Did You
Words: 1350 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

They also focus more on institutional support, like the need for appropriate funding for such educational programs, rather than psychological issues attacked to assimilation. Changing demographics in recent years in Canada have forced adult education programs to meet the challenge of doing more with fewer resources, as they fight, for more funding for programs designed to orient immigrants in the language and culture of the area. "As new citizens

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now