Verified Document

The Debate Over Who Owns Public Spaces Essay

Davila, A. Puerto Ricans, Latinos, and the Neoliberal City. (p. 27-58). In his chapter, "Dream of Place and Housing Struggles," Davila makes the point that growing numbers of Latinos are recognizing the need for collective action in the face of increasing threats to their communities from gentrification. Further exacerbating the process has been declining levels of federal and state housing assistance that has made it even more difficult for this population group to secure and maintain adequate low-cost housing, especially in communities where property values are being artificially inflated due to the influx of more affluent mainstream Americans. For instance Davila emphasizes that, "Rents are rapidly increasing, and buildings that a decade ago would have been abandoned or sold cheaply are being coveted by nonprofit investors and private speculators alike" (p. 28).

The implications of these trends on the Latino community in these urban communities have included growing numbers of residents seeking some type of low-cost alternative, which in many cases means reliance on publicly subsidized housing. The relegation of minorities to "the projects" carries involves significant social stigmatization, an outcome that is inconsistent with the need to empower local residents to exert more control over their own circumstances. Given the scarcity of this type of housing, though (there is an 8-year waiting list in some communities), it is little wonder that these trends have troubled many Latino observers. Nevertheless, the attitudes about gentrification vary according to social and economic status, even within the Latino community itself, and Davila suggests that those communities where Latinos openly embrace gentrification may suffer from exploitation by developers.

Kohn, M. Brave New Neighborhoods: The Privatization of Public Space (p. 167-188)

In his comparison of the perspectives advanced by the political theorists Jeremy Waldron and Robert Ellickson, Kohn makes the point that homelessness remains a serious problem in the nation's cities, but there remains less consensus concerning what should be done about the problem. On the one hand, the homeless are deprived of the fundamental ability to perform the most basic needs of living in a private space. Clearly, providing additional shelters for the homeless could alleviate part of the problem, but Waldron emphasizes that the homeless also enjoy a certain amount of...

This approach would promote more visitation to central urban areas by ensuring that "good" residents and visitors would not have to witness the debauchery and depravity that are characteristic of the "bad" parts of town. In an approach Ellickson analogizes with traffic control systems, a green light zone would mean "safety ahead" and visitors could proceed with impunity, yellow zones would of course mean "caution" and red zones, allowed to occupy 5% of a city's geographic area, would be the really bad places where prostitution, drunkenness and panhandling proliferate. In either case, the homeless are being relegated to a second-class citizen status where they are expected to remain invisible to mainstream society and an out-of-sight, out-of-mind way.
Mitchell, D. The Right to the City: Social Justice and the Fight for Public Space. (p. 227-237)

In his concluding chapter, "The Illusion and Necessity of Order: Toward a Just City," Mitchell emphasizes that longstanding beliefs about the effectiveness of so-called "broken window" policing have not only failed to reduce crime and poverty, these types of law enforcement initiatives may well do more harm than good by creating further divisiveness between community members and police. Moreover, this debate has assumed new relevance and meaning as the threat of terrorism has loomed large over the American consciousness following the attacks of September 11, 2001. Indeed, Mitchell makes the point that it remains unclear whether it will even be possible to maintain public spaces in America's cities in the future given the anonymity such venues provide. For instance, according to Mitchell, just as the homeless are criminalized by broken-window policing because of the tendency of others to commit crimes, so too are ordinary citizens being increasingly held suspect simply by virtue of occupying space in public. In this regard, Mitchell notes that, "The vision of the city promoted by security experts indicates that all people in public will need to be made suspect…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Contested Public Space Memories and History
Words: 3233 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

CONTESTED PUBLIC SPACE: MEMORIES & HISTORY Contested Public Space: Memories and History Das Denkmal fur Die Ermordeten Juden Europas The Memory Landscape. Mary's is a large old-style brick church belonging to the council of the Hanseatic city of Lubeck. On the floor at the rear of the church, broken pieces of two large bells remain where they fell during an air raid in World War II. The third largest church in Germany, it took

Public Funding of Abortion Clinic
Words: 1206 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

This means that the government should fund abortions despite of where they are performed whether in hospitals or clinics. This can be achieved through passing legislation to support pro-choice care for all pregnant women. Allowing abortions only in particular situations is a form of discrimination and in order to ensure that Americans have the necessary system that supports the choice of women to get an abortion, the government needs

Public Archeology Nationalism and Public
Words: 2216 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

One other area of the world which is currently experiencing some major problems related to archeological excavations in public places is the Middle East, particularly Israel and within its capital city of Jerusalem. In this case study by Yigal Bronner and Neve Gordon, the main area of dispute lies with "the way archeology is being used in Silwan, a Palestinian neighborhood in the oldest part" of Jerusalem, where excavations, under

Debating NASA's Budget and Importance As the
Words: 1209 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Debating NASA's Budget and Importance As the increasingly impotent federal government lurches towards the edge of a self-imposed fiscal cliff, the public and politicians alike have largely accepted the inevitability of deep cuts to the nation's massively inflated budget. While there is still rancorous debate over exactly how the proverbial belt should be tightened, with conservatives demanding reductions in so-called entitlement programs and liberals countering with decreased military spending, a consensus

Public Vs. Private Sector Unions Public and
Words: 1169 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Public vs. Private Sector Unions Public and Private Sector Unions Collective bargaining in public sector is a recent phenomenon that became common in 1960 and started gaining momentum at the time when unionism in private sector was slowly declining (Reilly, 2012). Changes in the government policies and the legal requirements made the way for the increasing unionism in the public sector. There has always been a debate regarding the issue if private

Public Sphere Democratic Governance Relates
Words: 4077 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Some of the communication technologies include news content, internet (social media platforms), campaigns, billboard advertisements, and organized interaction forums . These technologies are essential in enhancing interactions between the society and the state thus promotion of good or effective governance. Communication practices are forms of communication such as language, setting, mode, target audience, and content of information shared between the sender and the receiver. Communication practices and technology focuses on

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now