Verified Document

Theory That The Earth Revolves About The Sun Research Paper

¶ … Earth Revolves Around the Sun Is this idea/theory/episode/question an example of scientific activity? Why or why not?

It's important to bear in mind that the philosophers of hundreds of years ago didn't always believe that the Earth revolved around the sun. Many of these thinkers believed that the sun revolved around the Earth and that the Earth was the center of the universe -- with the sun and all the stars and planets revolving around it. However, the complicated movement of the sun made this a very difficult theory to support. "The Sun, however, does not merely rise in the east and set in the west. You can see for yourself that the Sun only rises directly in the east on the equinoxes: at all other times of the year, it rises in the northeast (summer) or southeast (winter). Also, the Sun moves with respect to the stars: the Sun wanders through the 12 constellations of the zodiac, coming back to its starting point after 1 year" (ucsb.edu). Thus, because the sun was making such a complicated movement, these ancient people were forced to create a very confusing model of the earth revolving around the sun. Ultimately, they discovered, that the motions of the sun could be understood very simply by the Earth moving on a tilted axis once a day and the earth orbiting the sun once a year (ucsb.edu). This entire process is an example of scientific activity as it demonstrates the creation of a theory, intense observation and then the revision of a theory.

The theory that the Earth revolves around the sun is actually an episode of scientific activity. This belief is founded on evidence; even though for a long time, many notable astronomers only believed that the earth revolved around the sun, but had very little to go on (Cuk, 2002). For instance, the astronomer, Aristarchus believed that the Earth goes around the sun, once it was found that the sun is much bigger...

"Kepler discovered that laws governing of orbits become much more simple if the Sun is in their center. Newton has shown that this is caused by the universal law of gravity. If gravity works, Earth and other planets have to go around the Sun, because it is much heavier" (cornell.edu, 2002). These ideas and concepts demonstrate that there was enough scientific knowledge of the era for these great thinkers to understand that the Earth likely revolved around the sun, there just wasn't the capability or logistical or intellectual knowledge to prove otherwise.
2. How might the scientific validity or importance have been improved? In particular,

assess the quality of evidence and/or argument in some leading example. If it was not an example of science, how might it have been turned into a scientific activity?

However, 1725 demonstrated a clear instance of scientific activity regarding this theory: this was when James Bradley found a stellar aberration (Cuk, 2002). A stellar aberration refers to when there is a yearly change in the positions of all the stars in the sky as a result of the Earth's very own movement (Cuk, 2002). Aberration would arise because of the speed of light emitting from the sun and as a result of the Earth's own velocity, two truly complex dynamics (Cuk, 2002). This marked the first piece of evidence which indicated that sun revolved around the Earth.

On the other hand, a simpler means of explaining this consequence is in connection with the Earth's stellar parallax: if the Earth was adapting its place relative to the stars over time, then the stars would rightly appear to reflect this change as well. Stellar parallax is a major conglomeration of evidence as to why the Earth does revolve…

Sources used in this document:
References

Cain, F. (2010, March 30). Earth's Orbit Around The Sun. Retrieved from universetoday.com: http://www.universetoday.com/61202/earths-orbit-around-the-sun/

Cuk, M. (2002). Is there a proof that Earth moves? Retrieved from Cornell.edu: http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?number=190

Motz, L. (2003). The Unfolding Universe: A Stellar Journey. New York: Perseus Books.

Tate, J. (2009, December 10). Stellar Parallax. Retrieved from Universetoday.com: http://www.universetoday.com/47182/stellar-parallax/
Ucsb.edu. (n.d.). How do we know that the earth revolves around the sun? Retrieved from Ucsb.edu: http://scienceline.ucsb.edu/getkey.php?key=2921
Witchita.edu. (n.d.). Johannes Kepler. Retrieved from Witchita.edu: http://www.math.wichita.edu/history/men/kepler.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Earth Science / Astronomy Ptolemy
Words: 1330 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The Moon is believed by many to have been part of the earth and that it was tore off as a result of an initial spin that was too great to hold the planet together. One of the prevailing theories was that involving an impact of large magnitude involving the newly formed Earth and a giant object of the size of Mars hitting Earth and blowing up material that

Metric System -- One of the Reasons
Words: 1185 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Metric System -- One of the reasons measurement can be complicated is that there is more than one system in use. Based on the Ancient Roman system, the metric system is based on powers of 10; which is called decimalization. The metric system has been the preferred European and scientific method of measuring sine the 18th century, but is not part of the International System of Units, which is also

English System of Measurement Is
Words: 1433 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

(Source: http://csep10.phys.utk.edu/astr161/lect/history/newtongrav.html). Assignment 2-1 -- a- Radiation may be considered information from space; different types of information from different sources. These are: 1) Light as a wave and particle, 2) Electromagnetism, 3) Cosmic Rays and 4) Ultraviolet radiation. Part 2-1-B- Light may be measured by telescopes; other space radiation by radio waves; x-ray machines may absorb cosmic and x-ray energy. Part 2-1-C- Stars and Planets emit electromagnetic; Sun emits UV, Electromagnetic and

Problem With Modern Curricular Philosophy
Words: 4534 Length: 14 Document Type: Research Paper

History Of Theory Behind Curriculum Development The evolution of curriculum theory by and large reflects the current of thought found in the academic-political landscape. The essence of the ancient maxim cuius regio, eius religio applies here: who reigns, his religion. In this case, who reigns, his curriculum. This has been true throughout all the centuries where education was deemed important by a group of individuals or a State. For example, in

Thomas Kuhn's the Structure of
Words: 3200 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

What they had regarded as the most certain of all theories turned out to be in need of serious revision. In reaction, they resolved never again to bestow their faith in scientific truth unconditionally. Skepticism, not certainty, became their watchword. (ibid) The implication of Kuhn's work was that science was seen to be dependent on history. It was no longer superior to historical analysis but could only be understood within the

Small Pieces of Glass: The
Words: 1209 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The Ptolemaic model was accepted by most philosophers of note until it was radically challenged by the Polish astronomer Copernicus in 1530. The Catholic church condemned the Copernican System in 1616 and forbade holding, defending, or even teaching alternatives to the Ptolemaic conception of the universe endorsed by the Church (Fowler 2008:10). But both theories were mere conjecture until the development of the Galilean telescope. Galileo's telescope was a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now