Verified Document

Transformational Leadership Vs. Transactional Leadership Essay

Leadership Models in Modern Organizational Landscape Leadership Models Available in the Modern Organizational Landscape

How cultural style dictates the perception of what is ethical in a leader's use of power, influence, and authority

There are clear variations between cultures, especially in terms of behavior, attitudes, and values of individuals. The divergence affects the leadership model adopted by various organizations. Many studies have also shown that different leader behaviors and activities are understood and interpreted in a different way based on their cultural environment. As such, they are caused by differences in the ideas of an ethical leader: some styles are preferred, and others recognized as less effective. These differences exist because the significance and importance given to the concept of leadership appears to differ across cultures. With globalization and the development of organizations across national boundaries, numerous opportunities and challenges are available for leadership. Varying cultural values and beliefs calls for the greater understanding and recognition of culturally linked leadership styles. Responsiveness towards cultural sensitivities that may be drastically different from someone's own beliefs, and values is crucial for leadership efficiency (Marturano & Gosling, 2008).

Leadership styles typically developed in individual cultures signify effective leadership as an action of generating greater and better financial results. Success is always a factor of a leader's behavior in ensuring that employees perform optimally at the workplace. These styles are drawn in forms of self-interest such as networking, mentoring, and other personal initiatives that succeed in individual cultures. However, it is expected that leaders in collectivist cultures will view leadership efficiency as a long-term goal because of subordinate dedication, extra effort, and fulfillment with the leader. Furthermore, collectivist cultures prioritize the needs of the team, family and the community when engaging in leadership behaviors. Therefore, principles of mutual responsibilities require leaders to give supporters direction and protection in exchange for commitment and loyalty.

Similarly, leadership styles typically suggest a democratic view of getting leadership roles, claiming, "Anyone can get to the top." However, this concept draws from an individual viewpoint in accordance with the cultural aspect of low power distance. Small power distance...

However, in high-power distance societies, titles, social status, and positions are well-known because they determine the way others treat and behave. Thus, leaders and their employees consider each other as unequal (Marturano & Gosling, 2008). Therefore, it is expected that leadership styles in high-power distance societies will seek to show respect for age, tolerance, compromise, and agreement while creating rules for togetherness among all stakeholders.
Leadership models, styles, and traits are most commonly accepted as ethical across the greatest array of social cultures.

Transactional and transformational leadership styles are worldwide concepts. Global Leadership and Organizational Behavioral Effectiveness (GLOBE) study have found both global transformational features of ideal leadership and ones showing cultural uniqueness within and between the suggested two styles. House et al. (1999) applied the idea of culturally recommended implicit leadership concepts to list the leadership attributes and behaviors, which are "universally" recommended as leading to effective leadership, and the extent to which behaviors and attributes are linked to cultural features. Universal leadership dimensions were used to create the profile for universally accepted social clusters like gentle oriented, charismatic or value-based, independent, and self-protective.

The charismatic/value based approach contains the most number of features globally recognized as contributors to successful leadership, but the charismatic dimension, partly risk-taking is not globally accepted. The Southern Western countries, such as Russian, recommended inspirational charisma and visionary, reliability, decisiveness, performance alignment, group integrator, competent, diplomatic, team oriented as the key excellent leadership traits. The recommended components of successful leadership consist of transformational/charismatic and team-oriented leadership. The most widely accepted leaders are decisive, inspirational, and visionary. Participative leadership has substituted paternalistic leadership that was traditionally seen in Southern Western countries. Leaders with integrity are able to act collaboratively and build highly respectable teams (Marturano & Gosling, 2008).

There has been a perception that…

Sources used in this document:
References

Jenkins, H., & Purushotma, R. (2009). Confronting the challenges of participatory culture: Media education for the 21st century. Cambridge, Mass: The MIT Press.

Johansson, O., & Begley, P.T. (2013). The ethical dimensions of school leadership. Dordrecht; Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Kezar, A.J. (2011). Understanding and facilitating organizational change in the 21st century: Recent research and conceptualizations. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Kouzes, J.M., & Posner, B.Z. (2012). The leadership challenge: How to make extraordinary things happen in organizations. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Transformational Leadership in the Promotion of Ethical
Words: 2019 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Transformational Leadership in the Promotion of Ethical Climate and Practices Some researchers have argued that transformational leadership is effective in promoting ethical climate and practices in order to influence individuals' ethical behaviors in workgroups. Ethical behavior is differentially defined from one culture to another and from one organization to another and it is this difference that the transformational leader is able to convey to the organizational employees through effective means and

Transformational Leadership, a Leadership Style
Words: 2770 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

This view posits the use of power as the primary functioning aspect of leadership. This style of leadership involves aspects such as gaining trust, respect and confidence from employees and the setting of high standards of conduct, as well as motivating people to achieve their full potential. In the transactional model the following aspects predominate in this leadership style. Idealized Influence - Gaining trust, respect and confidence; setting high standards of

Transformational Leadership Theory, According to
Words: 1273 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

They use a clear punishment and reward structure to get individuals to obey their instructions. Applying transactional leadership to Mr. Manager shows clear correlations. There are clearly defined punishments in relations to how professionals and para-professionals operate within this field. Those who do not follow protocol that results in the injury and accident of an MR/DD patient will be subject to termination, suspension, and other severe consequences. Mr. Manager

Transformational Vs. Transactional Leadership Theory
Words: 1534 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

Transactional and Transformational Leadership in Healthcare Assessing Transformational vs. Transactional Leadership During IT Implementations Transactional and Transformational Leadership in Healthcare: Assessing Transformational vs. Transactional Leadership During IT Implementations Healthcare organizations often are the most resistant to new technologies and systems that could paradoxically streamline their professions, making them more effective, productive and creating new career opportunities. Yet from personal experience it is clear that healthcare professionals, including physicians, laboratory technicians and nurses at times resist new

Transformational Leadership Analysis Leadership and Change Management...
Words: 1464 Length: 5 Document Type: SWOT

Transformational Leadership Analysis Leadership and Change Management Research Transformational Leadership Traits Situation Analysis Whitman Model Jobs Model Leadership and Change Management Research The following analysis has been conducted with perspective of transformational leadership and change management in mind. Furthermore, benchmarks were gathered for the situation faced by Janet Angelo as the Executive Vice President of Marketing and Sales at Intersect Investment Services. Janet was originally selected for her expertise in executing a "Customer Intimacy" model at two

Transformational Leadership and Transactional Leadership
Words: 1592 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Transactional Leadership and Transformational Leadership Transactional leadership style is a leadership style that uses group performance, organization, and supervision to get results. It is also called managerial leadership. This leadership style is focused on getting specific tasks done and the leader may use punishments and rewards as motivational tools. A good structure is highly valued in such a scenario as is highly apparent in situations such as the military and big

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now