Traffic Stop Case
Did Officer Smith have reasonable suspicion to make the initial stop of this vehicle?
As we examine this case and more confrontational moments occur between the officer and the suspect, all events remain in question largely on the basis of this initial question. This is because ultimately, it was revealed by due process that the basic cause for the traffic stop was a suspected broken taillight which was ultimately in proper working order. This denotes that probable cause may not have existed to justify the encounter between the officer and the suspect. That said, 'probable cause' is a higher standard than that required for a routine traffic stop absent the intent for a search of the suspect or vehicle. Here, reasonable suspicion is sufficient, though given the working condition of the taillight, it is not certain that this necessary existed either. According to Tennessee v Brother (2010), a similar case involving a search and seizure which was preempted by a broken taillight offers reason to believe that the officer in this case did not have a legal right to pull the suspect over. According to Baker Associates (2010), in Tennessee v. Brotherton, it was incumbent upon the court to determine "if a police officer had reasonable suspicion to stop the defendant's vehicle based on the fact that the taillight was not in "good condition" because it was projecting a glaring or dazzling light. In this case, the defendant had broken the taillight and attempted to repair it with red repair tape. The intermediate appellate court held that the taillight was in proper working condition in that it provided proper warning and
1) Using this as our basis, we may deduce that the officer in question, though acting on a good-faith assumption that a taillight was broken, may not have had cause for 'reasonable suspicion' sufficient to justify the traffic stop. That said, the case does not articulate exactly what conditions caused the officer to mistake a functional taillight for a broken one and further examination may find that while not broken, the taillight was altered sufficiently that 'reasonable suspicion' was present to justify the traffic stop.
2.Was the "pat-down" of the driver legal?
Putting aside the discrepancy over the state of the suspect's taillight, we consider the question of the 'pat-down.' Here, the officer determines to frisk the suspect because her car is consistent with the description of one recently involved in the roadside murder of a fellow officer. It is thus that the officer determines she must, for reasons of her own safety, take this precautionary step. According to the case of Terry v. Ohio, 'reasonable suspicion' is the basic threshold for pat-downs as well. Here, our findings denote that "generally, law enforcement officers will perform frisks at their discretion, regardless of the 'reasonable suspicion' standard…
Officer Smith have reasonable suspicion to make the initial stop of this vehicle? As per the facts of the case, Officer Smith was informed of a car of the similar make and color which was involved in the killing of a police officer. The impugned car seems at first sight to have a broken taillight which appears to be covered with color tape. Since the officer feels that the make
Reasonable Suspicion and 4th Amendment Law in U.S. v. Arvizu, 534 U.S. 266 (2001) Title and Citation: U.S. v. Arvizu, 534 U.S. 266 (2001) Type of Action: Review by the U.S. Supreme Court of a ruling made by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which held that evidence should be suppressed as a result of a violation of the Fourth Amendment right to privacy and protection from unwarranted and
Human Trafficking: Comparative Analysis of Human Trafficking in the United States with the World Stephanie I. Specialized Field Project Human Trafficking is a very serious issue that affects every country around the world. Human Trafficking is also known as "Sex Trafficking," or "Modern Day Slavery," which reflects the primary reasons people are bought and sold today -- sex trade and involuntary labor. The Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000 (TVPA) defines sex trafficking as "the
It became apparent that we have a serious problem in this country and that this problem could undermine attempts to build bridges between different cultural groups. It became an issue at the forefront of law enforcement management. The Roots of Racial Profiling Police officers used to be trained to view people of different cultural background as potential suspects for deportation. It went so far that in 1972 taxi drivers in California
Indianapolis vs. Edmond 531 U.S. 32, 121S. ct.447, 148 L. Ed. 2D 333(2000) Facts: In an attempt to discover and intercept unlawful narcotics on transit across the city, Indianapolis police implemented a highway checkpoint program, where motorists would be stopped at designated checkpoints, and their vehicles searched for narcotics. The checks lasted no more than five minutes and involved both an open-view examination, and a sniffer dog program. Two motorists, one of
Air traffic has continued to increase and it now constitutes a considerable proportion of the travelling public. The amount of long-hour flights has increased significantly. Based on the International Civil Aviation authority, air traffic can be anticipated to double amid till 2020. Airline travel, especially over longer distances, makes air travelers vulnerable to numerous facets that will impact their health and well-being. Particularly, the speed with which influenza spreads and
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now