Verified Document

Tom Shulich "Coltishhum" Literature Review And Synthesis Essay

Tom Shulich ("ColtishHum") Literature Review and Synthesis of Research on Time Management

Psychologists have conducted research into the effectiveness of various time management techniques for organizing work and personal life. Time management is also a popular topic for self-help books, PowerPoint presentations, and instructional web videos (for example, Allen, 2001; Mann, 2007; McGhee, 2005; Spidal, 2009). The untested assertions found in some of the practical manuals provide testable hypotheses that psychologists can investigate empirically using controlled samples and statistical models. These researchers have found some of the popularly promoted time-management advice to be supported by the research, and other recommendations to be of questionable value.

In this essay, I will compare, contrast and synthesize information presented in the three publications on time management: Bruce K. Britton and Abraham Tesser (1991), Therese Hoff Macan (1994), and Debra Spidal (2009). Each of these authors approaches the problem from different angles. Together their work covers different populations and applies different models of time management. In the end, all of the authors considered here are advocates of using time management techniques to improve work efficiency, perform better in school, or enhance a subjective sense of confidence and self-efficacy.

Assertions

Two of the articles -- the Britton and Tesser study and the Macan study -- present empirical evidence for the value of time management, testing the outcomes on populations which had either attended time-management seminars or scored high on time-management inventories. The third article by Spidal is not a statistical study that compares control groups, but instead offers practical advice for individual self-assessment and application of one's findings to improve personal time-management.

Britton and Tesser focused their investigation on college students. They proposed that differences in time-management habits among students account for significant differences in their performance in college, as measured by grade point average (GPA).

Macan also ran statistical tests on comparable populations to look for practical outcomes resulting from different styles of time management. Rather than testing college students, Macan's research focused on adults employed at two government agencies -- a correctional facility and a public social service agency. She was able to compare a sample group of workers at these agencies who had received time-management training to a control group of coworkers those who had not benefited from the training. She found that time-management training did have beneficial effects for reducing tension in the workplace, but not for increasing efficiency.

Spidal's article can be seen as the practical application of the kinds of time-management techniques the other two studies found effective. Spidal elaborates on methods for self-evaluation relevant to improving personal time management. She proposes that these techniques will benefit anyone who has goals, helping people get down to the business of identifying time-wasters and organizing their schedules to accomplish their objectives more efficiently.

Research questions

As the papers were written for different purposes and looked at different populations, the questions that motivated the papers were also different, though complementary. Britton and Tesser's motivating question was whether personal differences in how college students manage their time results in greater academic success, as measured by higher grades. They were able to demonstrate that some aspects of time management did contribute to success in school. Specifically, the researchers were able to show that for their sample self-reports of time management were related to academic achievement. Their measures of Time Attitudes and Short-Term Planning together accounted for 21% of predictable variance in grades. As a control, they also compared college GPA to SAT scores and found that the SAT score accounted for only 4% of the variance, which was nonsignificant.

Macan's central question was whether the application of the "process model" of time management reduced work-related stress and improved job performance. The process model Macan discusses begins with time management training that gives workers specific strategies for setting goals and priorities, making lists and schedules, and inculcating a preference for being organized. After...

This perception should in turn have the psychological benefits of reducing tension and enhancing job satisfaction, along with the practical effect of improving job performance.
Like Britton and Tesser, Macan found some empirical support for the efficacy of the benefits of time management. She found that time management training gave the workers a sense of self-efficacy at work and reduced symptoms of psychological and somatic tensions on the job. However, with regard to the practical benefits of time management, Macan's findings were mixed. She found, contrary to popular time management claims, that while prioritizing, goal-setting, and having a preference for organization did enhance respondents' perception of control over time, other time-management strategies such as making lists and scheduling activities did not lead to perceptions of greater time control (290).

Like Macan, Spidal is also concerned with self-assessment and subjective perceptions of budgeting and effectively managing time. Spidal's recommendations entail keeping a daily log for several days and taking note of one's activities throughout the day. Individuals keeping these logs are to write down when they are working efficiently, when their work is interrupted, what sorts of distractions regularly waste their time, and how often they look for misplaced items. Using this information, they can then organize their personal work space and their priorities, deciding which activities to delete, defer, delegate or delay to a later date.

Spidal's questions for each person's individual research include asking them to reflect on how many of their goals were accomplished on a given day, and if they were not, then why. Rather than statistically comparing research populations that do or do not employ time-management techniques, Spidal provides instructions on how to do individual self-research into one's current use of time. Spidal's presentation could be used in the type of training program that Macan evaluated in her questionnaires.

Spidal expects that keeping a time log will help people identify how when they are most productive, raising their awareness of common interruptions to their work, helping them to better manage their personal time.

