Verified Document

Supreme Court Sodomy Cases Rulings Essay

Related Topics:

Right to Privacy and Consenting Adults: Examining the Sodomy Cases The 1986 case of Bowers v. Hardwick represents the continued legacy of homophobia of the era. This case demonstrates how homophobia has amounted to longstanding oppression for gay people, and has continually thwarted justice from protecting them or ever serving them. Michael Hardwick was in his late 20s when he was bartending at a gay bar in Georgia. He threw a beer bottle into an outdoor trash can and was written up by the police for public drinking (Bazelon, 2012). The terms of this citation come under suspicion as its possible that the police officer who wrote the ticket was just targeting him because he knew he was gay and worked at a local gay bar. The details of this citation of extremely dubious. The police officer that wrote the wrong day on the citation, ensuring that Hardwick would not show up as a result. This meant that a warrant for Hardwick’s arrest was issued (Eskridge, 2008). An officer arrived at Hardwick’s apartment to deliver the warrant; a person who had been sleeping on the living room couch asserted that they weren’t sure if Hardwick was home. This caused the officer to search the apartment, and he soon found Hardwick in the bedroom, having oral sex with a man: both men were immediately arrested in the name of sodomy (Bazelon, 2012).

In the 1980s Georgia still defined oral or anal sex between people—be them heterosexuals or homosexuals. This was actually not uncommon at the time, as other states had official laws in place: “…but none really enforced them against consenting adults who were acting in private. In fact, the county prosecutor dropped the charges against Hardwick” (Bazelon, 2012). This official dropping of charges was what most people expected at the time. Many of the laws that were officially on the books and intolerant and unjust weren’t actually enforced. Many people presumably viewed them as relics from another time, and while latent homophobia probably stopped people from wanting to change them, they were passively unenforced.

In the case of Hardwick, things became more complex, as the gay rights movement had wanted an opportunity to officially spar with the constitutionality of the sodomy legislation. Leaders of the gay rights movement encouraged Hardwick to sue and he did (Bazelon, 2012). However, the ultimate ruling in this case showed that homophobia ruled the day and still...

As stated earlier, the district court dismissed Hardwick’s case, without even needing a trial. Hardwick then won an appeal before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, as this panel of judges determined that his innate right to privacy had been sullied (Bazelon, 2012). This ruling was founded in another earlier ruling regarding the individual’s right to privacy and intimate acts. In 1965 the Supreme Court had determined in the case Griswold v. Connecticut, that the state could not block married couples from employing birth control while in the seclusion of their own homes (Bazelon, 2012). To a modern audience, this seems obvious and almost ludicrous that something of this nature would have to go before the official court. However, this serves to demonstrate some of the issues of the era, and the lack of evolution of human thought, along with the general lack of empathy for others. This stunted mentality of human development, justice and tolerance, poisoned Hardwick’s case when it was brought before the Supreme Court, were it was not presented in terms of privacy or other indelible civil rights. Justice Byron White asserted, “The issue presented is whether the Federal Constitution confers a fundamental right upon homosexuals to engage in sodomy” (Bazelon, 2012). The answer turned out to be one of the Supreme Court’s most shameful decisions, and a clear representation that justice had not been served. The Court essentially ruled that homosexuals did not have a fundamental right to engage in sodomy. This decision was clearly representative of the fact that the toxic beliefs that characterized homophobia were still alive and well in the eyes of the Court. This was no doubt reflective of a certain portion of society. While this ruling did occur in the mid-1980s (and not say the more archaic periods of the court that characterized the 1950s), it still clearly demonstrates that to think that homosexuals don’t have a right to express themselves in acts of intimacy, was popular in the era. The rulings of the Supreme Court generally express a certain portion of the overall population, one could argue, looking at history.
In this case, the Supreme Court decided to rule with the more antiquated and bigoted viewpoint of the day. White reached his conclusion by arguing that the…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Constitutional Law the Case of the 'Lawrence
Words: 3461 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Constitutional Law The case of the 'Lawrence vs. Texas' of June 26, 2003, was in a nutshell about privacy rights and 'equal protection' under the law, and whether 'sodomy' can come under the protection of the U.S. Constitution. Who were the Petitioner(s) and the Respondent(s)? The case deals with two gay men, or in other words, homosexual men, that is, men who prefer partners of the same sex, who happened to be

Two Views on Court's Ruling
Words: 1521 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

court ruling 'Two Views on Court's Ruling" (2003) presents the differing opinions of legal analysts Douglas W. Kmiec and Alan Hirsh regarding the Massachusetts Supreme Court decision to extend the legal definition of marriage to include homosexual couples. In the section entitled "Judges overstepped role," Kmiec argues that the Massachusetts ruling "tears at the institution of family upon which all else depends." In spite of his being a constitutional

Four Cases That Involve Constitutional Law
Words: 1440 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Commonwealth v. Johnson.. 1. List the facts relevant to whether Gail and/or William Johnson’s were protected by the First Amendment Gail and William Johnson were convicted for criminal harassment in the state of Massachusetts. State statutes outline specific prohibitions on spoken or behavioral harassment, including the types of cyberharassment techniques used by Gail and William Johnson. The Johnsons claimed that the statute violated First Amendment rights to free speech, claiming that their

Controversial Rape Decisions in Courts
Words: 2258 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Rape Case Law and Jurisprudence Panichas[footnoteRef:2] discriminated between aggravated rape and lesser offenses in a review of Stephen Schulhofer's book Unwanted Sex: The Culture of Intimidation and the Failure of Law. When the use of violence or its threat is used to overcome a victim's lack of consent, immediately before the assault, and this is clearly demonstrated by the evidence presented in court, then aggravated rape has occurred. If, however,

Constitutional Queer the Modern Legal
Words: 1723 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

Nelson -- the decision in which was binding on all lower courts -- was decided in favor of the state law in Minnesota banning same-sex marriages (UMT 2010). Conclusion The issue of the rights of gay, lesbian, and transgendered people are still in a state f flux and some confusion, based on the Supreme Court's rulings on the various matters. On the one hand, there is a legal mandate in place

Should Same Sex Marriages Be Legally Sanctioned
Words: 918 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Same Sex Marriages Should Be Legally Sanctioned Some of the most pervasive problems that exist within American society today are the problems of prejudice, stemming from fear of what is different and seems to be alien. Only by making what is alien seem to wear a more familiar, human face, can such deep-seated hatred be uprooted and destroyed. Prejudice, and the violence that is the result of such hatred, is particularly

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now