Verified Document

Student Freedoms Term Paper

¶ … limits that should be placed upon search and seizure in public schools. Apply specific legal rulings to support your position.

Analyze the New Jersey v. T.L.O. case and explain how it supports or undermines your argument.

Recommend changes to existing (specific) laws to create a fairer educational setting in terms of search and seizure.

It seems to me that search and seizure of student and faculty member possession should be scrupulously directed by the Fourth Amendment and the Fifth Amendment and that searches conducted on students should be implemented with the same dignity and in the same manner as they are conducted on faculty members. Research shows that schools are becoming increasingly restrictive in their investigation and that they, frequently, fail to protect even the basic Fourth Amendment privacy rights of the students (Berger, 2003)

The Fourth Amendment prohibits "unreasonable" searches and seizures. It is concerned with the manner that the school may conduct the investigation and ensures that the school does not act in an overly zealous manner. On the one hand, the school cares about the safety of other students and faculty members. This is particularly so given today's rising manifestation of violence in school settings. On...

The school wishes to tread a balanced line. And this is where the guidelines of the Fifth Amendment come in.
The Fifth Amendment is a follow-up to the Fourth Amendment. It says that search and seizure should be preceded by the following two steps:

The employee should give the faculty member / student a chance to tell his or her story

He should inform the faculty member / student about what he intends to do and why

A comparatively minor offence can be addressed by a 'chat' in the principal's office. A more significant offense (such as smuggling of drugs) for instance where penalties that involve criminal charges, potential job loss, and expulsion loom need a more intensive hearing with, possibly, legal representation present.

Instances of where the Fourth Amendment applies would be in the following cases. These, depending on results, may be followed by practice of the Fifth Amendment:

Searching the student's car

Metal-detectors and locker searches

Drug-sniffing dogs on campus (Pinard, 2003))

However, there is a great deal of difference between the tone and intensity of the search conducted on the faculty member and those conducted on students. Contrast will point this out. Faculty staff seems to be accorded more rights than students in regards to the state of search and seizure of their belongings. They are generally granted a greater amount of privacy in regards to their offices, lockers, personal effects, and persons. Schools know that were their case to come to court, they must be prepared to fully justify reasons for their search and the intensity of their search. Searches of possession of faculty member are, therefore, conducted less frequently and on a far less intensive level than they are for students. Exceptions exist in rare cases such as for the search of a gun or when a staff member has permitted the search.

Urinalysis for employees is generally given only on personnel insensitive safety positions, such as on a bus-driver, or on hose who use hazardous substances or operate dangerous equipment and are in frequent contact with students.

Students should also be given greater dignity…

Sources used in this document:
Sources

Berger, R (2003) The "Worst of Both Worlds": School Security and the Disappearing Fourth Amendment Rights of Students Criminal Justice Review Autumn 28 2 336-354

Beyer, D. (1997) School Safety and the Legal Rights of Students. ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban Education. ERIC/CUE Digest, Number 121.

Pinard, M (2003) From the Classroom to the Courtroom: Reassessing Fourth Amendment Standards in Public School Searches Involving Law Enforcement Authorities Ariz. L. Rev., 24, 1

The Center for Public Education. Search and seizure, due process, and public schools http://www.centerforpubliceducation.org/Main-Menu/Public-education/The-law-and-its-influence-on-public-school-districts-An-overview/Search-and-seizure-due-process-and-public-schools.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Freedom and Education United States
Words: 769 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Everyone should be treated as per his/her capabilities not as per hi/her religion. This is what knowledge about the psychology teaches us clearly in all the fields and stages of life. Education is a wide subject in which so many fields are included. The government of any country should try to plan education curriculum in such a way that the modern requirements are properly met. Education is always an independent

Freedom of Association Facts the
Words: 1997 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

S. citizens. In this program designed to help young ones value the freedoms they currently experience: according to Tyler Barnwell, stands for grievance, as in "to petition the government for a redress of grievances." which denotes religious freedom, Leslie Anne Hill, a Presbyterian, states: "means you don't have to follow a certain religion." stands for freedom of assembly, Sherri Jones states is "the right to get together with other people peaceably, but

Students' Right to Free Speech the Right
Words: 1540 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Students' Right to Free Speech The right of student to free speech is a matter that has been debated over years. Where many people claim that students, just like any other group of people, have the right of free speech, others claim that students should know where their limits end. Therefore, at many schools, colleges and universities, the students are provided with a code of conduct that they have to follow.

Freedom Riders
Words: 652 Length: 2 Document Type: Reaction Paper

Freedom Riders The purpose of the Freedom Rides was to draw attention to the racial disparities and racism that existed in the United States in 1961 at the time of the rides. The riders were going to ride on integrated buses through the South where the racism was most intense. They were looking to encounter situations in which there was prejudice and bigotry so that they could provide an example to

Freedom of Speech There Was
Words: 1025 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

"[T]here remains a distinction between autonomy, the ability to think for oneself, and self-expression, the communicating of one's thoughts to others. Both are important components of our interest in free speech" (Lichtenberg, 336). Still some believe that any infringement upon the media would diminish the amount of true information disseminated into society. Truth, though, is filled with ambiguity and is intangible -- the "truth" of the media story is based

Student Unrest and Its Connection
Words: 985 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

The line of reasoning behind this behavior was to bring the war home in order to raise awareness. At this point, the protests seemed out of control and the war did as well. However, while things seemed out of control, students could rest assured that they were making their point well-known. Student protests did influence the war in that the government realized that something needed to be done. Gianoulis notes,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now