Research design

Britton and Tesser constructed their time-management questionnaire in order to measure the degree to which students implemented components of a particular time management theory. The theory emphasizes "choosing goals and subgoals, prioritizing the goals, generating tasks and subtasks from the goals, prioritizing the tasks, listing the tasks on a "to-do" list, scheduling the tasks, and then carrying out the tasks" (407).

In collecting data for their statistical analysis, Britton and Tesser used standard measures of three different aspects of time management -- short-range planning, long-range planning and time attitudes. They then ranked the 90 students who took the time-management inventories according to their scores on these measures. This became the independent variable of the study. They then used the students' college GPA for the dependent variable, as a measure of academic accomplishment. They predicted there would be a correlation between time management skills and academic accomplishment.

Macan took a similar approach to Britton and Tesser. She also constructed surveys for this specific study, which she then asked the public employees to complete. The surveys asked if the workers had participated in time management training. For those who had, they were asked if they used any of the techniques they had picked up from the training. They were also asked to estimate the degree to which they perceived they had control over their time.

While Britton and Tesser looked only at objective measures of behavior as indicated by self-report, Macan asked her respondents to assess subjective feelings, such as their perception of personal control over their time at work, and their feelings of satisfaction with the job. Perceived control and subjective feelings of tension were relevant to Macan's process model of time management.

Spidal was also interested in introspection, encouraging her audience to reflect in their journals on when they were distracted and when they were productively attending to the task at hand.

Criticism and future research

The Spidal paper…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Allen, D. (2001). Getting Things Done: The Art of Stress-free Productivity. New York: Viking.

Britton, B.K., Tesser, A. (1991). Effects of time-management practices on college grades. Journal of educational psychology, 83 (3), 405-410.

Macan, T. (1994). Time management: Test of process mode. Journal of applied psychology, 381-391.

Mann, M. (2007). Inbox Zero. via Google videos video.google.com / (accessed May 29, 2008).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Synthesis Apixaban Vs Enoxaparin
Words: 2354 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Proposal

Hip replacement surgery puts its recipients at risk of deep venous thrombosis (DVT) or venous thromboembolism (VTE), whose complications include, but they are not limited to pulmonary embolism. With thousands of Americans opting for hip replacement every year, and statistics indicating that a significant percentage of patients develop thromboembolism after surgery, there is need to formulate and adopt an effective preventive plan to minimize the risk of DVT or VTE

Synthesis of Aspirin
Words: 659 Length: 2 Document Type: Lab Report

Aspirin is a most widely bought and used drugs for pain, fever and inflammation. Its main ingredient, salicylic acid, is irritating to the stomach and the drug must be modified. This experiment synthesizes aspirin with the use of salicylic acid as reactant. The experiment yielded a more acceptable, less irritating drug. Background of Experiment and Lab Concepts Present records say that more than 15,000 pounds of aspirin are sold daily (Smith n.d.).

Dealing With Difficult Dementia Patient Synthesis of the Evidence...
Words: 686 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Dementia and Alzheimer's Disease Dealing with Dementia and the progression of Alzheimer's disease through its three stages is often a daunting and distressing task. Most often relatives feel isolated and without help as if they were to be left alone, having no help to deal with the "unknown." They are also afraid of having to watch their loved ones become more and more distant, potentially losing a horrible battle with

Successful Expatriate Training Synthesis Successful
Words: 649 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

American companies may be unwilling to participate in some aspects of the 'grey economy' of bribery that locals take for granted. However, the memory of Western colonialism in many regions of the world is still fresh, and Americans must be sensitive to the fact that they may not always be welcomed automatically with open arms. Unfortunately, the symptoms of culture shock are often counterproductive to creating an understanding relationship --

Immigration Twenty-First Century" This Synthesis Essay; Involves
Words: 1248 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Immigration Twenty-First Century" This synthesis essay; involves essays "Amnesty?" John Immigration in the Twenty-First Century Immigration in the twenty-first century is one of the most widely debated issues in the United States. Many different states, liberals and conservatives have denoted varying stances on this topic, which seemingly becomes more pressing every day as the number of undocumented workers continues to grow. This phenomenon is widely discussed in a pair of essays

Digital Sound Synthesis and Usability Testing
Words: 5640 Length: 20 Document Type: Dissertation

Digital Sound Synthesis and Usability Testing Overview of analogue/digital synthesizers and their input in the music industry An essential issue in the researches of new media happens to be to investigate and clarify the connection between technological development and cultural revolutions. In this case, digital technology has usually been seen as the single most significant tool in the design of numerous of today's new cultural terminologies. In media that is heavily reliant

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now