Through talking with their students, teachers can learn in what those students are interested. Teachers can learn what teaching styles best affect them, what can engage them. This can help them better relate to their students as teachers, portraying their subjects in a way that students can understand. In addition, Corbett argues that teachers can learn from their students by re-learning what it is like to be a beginning learner. They can do this by taking a class themselves or by writing the papers that they assign to their students. Thus, they learn the pain and suffering that many students have to go through in order to learn. Thus, Corbett's major theory is that both students and teachers exist in a symbiotic relationship in which they learn from one another.
At first, many teachers may react to Corbett's piece without surprise. They may think that what he is theorizing is not revolutionary, but on closer look, it is actually both revolutionary and important. Corbett argues not that teachers need to find a way to affect their students, but that they need to view the learning process as reciprocal -- two sources of instruction and two benefactors. If teachers view their classrooms this way, it is likely that they and their students will find learning a much more beneficial and easy process. Students and teachers who are not caught in a power play can better learn for the sake of learning, instead of for the sake of setting up a hierarchy. On the other hand, Corbett's article raises questions of authority. Classrooms must still have an authority figure, and in the modern system of education, they must be geared toward some type of completion. The class that looses itself in discussion may not prepare the students adequately for the vocation into which they will enter. Thus, Corbett's piece has positive implications for the classroom, but teachers must use them with caution in order to avoid problematic situations.
Elbow, Peter. (1994). Writing for Learning -- Not Just for Demonstrating Learning.
Accessed June 28, 2005, at http://www.ntlf.com/html/lib/bib/writing.htm.
In his article, "Writing for Learning Not Just for Demonstrating Learning," Peter Elbow discusses theorizes that writing can be a useful tool that teachers can use to impart learning. In this article, Elbow argues that two types of writing exist, high stakes and low stakes. While high stakes writing is the kind that is used to "demonstrate learning" (1). This is the type of writing that many students do on tests and in-class essays. On the other hand, "low-stakes" writing is writing "to learn, understand, remember, and figure out what you don't yet know" (1). Elbow argues that this might not be considered "good writing," but it is an effective tool for getting students to learn concepts, in addition to being a good way for teachers to gauge whether or not the students have learned the concepts that they have been teaching. Elbow lists several types of writing exercises that the teacher may have his or students complete in order to teach them. In class writing can fall into the categories of journal writing and think pieces. In journal writings, the students "connect what they are studying with the rest of their experience, thoughts, and feelings." In this way, students engage with the material, understanding its importance, in addition to its applicability in the classroom. In addition to journal pieces, Elbow proposes that teachers use think pieces in order to encourage their students to think about the novel. Still not a formal essay, think pieces are structured like "thoughtful letters to an interested friend." Not only do these pieces encourage students to think about the course material, but they also encourage students to come to class with their reading already completed, ready to engage in learning. The final type of writing that Elbow discusses is writing to demonstrate learning. These formal essays can be based on the previous journal entries and think pieces, but they are an exploration of the learning they have managed to complete.
Peter Elbow's piece theorizes that teachers can use writing to encourage students to learn and be responsible, in addition to simply assessing that learning. By using these strategies, teachers can really grasp what material the students have learned, and what they still need to understand. This takes some of the guesswork out of teaching, and allows students to target just the materials that students...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now