Verified Document

The Ethics Of Controlling Disease Spread Research Paper

Medical Ethics Sexually Transmitted Diseases and Contact Tracing

MG is a 27-year-old graduate student, recently married, who comes into the student health clinic for a routine pelvic exam and Pap smear. During the course of the exam, the gynecology resident performing the exam obtains the Pap smear, but also obtains cervical cultures for gonorrhea and chlamydia. The examination concludes uneventfully. Several weeks later, MG receives a postcard indicating that the Pap smear was normal, with no evidence of dysplasia, but that the cervical culture for gonorrhea was positive. The card instructs her to come into the clinic to discuss treatment, and that "public health authorities" have been notified for contact tracing, which refers to the identification and diagnosis of sexual partners, as required by law. The young woman is terrified that her husband will be contacted. Is contact tracing ethically justified?

While it is definitely not a good thing that the woman has gonorrhea and there is a chance that she is the one whose behavior that is spreading it, there are a lot of assumptions that could be made and most of them would be wrong regardless of the actual reason she has contracted gonorrhea. Indeed, it may be because of unprotected sex on the part of the woman with more than one partner but the same could be true of the husband. While whomever the victim of all of this happens to be, it is a bridge too far...

The guilty party could lie and/or the person who gave it to the woman may have gotten cured already. Second, gonorrhea is easily treatable and is not nearly as potentially or definitely damaging as HIV / AIDS, herpes or HPV, the last of which could cause cervical cancer.
However, even with the best of intentions when it comes to contact tracing, the overall practice is generally ineffective in practice. Beyond that, many STD's (including gonorrhea) can be asymptomatic for a long while. It is entirely possible that the woman had the disease before she started having sex with her husband. It certainly does not necessarily mean that she has been unfaithful and/or that he has done the same. That all being said, if the woman is having unprotected sex with her husband (which is likely), he should be notified. The reason the agency doing so is ethically dubious is because it would plant the seed that his wife is being unfaithful and this, by itself, could break them up. Even worse, the couple in question may have one or more children and a potential separation or divorce could impact them greatly and negatively. Generally speaking, public health officials should probably refrain from contact tracing except as it relates to more dangerous diseases. Public health education and so forth would be the wiser course as changing the root habits that lead to the spread of STD's is the…

Sources used in this document:
References

Amir-Singh, J., Upshur, R., & Padayatchi, N. (2007). XDR-TB in South Africa: No Time for Denial or Complacency. Plos Med, 4(1), e50. http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0040050

Armbruster, B., & Brandea, M. (2007). Contact tracing to control infectious disease: when enough is enough. Health Care Management Science, 10(4), 341. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3428220/

Boskey, E. (2016). Contact tracing really is an important thing to participate in.. About.com Health. Retrieved 20 March 2016, from http://std.about.com/od/prevention/f/contacttracing.htm

McKay, B. (2016). Dangerous TB Patient Detained on U.S. Border. WSJ. Retrieved 20 March 2016, from http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323978104578332461533970412
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics and HIV Ethical Considerations
Words: 575 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

It would therefore be a major breach of ethics for the status of individuals in the study to be leaked. Another ethical challenge would be keeping the status of individuals from their significant others. Women are often in relationships where the power and economic disparities require them to remain in those relationships for mere survival. Should their status become known by their partner this may threaten the longevity of the

Ethics and Technology
Words: 1821 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics and Computing in Computer Science EMPOWERMENT AND RESPONSIBILITY Errors and Hazards and Their Consequences Despite the best of care and talent, computation is subject to uncertainties, which experts call "errors (Landau, 2008)." Some of these errors are man-made and some are produced by the computer itself. The four classes of errors are blunders or bad theory, random errors, approximation or algorithm errors, and round-off errors. Blunders are typographical errors or errors caused

Ethics and Development
Words: 3006 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics and Morality -- Ethics and Development The problem of "development" (or, perhaps "progress" and "advancement" also fits in this context) is that while many millions of citizens of the world have been blessed by dramatic progress (technological, industrial, and communications) over the past few decades, many millions are being left behind. Indeed, while millions are living better, living more comfortable lives, countless millions are not benefiting in the least from

Ethics in Nanomedicine the Term
Words: 10726 Length: 40 Document Type: Term Paper

All these charters that have clearly defined the boundaries of what both the positive i.e. natural rights and negative i.e. The unjust exploitative rights of the people are and how no institution or research domains have the right or power to violate them (Dierkes, Hoffmann and Marz, 1996). Based on the above fact, we have to consider all the concerns related towards security of an individual as well as his

Nursing Ethics and Vaccination Debate
Words: 1658 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

The Vaccination Dilemma The rights of individuals to refuse vaccinations, and the rights of parents to refuse their children vaccinations, has been increasingly called into question because of the way individual autonomy conflicts directly with the rights of the general public. For example, outbreaks of vaccine-preventable illnesses have increased, with serious outbreaks of measles in the United States being a prime example. Although the United States Centers for Disease Control and

Peter Singer - Ethics Peter
Words: 2190 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Chickens never see the light of day nor set foot on solid ground. They are raised in wire cages no bigger than this page -- often three to a cage -- and thus are never able to spread their wings or to establish a normal pecking order. They are so unable to move that their feet grow around the wire (Spira, 2005). Packed confinement makes them try to kill each

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now