Abstract
Student loan debt forgiveness has become an increasingly controversial hot-button topic in American higher education today. On one hand, the American system of higher education has grown increasingly expensive. More students have been forced to take out loans to support their education as a result. On the other hand, many people oppose debt forgiveness on financial and ethical grounds. This paper argues in favor of debt forgiveness on principle, and offers a practical solution about how to achieve it.
Student Loan Debt Forgiveness: An Argument in Favor
Student loan debt is crippling young—and many older—Americans. More people are in debt for their educations than at any time in the nation’s history. As a democracy, having an educated populace is considered necessary for government to function, so people are able to vote in an educated fashion. Our society is growing increasingly technologically complex, and greater and more specialized knowledge is needed for it to be competitive and generate new ideas. Yet because of the high cost of education, a new generation of college students is being penalized rather than supported for pursing knowledge and a college degree.
According to Nichols, Bullington, & Gregory (2020), federal student loan debt has grown by 60% in the past 10 years, supporting the notion that education more financially burdensome for the current generation of college graduates. The United States is relatively unusual in this, even compared with other industrialized nations, where tuition and higher education is heavily subsidized. According to The Atlantic, “higher education has become impossibly expensive, saddling 44 million Americans with $1.6 trillion in debt. The cost of a year at a private college is now $37,650, on average, and $10,560 at public institutions” (Lowrey, 2020, par.4). For the average middle-class family, this means that students must take out loans, or their parents (or both).
The economic costs are significant. College graduates report delaying home buying because of having significant debt, even forgoing having children (Lowrey, 2020). Debt-ridden graduates report experiencing significant depression and anxiety, which can...…a significant contribution to society. For example, 75% of all psychology graduates are women (Weiner, 2014).
Opponents to debt forgiveness argue that it would disproportionately favor upper middle-class individuals who take out money for graduate schools and private institution (Chinos, 2017). But the data suggests this is not true, and it could substantially free up the lives and scope of choice of many borrowers, particularly Black and female students, to live more fulfilling lives without being burdened by debt. With debt forgiveness, students could take jobs without the pressure solely of paying student loans, and take into consideration the potential value those jobs could provide for society.
The current proposal of President-elect Joe Biden to forgive debt is relatively modest, up to $10,000 per person for undergraduate debt which would not substantially benefit upper income borrowers (Lowrey, 2020). Even though this would not necessarily be live-changing for all borrowers, it is an important and compassionate first step for freeing a generation suffering from debt as a result of…
References
Chingos, M. M. (2017). The rich get richer. Education Next, 17(4). Retrieved from: https://www.proquest.com
Fields, S. (2019). 70% of college students graduate with debt. How did we get here? Marketplace. Retrieved from: https://www.marketplace.org/2019/09/30/70-of-college-students-graduate-with-debt-how-did-we-get-here/
Lowrey, A. (2020). Go ahead, forgive student debt. The Atlantic. Retrieved from: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/11/why-biden-should-forgive-student-loan-debt/617171/
Nuckols, W., Bullington, K. E., & Gregory, D. E. (2020). Was it worth it? using student loans to finance a college degree. Higher Education Politics & Economics, 6(1), 1-19. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.32674/hepe.v6i1.1358. Retrieved from ProQuest.com:
Weiner, J. (2014). Why sally can't get a good job with her college degree: College-educated women find it hard to get a job because the market doesn't value their bachelor's degree. The Washington Post. Retrieved from: https://www.proquest.com
Improving the Administration and Collection Process for Government-Sponsored Student Loans Introduction Today, tens of thousands of young people are mortgaging part of their future with student loans in order to obtain a higher education. In some cases, these students do not receive the full disclosure concerning repayment terms, creating a long-term hardship. To determine the facts, this paper provides an overview of government student loans and how the different actors on the
Canceling Student Loan Debt for Black StudentsStudent loan debt problem is one of the major social issues in the United States education sector. This problem is fueled by various factors, particularly the fact that tuition fee is outpacing the ability of students to pay. In addition, the percentage of students taking out loans to finance their education continues to increase rapidly. Therefore, policymakers and stakeholders within the education sector are
Government Subsidized Student Loans Have Economic Costs but Political Benefits Higher education has become increasingly important in the contemporary world scenario today where globalization has led to a higher need for a skilled labor force that is mobile and that is well-versed in the academic disciplines followed all over the world. In fact university education is starting to be seen as a hallmark for success, even though there are college drop
Student Loans Dangerous to the Economy? In Sharon Epperson's interview with Sarah Bloom Raskin, it becomes clear that not only are student loans dangerous to the economy, but also that the solution to the student-loan debt crises might have a significant impact on the financial future of multiple generations of Americans. The interview also makes it clear that Bloom Raskin's approach to loan debt does not appear to involve making
College Students Need Personal Finance Education Often, the twenty-first century is referred to as the "Information Age." With a few keystrokes, a large percentage of individuals on the planet is able to access incalculably large databases containing the sum of human knowledge. No longer do students have to toil for hours in paper-based libraries to complete research; most research can be attained in the home via the Internet. Furthermore, individuals can
The choice to borrow money is never an easy one. Kyle needs to consider the loan as an investment in himself. A person like Kyle, who has a clear plan about his future and how he intends to build a career, has solid chances of being able to pay off the loan. It is people who are afraid to take financial risks that end up missing out on opportunities, neither
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now