Verified Document

Trait Theory The Central Premise In The Essay

Trait Theory The central premise in the argument that leaders tend to be taller than followers is based on a logical fallacy concerning the nature of trait theory and leadership in general. Leadership theory focuses on what makes leaders effective, not the characteristics that put people into a leadership position in the first place. This essay will break down the argument for trait theory, why trait theory fell out of favor and why the point about leaders' height is irrelevant to the entire argument.

Trait theory is based on the assumptions that people are born with inherent traits, and that many of those traits are suited to leadership -- those who make good leaders are those with the right combination of traits in the right amount (ChangingMinds.org, 2011). In general, trait theory was based on personality traits as opposed to physical -- adaptability, assertiveness, decisiveness, self-confident, tolerant of stress, intelligence and creativity to name a few (Ibid). These traits were derived primarily in observational studies of successful leaders. Unsuccessful leaders were generally not...

These theories were similar, but focused on the behaviors exhibited by leaders (outputs) rather than the underlying traits of the leaders (inputs). Over time, it became apparent that leadership is something that can be exhibited in a wide range of situations, and successful leaders can take different forms (Doyle & Smith, 2009). Contingency theory emerged as the role of context became better understood, and as society began to accept a wider range of leadership styles beyond the traditional industrial/military archetypes that dominated in the early 20th century. By the 1970s, it became apparent that effective leaders were successful largely because they adapted their style to fit the situation -- and leaders who were effective under some circumstances could not be counted on to be effective in other circumstances. An example of this would be the visionary leadership needed to transform an entity vs. The leadership needed to drive complex micro-actions that sustain the entity. Consider the relative effectiveness of Lech Walesa or Nelson Mandela in the transformation process (very high) with their effectiveness as a transactional leader in the post-transformation period (moderate). As with trait theory, behavior theory and contingency theory both focused on what made leaders successful.
What was never a part of leadership theory is the concept of how people become leaders, especially in politics. Followers may well be attracted to height, but being voted into a leadership position is not the same thing as being a successful leader. There is no shortage of unsuccessful elected officials. Further, height was never considered by the early trait theorists, so there is little if any documentation to back up any theory about height being correlated with leadership success. There are tenuous connections that can be drawn between, say, height and confidence (Case & Paxson, 2008) or other such traits that were considered important, but evidence…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Bolden, R.; Gosling, J.; Marturano, A. & Dennison, P. (2003). A review of leadership theory and competency frameworks. Centre for Leadership Studies, University of Exeter. Retrieved January 29, 2011 from http://www2.fcsh.unl.pt/apsociedade/Lideran%C3%A7a.pdf

Case, A. & Paxson, C. (2008). Stature and status: Height, ability and labor market outcomes. Journal of Political Economy. Vol. 116 (3) 499-532.

ChangingMinds.org. (2011). Trait theory. Changing Minds.org. Retrieved January 29, 2011 from http://changingminds.org/disciplines/leadership/theories/trait_theory.htm

Doyle, M. & Smith, M. (2009). Classical leadership. InFed. Retrieved January 29, 2011 from http://www.infed.org/leadership/traditional_leadership.htm
No author. (2011). Trait theory of leadership. Management Study Guide. Retrieved January 29, 2001 from http://www.managementstudyguide.com/trait-theory-of-leadership.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Learning Theories to the Current Educational Environment
Words: 2351 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Learning Theories to Current Education In psychology and education, learning is normally described as a process that brings together cognitive, emotional, and influences of the environment being experienced for obtaining, enhancing, or enacting changes in an individual knowledge, values, skills, and views of the world. Learning as a process put their center of attention on what takes place during learning. Explanations of what takes place forms learning theories. A learning theory

Leadership Theory in a Changing and Globalizing
Words: 5806 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Leadership Theory in a Changing and Globalizing Marketplace Modern business practice is permeated by the complexities of a changing world. The impact of globalization on the cultural makeup of companies, the effects of the global recession on the conventions of daily business and the evolutionary shifts brought on by emergent technology all call for an orientation toward simultaneous stability and adaptability. Only under the stewardship of a qualified, communicative, flexible and

Criminological Theories and How They Apply to a Fictional Characters...
Words: 4431 Length: 13 Document Type: Essay

Criminological Theories and Their Application Character History Nikita Voronov was born in Omsk, Russia in 1977 to a 17-year-old mother named Natasha Voronov. She had gotten pregnant with him after dating a man for one month, another Russian male who was working in the mining area at the time. Once Natasha became pregnant she never saw the father of her child again who fled the town. Desiring a better life for her

Object Relation, Attachment Theories, And
Words: 26278 Length: 90 Document Type: Dissertation

S., experts estimate the genuine number of incidents of abuse and neglect ranges three times higher than reported. (National Child Abuse Statistics, 2006) in light of these critical contemporary concerns for youth, this researcher chose to document the application of Object Relation, Attachment Theories, and Self-Psychology to clinical practice, specifically focusing on a patient who experienced abuse when a child. Consequently, this researcher contends this clinical case study dissertation proves

Social Cognitive Theory Sct Was
Words: 944 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

The individual component of personal identity is represented in the older, early acquired traits (Cerulo, 1997). In a given time and social situation, certain components of personality are mobilized in action, while other components are temporarily subordinated. With a change in time and group situation, a shift of emotional integration occurs with a corresponding shift of integration into another social role; that is, other components of the self are moved

Magic Bullet Theory
Words: 3545 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

magic bullet theory" -- sometimes called the hypodermic needle theory -- holds that when recipients of broadcasted information are separated from one another they are extremely susceptible to the messages that they are receiving; theses messages can drastically influence their opinions as well as their perceptions of reality. "Agenda setting scholars corroborate the fact that our dependence on the media for news and information has shaped and reinforced our

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now