Verified Document

Teaching ESL Students At Least 3.5 Million Research Paper

¶ … Teaching ESL Students At least 3.5 million children every year are identified as possessing limited English proficiency and require additional support before they are mainstreamed into the regular classroom environment (Miller & Endo 2004: 786). Approaches to ESL instruction run the gamut from total immersion to fostering a largely bilingual approach to education for this group of students. The two typical program approaches are that of a transitional bilingual education (TBE) versus a structured (sheltered) English immersion (SEI) program. In TBE, students are instructed in their native language and slowly transitioned to English, and are mainstreamed within 2-3 years to an English-only environment. In the SEI model, all instruction is provided in English immediately, with no accommodations (Tong 2009). A "major challenge that schools face under the pressure of the landmark No Child Left Behind Act of 2002 is to prepare ELLs with native-like English proficiency through various instructional models so that these ELLs will be able to participate competitively in academic and social events"(Tong et al. 2008). The debate on how to educate ESL students is often ideologically charged, thus it is important to conduct an overview of the research on what actually seems to 'work' with students, versus the approach which satisfies a particular agenda of how American education 'should be.'

According to Miller & Endo (2004), the typical duration of an ESL program or support system is one or two years before a student is entirely left to 'sink or swim' in a class alongside of native English peers. Yet current language research indicates that 5-7 years of education in a language is required to reach full academic proficiency (Miller & Endo 2004: 786). This means that students will be constantly playing 'catch up' with their peers without proper academic support. They note that many studies show considerable benefits for students who continue to be bilingual, and advocate a bilingual approach...

Students should not be penalized for transitioning into their native language every now and then, and teachers should make accommodations when needed, such as simplifying higher-level vocabulary when teaching complex scientific or historical material (Miller & Endo 2004: 790). This ensures that ESL students can keep pace with their native language peers without falling behind in other academic subjects.
It is also argued that bilingual education that does not demonize the student's first language as 'dead weight' and encourages the retention of two languages also reduces the cognitive dissonance students experience when acclimating to a new culture as well as to a new language. Students may be reluctant to learn English if they feel it is a betrayal to their parents at home, who still speak a foreign language (Miller & Endo 2004). The ability to remain grounded in their native language eliminates some of the discomfort that can result with frequent 'code switching' between their original language at home and total immersion in English at school. The instruction that children receive in schools as well as the language can be quite Eurocentric in terms of the concepts and history on which it focuses, and also upon the approach. Many students from other cultures feel uncomfortable with the informal, contentious style of American education which places a greater emphasis on open-ended questions and class debate, and this exacerbates the difficulties they experience in transitioning to an English language-only mainstream classroom.

The anecdotal evidence supporting a gradual bilingual transition of Miller & Endo (2004) is contradicted to some degree by one study by Tong (et al. 2008) who conducted a two-year longitudinal survey 534 Hispanic English-language learners in kindergarten and first grade in different programs. "The comparison…

Sources used in this document:
References

Miller, P. & Endo, H. (2004). Understanding and meeting the needs of ESL learners. Phi Delta

Kappan, 786-791,

http://faculty.weber.edu/mtungmala/Hybrid4270/Articles/MeetNeeds.pdf

Owens, A. (2010). In the Aftermath of question 2: Students with Limited English Proficiency in Massachusetts. Massachusetts Office for Refugees and Immigrants: Special report.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/radical-teaching/201211/bilingual-brains-smarter-faster.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Motivation to Read Amongst Esol
Words: 1239 Length: 4 Document Type: Literature Review

Reaction to the source The authors presented a well developed and cohesive approach to analyzing the manner in which young people learn a foreign language. Kartal, G. (2006). Working with an imperfect medium: Speech recognition technology in reading practice. Journal of Educational Multimedia and Hypermedia, 15(3), 303-305. Description of the focus of the source The focus of this study was the read-aloud behaviors of learners who were assigned an experimental computer-based program that used

Application of a Pedagogic Model to the Teaching of Technology to...
Words: 60754 Length: 230 Document Type: Dissertation

Pedagogic Model for Teaching of Technology to Special Education Students Almost thirty years ago, the American federal government passed an act mandating the availability of a free and appropriate public education for all handicapped children. In 1990, this act was updated and reformed as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which itself was reformed in 1997. At each step, the goal was to make education more equitable and more accessible to

Education, Reading Disorders Reading Disabilities
Words: 3924 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

In order to build an age-appropriate vocabulary in the English language, ESL students must learn words at a faster rate than normal (Lipka, Siegel, & Vukovic, 2005; Drucker 2003). This results in a widening gap between the reading and comprehension levels of ESL and non-ESL students if the needs of ESL students are not addressed (Lipka, Siegel, & Vukovic, 2005). Some ESL students come from a native language that poses

Reading Strategies' Impact on ELL
Words: 7058 Length: 26 Document Type: Capstone Project

There is also the question of what approach should be used in a given setting. For instance, Lewis-Moreno points out that, "A great deal of energy is expended selecting and defending the model used: Should it be late- or early-exit bilingual, dual language, or English immersion?" (2007, p. 773). Although complex problems require complex solutions, a common theme that runs through the relevant literature concerns the need to use

Gifted Program It Is Difficult
Words: 3442 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Proposal

To address these social and academic issues, the Waco, Texas, Independent School District (2005) initiated a project offering AP Spanish Language to eighth-grade Hispanic students and later expanded to three years (Rakow, 2005). The goal was to promote student success, develop self-confidence, and support student academic aspirations among an at-risk student population. In the three years of program implementation, 117 students took the class and corresponding AP exam. Of

Individual Learning Plans in Community
Words: 4463 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

V. Government System RARPA The government introduced the RARPA Program which is abbreviated for the:: "Recording and Recognition of Progress and Achievement Summary of the Evaluation Report" in relation to the Pilot Projects April 2003 to March 2004 Learning and Skills Development Agency National Institute of Adult Continuing Education 2004 August. Since 2002 the Learning and Skills Council (LSC) has focused its efforts on establishing an appropriate method of recognizing and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now