Verified Document

Teacher And Peer To Peer Mentoring Research Paper

¶ … Constraints in School Advisory Programs In an era of high stakes testing and increasing calls for educator accountability for academic outcomes, identifying opportunities to use existing resources to their maximum advantage has assumed new importance and relevance today (Phillipo & Stone, 2013). A growing body of research confirms the importance of school advisory programs in achieving improved academic outcomes, but these initiatives are also characterized by a number of constraints that must be taken into account in order to achieve optimal results. To determine the facts, this paper reviews the relevant literature concerning school advisory programs to identify current theories, explanations, proposed relationships among constructs, as well as existing gaps in this body of knowledge. In addition, a discussion concerning the contradictions, inconsistencies, and ambiguities regarding the findings that emerged from the research concerning school advisory programs is following by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Discussion

School advisory programs in junior and middle schools have a lengthy history dating back nearly a century and a half (Weilbacher & Lanier, 2012). More recently, school advisory programs have been implemented at the elementary school level and are continued throughout a student's academic career (Wielbacher & Lanier, 2012). These are important advances because the relationship between educators and students is an integral component of promoting academic success, but many students experience a degradation of this relationship when the transition between elementary and secondary schools (Van Ryzin, 2010).

In response, a growing number of secondary schools have implemented advisory programs wherein an educator/advisor periodically meets with small groups of students throughout the school year (Van Ryzin, 2010). Likewise, Wall (2012) reports that advisory programs are also consistent with the goals set forth in the Developmental Designs for Middle School initiative. A study by Borgeson (2009) found that mentored students generally benefited from the process and many experienced improved academic outcomes as a result. n addition, Benson and Poliner (2013) cite the value of the low-key environment in which school advisory programs are administered as one of their major strengths. This strategy is also congruent with the recommendations of the Carnegie Council...

In this regard, Miglin, Hurd and Al-Bataineh (2015) report that, "Advisory programs were developed with the belief in mind that all adolescent students should have at least one adult at school acting as the student's advocate" (p. 1).
In truth, the argument could be made that given the rigors of the academic process today, young learners need all of the advocacy they can get at school (Shulkind & Foote, 2009). The research to date confirms that advisory program result in improved academic outcomes as well as a host of other positive features, including a positive learning environment, improved teacher-student relationships and peer-to-peer interactions, providing students receive the training they need to exercise these responsibilities appropriately (Miglin et al., 2015). In sum, school advisory programs are used for a number of reasons, including: (1) to promote students' sense of belonging within the school (2) to assist students in the development of self-understanding (3) to assist students in the development of effective interpersonal relationship (4) to guide students in decisions related to future growth.(Rotenberg, 1994, p. 72).

Although there is a growing consensus concerning the value of advisory programs at all educational levels, there are also some constraints and ambiguities related to their administration that make formulating truly effective approaches a challenging enterprise (Johnson, 2013). For example, a survey of 5,300 school counselors conducted by Gewertz (2011) found that fully 90% of the respondents reported two specific goals (i.e., ensuring that all students have access to high-quality education and that they graduate well-equipped for college and careers) should be the main priorities for their schools, but fewer than 40% reported that their schools fully embraced these priorities. In addition, far too many schools are overlooking the importance of peer mentoring initiatives as part of their overall advisory programs (Cohen, 2012). In this regard, a study by Wilkins, Ruddle, Paitsel, Duffield and Minch (2014) the peer-to-peer advisory programs used by some West Virginian school districts in the form of school clubs have also proven effective in reducing their dropout rates.

Many students today also experience a wide range of mental health issues that can benefit from advisory programs, but many schools have tended to overlook the centrality of these issues in their advisory programs to…

Sources used in this document:
References

Benson, J., & Poliner, R. E. (2013). Designing advisories for resilience. Educational Leadership, 50-55.

Bierman, K. L., Coie, J. D., Dodge, K. A., Greenberg, M. T., Lochman, J. E., McMahon, R. J. & Pinderhughes, E. (2010). Conduct problems prevention research group. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 78(2), 56-168.

Borgeson, P. (2009). Student and teacher perspectives of the effectiveness of middle school advisory programs on sense of belonging. ProQuest Education Journals, 47(3), 224-229

Cohen, M. (2012). Seniors take the lead. Principal Leadership, 13(3), 28-31
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Teaching Is One of the
Words: 17626 Length: 64 Document Type: Research Proposal

3.4 Finally, I am interested in whether or not there is a trickle-down effect from leftist or rightist politics style at the provincial and federal levels. 1.3 Objectives 1.3.1 There are two major objectives for this research. The first is to compare the level of motivation among secondary school teachers under the Vancouver British Columbia School District in Canada by their socio-demographic and organizational factors. My hypothesis in advance of investigating this is

Peer Coaching of Teachers Introducing
Words: 1022 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

As teachers are asked to do more and more by busy and demanding parents, it further fosters collaboration and support among teachers throughout the same school building. The purpose of peer teaching is not to judge the other teachers, but to encourage mutual reflection and analysis of teaching practice. It promotes specific feedback over time, rather than monitors teaching in glimpses, like a visit from a principle. (Robbins, 1991) Selecting

Peer Coaching Lead to Professional
Words: 5012 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Proposal

Each level influences and is influenced by those around it." (Costa, Kahaneo, Lipton, et al., 2001, p. 2). Once the teacher understands how their performance and their teaching ability relate to the outcomes of the school as a whole, they will be able to understand the need for peer observation and coaching. They desire better outcomes for the school, but they are not accustomed to the openness of the peer

Teacher Burnout
Words: 2040 Length: 7 Document Type: Literature Table

EDUCATION ADMINISTRATION Education Administration: Teacher Burnout- Literature Table and Reference ListReference1. Carroll et al., 20212. Herman, Hickmon-Rosa & Reinke, 20183. Jacobson, 2016Type (qual, quant, theoretical, peer-reviewed, book, dissertation)Quantitative research (peer-review article)Quantitative research (peer-review article)A qualitative study (dissertation)Aim or scope of the studyTo assess the downstream effects of teachers� burnout along with the effectiveness of stress-reduction interventions and improvement in student self-reported outcomesTo explore the relationship between teachers� stress, burnout, self-efficacy,

Peer Mentors Compare and Contrast
Words: 1958 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Why Mentees Feel Socially Supported from Peer Mentorship Compare and Contrast Essay:  Peer Mentors Lucas and James (2018) evaluate the effect of specialist mentoring on college students with autism and other mental health conditions and found that mentees receive academic, social and emotional support from their mentors. However, the researchers also observed group differences between those with autism and those with other mental health issues. What makes a relationship between mentor and

Mentoring and Coaching
Words: 647 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Mentoring and Coaching Learning strong teaching skills is crucial to students looking to enter into the field of education. Part of their learning comes through experiencing lessons and actually teaching in classroom environments. This can then be augmented with professional guidance. This is essentially the aim of the program examined here. This program focuses on helping provide student teachers with better direction through methods of "support and challenge" (SchoolsWorldTV 2012). This

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now