Verified Document

Torture Can Be Simply Explained Essay

The dilemma lies herein: neither of the two approaches is entirely wrong.

The former, seemingly more humane, also seems impractical considering the fact that the overall dangers that hover the world today in the form of weaponry available and tactics designed are far advanced and devastating than anything else that has been witnessed in history. Its impracticality lies in its overlooking the gravity of an attack and in how torture at the right time and towards the right link could prove to be the difference between mass destruction and liberty. The fact is that this idea cannot stand firm for long in the face of the dangers and perils that can be caused today.

The latter approach, seemingly harsh, also seems ignorant of the fact that terrorism or war is not restricted to any race, religion or nation. Since the beginning of time, every nation has looked for supremacy in the world and planned for it accordingly. Yes, the current methodologies are more disaster-prone but that only confirms that there isn't one single nation that cannot have its intelligence designers, or soldiers, captured and tortured for information that could "potentially save millions" including American intelligence designers and soldiers. The latter belief seems to project that the American intelligence only has reactionary plans while that is not only naive to believe and hypocritical to project.

The facts, in the 21st century, are these: the economic state of a nation (agricultural, industrialized, capitalized, urbanized, etc.) is one of the main factors that determine their approach towards their overall policies on torture. History has shown that it is usually authoritarian governments who have been recorded to have the most extensive...

Comparatively, the governments that promote democracy that initiate and apply the extreme conditions of torture on not only their enemies but also their own citizens in circumstances of civil wars or internal clashes. One of the main indicators of the torture laws or policies that a government makes is dependent upon the balance between the economic state of the country and the nature of its government.
Conclusion:

Throughout the thesis above, the two ideologies towards the use of torture as a tool of war or strategy have been discussed under logical lights. One ideology condemns the use of torture under any circumstances by arguing that torture is an inhumane practice and is against the basic human rights that every person has. Furthermore, this ideology also points out that using torture as a strategy against one's enemies is an automatic permit for the enemies to use torture as a strategy as well. The other ideology is far harsher but more practical as it condones and even promotes torture in extreme and do-or-die circumstances where the action is clearly to save innocent lives by torturing a criminal mastermind or puppet.

The key, when it comes to torture in the modern world, lies in the balance of the two strategies. Since the War on Terror, there has been a deficiency in any form of balance. Initially there was an extensive use of torture tactics by the Bush administration to punish the terrorists and extract information from them which has been a direct circumstance of the approach of the two current presidential candidates, McCain and Obama, to have a no-torture policy. Neither is wrong and neither is right. Torture, even though, is a devastating tool but it is perhaps the most effective tool available to fight off mass killings and persecutions of innocents if used intelligently and circumstantially.

Sources used in this document:
References:

Corrado, Raymond R., and Cohen, Irwin M. State Torture in the Contemporary World. International Journal of Comparative Sociology. Volume: 46: 1-2. 2005. 103.

Krauthammer, Charles., the Truth about Torture-it's time to be honest about doing terrible things. The Weekly Standard. 11. 12. 2005.

McCain, John. Torture's Terrible Toll. Newsweek. 2005.

Torture -
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Torture and Interrogation Essay
Words: 6804 Length: Document Type: Essays

The Rationale for and the Efficacy of Torture during Interrogation Although information from interrogational torture is unreliable, it is likely to be used frequently and harshly. ==John W. Schiemann, 2012 Introduction The epigraph above is indicative of the growing consensus concerning the lack of efficacy of torture in providing interrogators with reliable concealed information Concealed information is the foundation of the majority of security issues. In most cases, concealed information is a situation

Tortured Loneliness of Robert Lowell's
Words: 581 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The skunks are a potent contrast between the gentility symbolized by the millionaire's casually auctioned-off yacht, yet like the auctioned boat, they are also a symbol of waste and decay. The skunks' willingness to eat anything is also a contrast with the poet's deeper sense of existential dread and sorrow about his plight, as he sadly listens to "Love, O careless Love...." On the radio, symbolizing his inability to

International Law V Torture in
Words: 7379 Length: 25 Document Type: Thesis

S. Congress 2006). Under a military commission's procedures and rules of evidence, the accused may present evidence, cross examine witnesses against him, and respond to evidence presented against him; attend all the sessions of the trial; and have the rights to counsel and self-representation. The bill does not grant him the right to see all the evidence against him to establish his guilt or innocence. It authorizes the Secretary to

Financial Crisis a Crisis of Capitalism Compare
Words: 3172 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

financial crisis a "crisis of capitalism? Compare and contrast the theories of Susan Strange, Karl Polanyi and Giovanni Arrighi. Explain how three of them accessed issues of Financial crisis and its relationship with capitalism Starting from 2008 onwards, we are currently experiencing an unremitting state of economic recession. Each of the three theorists stated in this essay have different perspectives of whether or not the recession indicates crises of capitalism. Whilst

Legislation, Jeremy Bentham Outlines His
Words: 1686 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Thus, as this initial object is almost impossible to fully achieve, Bentham argues that the subordinate goals of any given justice system should be "if a man must needs to commit an offence of some kind or other […] to induce him […] to choose always the least mischievous of two offences that will either of them suit his purpose," "to dispose him to do no more misheif than

Ayer on the Nature of Ethical Judgments
Words: 1222 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Ayer on the Nature of Ethical Judgments Ayer makes a truly original and remarkable statement about moral judgments and ethical judgments which some scholars have summarized as a phenomenon called emotivism. Within this theory, there is the belief that moral judgments aren't necessarily truthful; they're an expression of sentiments of approval or disapproval (Ayer). Thus, according to this construct saying something like murder, stealing, lying or cheating is "wrong" merely expresses

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now