Verified Document

The OJ Simpson Case Analysis Essay

Related Topics:

OJ Simpson Versus the People: Impact on Criminal justice

The American criminal justice process and system are responsible for shaping the present-day US laws; influential entities include even 19th-century governmental authorities and political leaders. The system, which comprises law enforcement bodies like local police forces, correctional facilities and criminal courts, was primarily created for ensuring American citizens’ safety. It constitutes a structural framework that facilitates the maintenance of law and order in American society (Zedner & Ashworth, 2012; \"Justice, Western Theories\", 2018; Baldwin, 1912). 

According to Mueller (1996), the structuring of the US criminal justice system has gone through several modifications after historic events occurred within the criminal law context that uncovered the system’s shortcomings (Mueller, 1996). These events, perhaps, influenced lawmakers to enforce amendments and change the case execution process, for appropriately upholding justice. One such case is that of OJ Simpson, who was tried for killing Nicole Brown (his former wife) and Ron Goldman (who worked as waiter at the Mezzaluna Restaurant); the two were found dead on 13th June, 1994.

The victims’ bodies were discovered just before midnight. According to the prosecutor, the killings probably took place somewhere around 10:15-10:35 P.M., as indicated by the Akita dog’s wailing. Simpson and Kato weren’t accounted for from 9:36 P.M. onwards (when the two went their separate ways upon reaching Rockingham house, on their way back from McDonald\'s) until 10:55 P.M. (when limo driver, Allan Park, saw Kato on the estate’s grounds and, at the same time, a \"shadowy figure\" that looked like Simpson entering the house). In a short while, Simpson left for the airport, to board a Chicago-bound midnight flight (Mueller, 1996). Though Simpson didn’t testify at all at trial, his lawyers claimed their client was, in this period of time when nobody saw him, asleep, packing, and playing chip golf shots. For proving Simpson was guilty, the prosecution presented the following types of evidence.

Firstly,...
Simpson was incensed that Nicole had left him, reconciled, and then left him again, just a month earlier (Muller, 1996; Thompson, 1996). She had rejected his birthday present for her and not included him in her family circle during the dance performance and subsequent dinner. Further, Simpson’s left index finger was injured, as observed by policepersons at the station on the night of the murder. This cut wasn’t noticed earlier, either by the dance recital attendees or Kato Kaelin.
The next piece of evidence provided was a ski cap and bloodstained, left-handed Aris Isotoner glove discovered at the site of the murder. The other (right-hand) glove, also bloody, was discovered on the outer walkway to the rear of Simpson\'s house. Fibers taken from the Bronco fabric, ski cap, Goldman’s shirt, and the gloves were identical (Mueller, 1996).

The third proof presented was scientific. Blood samples from the Bronco and glove were DNA tested, with the results matching Goldman, Simpson, and Nicole. The blood sample from a bloodstained sock discovered on the defendant’s bedroom floor was DNA-tested and matched Brown’s DNA. Lastly, blood drops discovered on the Bundy sidewalk and Rockingham house’s hallway and walkway matched the defendant (Mueller, 1996; Fairchild & Cowan, 2010). These scientific proofs were quite incriminating, given the statement that, in only one in 7 billion cases would the alleles be identical in the accused and in the sample found on the crime scene.

A sound counterattack was put forward by the defense. Firstly, it claimed the prosecution’s statement pertaining to Simpson\'s motive, conduct, frame of mind, and appearance was wrong. Their client was neither furious with the victim nor intended any harm (Brewer, 2004; University, 2018). According to a homemade video of the recital, Simpson appeared to be congenial and smiling when interacting briefly with another performer’s parent. Secondly, the defense team criticized the physical proof’s integrity and interpretation; defense lawyer Cochran mocked at the…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

O.J. Simpson Case: Orenthal James
Words: 1381 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Jury Selection Process, Sequestration, Verdict and Relevant Controversies: OJ Simpson's case had already set the record for being the longest jury trial in the history of California even before the commencement of closing arguments. For a better part of the year, the jury in the case had been sequestered and was displaying signs of exhaustion and strain (Linder, 2000). Actually, Judge Ito was blamed for permitting the trial to drag on

Oj Simpson and Crime
Words: 910 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Courtroom TV The discussion below is an analysis of a criminal prosecution case that was celebrated The OJ Simpson Case; Criminal Procedures The presiding judge indicated that she was satisfied with the prosecutions argument. Judge Kathleen pointed out that she was convinced that Mr. Simpson had questions to answer in the superior court about the murder of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald L. Gold man on 12th June night. This ruling was a

How to Use DNA Analysis in Court
Words: 2199 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

DNA Analysis Abstract This paper discusses the history of DNA analysis, how it came about, how it was first used in a criminal case, and some of the limitations of DNA analysis as shown by later criminal cases. It looks at how DNA analysis is currently used today, including a recent criminal investigation in Europe in which DNA analysis played a crucial role, and provides a description of the various directions that

Casey Anderson Criminological Case Study
Words: 1471 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Casey Anthony Trial The murder trial Florida vs. Casey Marie Anthony turned into a national sensation because of the alleged attempt by 25-year-old Casey Anthony to cover up the murder of her own 2-year-old daughter, Caylee Anthony (Alvarez, 2011). On July 5, 2011, after nearly six weeks of courtroom testimony and just 11 hours of deliberation, the jury found Casey Anthony not guilty. The prosecution's failure to convince the jury of

Application of DNA in California in Criminal Cases
Words: 7716 Length: 28 Document Type: Term Paper

DNA in Criminal Cases - Solving Cold Cases in California with Forensic Science This research will attempt to analyze and discuss the feasibility of DNA testing in solving cold cases and will study the impact that DNA fingerprinting has had on the forensic science community as a whole. DNA is generally used to solve crimes in one of two ways. In cases where a suspect is identified, a sample of that person's

Media Coverage of the Scott Peterson Case
Words: 1740 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Media Coverage of the Scott Peterson Case man allegedly slaughters his pregnant wife in cold blood! This sensational headline for the sensational case of Scott Peterson could very easily and ironically, accurately sum up the details of Peterson case. Peterson is accused of pretending to go fishing on Christmas Eve, killing his wife and his unborn son because of anxieties about becoming a father and because he desired his beautiful

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now