Verified Document

Substance Abuse Patterns Of NCAA Article Critique

The subjects of the study are students, but there was no attempt to randomize the sampling. Instead, the authors chose the schools and the athletic programs within the schools. The students self-selected for participation, which also may have affected the participation rates. Because the schools and athletic programs were involved, the subjects may have been wary of the promise of confidentiality, causing the results to have some bias. Singer, von Thurn and Miller (1995) note that when the data is sensitive, confidentiality assurances can improve the quality of responses. However, the confidentiality promise needs to come from the researcher in order to be completely trustworthy. Thus, the methodology introduced some bias into the study with the design of its confidentiality mechanism, and the researchers introduced bias when they failed to randomize school and program selection. The independent variable is the prevalence of drug usage. The dependent variables were the NCAA division, the team, the gender and the race/ethnicity of the respondents. The responses were in the form of categorical variables (yes or no). The responses were subject to Chi-squared analysis to "determine if sport division or ethnic category could differentiate drug-use patterns among collegiate student-athletes" (p.52). This test does provide information regarding the statistical difference between the groups (p.52) but the authors choose not to interpret the data further. The authors discuss the statistical, but not practical significance...

This approach is appropriate, since the role of the study is to inform policy, not set policy.
The issue with the paper lies not with the methods of statistical analysis but rather with the methods of collection. The study design's major flaw is the lack of randomization and the lack of true confidentiality. Given that the sensitivity of the information that the students were asked to provide, better assurances of confidentiality, gained from direct interaction with the researchers, would have been more ethically sound and also would have delivered more accurate response. Further, the lack of randomization could lead to researcher bias interfering with the reliability of the data. This bias risk is not addressed in the paper; this is an oversight on the part of the researchers. Unfortunately, the reliability of the results suffers from these deficiencies, and the study should be read with an understanding of the methodological flaws in mind.

Works Cited:

Green, G., Uryasz, F., Petr, T. & Bray, C. (2001). NCAA study of substance use and abuse habits of college student athletes. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. Vol. 11 (2001) 51-56.

Hart, C. (1999). Doing a literature review: Releasing the social science research imagination. SAGE Publications, Inc.

Singer, E., von Thurn, D. & Miller, E. (1995). Confidentiality assurances and response a quantitative review of the experimental literature. Public Opinion Quarterly. Vol. 59 (1)…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Green, G., Uryasz, F., Petr, T. & Bray, C. (2001). NCAA study of substance use and abuse habits of college student athletes. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. Vol. 11 (2001) 51-56.

Hart, C. (1999). Doing a literature review: Releasing the social science research imagination. SAGE Publications, Inc.

Singer, E., von Thurn, D. & Miller, E. (1995). Confidentiality assurances and response a quantitative review of the experimental literature. Public Opinion Quarterly. Vol. 59 (1) 66-77.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

NCAA Regulations NCAA Rulings and
Words: 6280 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Despite the mixed feelings of many on the issue, however, it seems as though Jeremy Bloom had his rights restricted very strongly by the NCAA, since there was no correlation between the football that he was playing at the University of Colorado and the skiing-related endorsements that he was receiving payment for. Bloom may have given up these rights when he enrolled in the University, but it is suspected that

NCAA As Myles, the Issues Confronting Me
Words: 605 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

NCAA As Myles, the issues confronting me in regards to accepting an offer from a Big East or ACC school virtually all pertain to my future, which is stratified into both short-term and long-term goals. The objectives are of course to embark on a professional sports career in which I am able to provide for my family and my progeny -- which is the long-term goal. The short-term goal is to

NCAA Liability for Head Trauma
Words: 1577 Length: 5 Document Type:

Onyshko v. NCAA Case briefing: Onyshko v. NCAA pending in the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. Recently, the heightened publicity in regards to the dangers of college sports, specifically football, has raised the question of the degree to which colleges and the NCAA have a responsibility both to warn and protect players on teams from participating institutions. The case of Onyshko v. NCAA currently pending in the

NCAA Division I College Male
Words: 2999 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

" (Weatherby & Edmonds, nd) Weatherby & Edmonds (nd) One argument consistently made by individuals that are against paying student-athletes is that the student-athlete receives a free education so in effect they are receiving something for their services. But examining graduation rats of some universities does not support this statement at all. The following is a list with an accompanying chart showing the graduation rates from several universities across the

NCAA Villanova Powerhouse Basketball Team
Words: 640 Length: 2 Document Type:

Since the 1920s, Villanova has been a top contender in the NCAA, rival of other Philadelphia area schools. Yet it was not until 2016 that Villanova really made history. Kris Jenkins’s historic clock-beater shot made this Final Four appearance the most memorable in all of Villanova’s history. Villanova has in many ways always been a threat, whether as a thorn in the side of top seeds or as a top seed

Concussion Management and the NCAA Litigation Case
Words: 1048 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Concussion Management and the NCAA Litigation Case -- Concussion Management The case of Adrian Arrington, Derek Owens, Mark Turner and Angela Palacios v. National Collegiate Athletic Association arose from the consolidation of a On September 12, 2011, a class action filed against the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), Adrian Arrington v. NCAA, on September 12, 2011, and a second lawsuit, Derek Owens et al. v. NCAA. The complaints allege that the NCAA

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now