Verified Document

Student Assessment: The Superiority Of Thesis

In addition, teacher-based methods of assessment have at least one positive implication for students. According to Flood et al., teacher-based assessments allow teachers to enter the process of scaffolding with significant foreknowledge. Flood et al. (2003). suggests that all good assessment includes a component in which a teacher plans and sets goals, and then collecting data and interpreting it. This can be done in the classroom or at the macro level -- applicable to either the school itself or the state. Teachers can use the data gleaned from teacher-centered assessment as a means by which to identify areas of weakness and address them (Kearns, 2009). Standardized testing and teacher-based testing in classrooms allows teachers to determine where most students are having problems and use scaffolding techniques to intervene on the student's behalf and move them to a higher level of achievement. While these benefits are certainly important and crucial to the running of an institution of academic learning, many have risen up against standardized testing in schools. Wortham (2003) notes that through No Child Left Behind, "there is no doubt that mandates for increased standards-based testing will continue in spite of concerns of their relevancy" (para. 6). The relevancy issue comes into play when one examines why standardized tests are used in the schools. Schools are essentially graded based on students' performance on standardized tests. The performance determines what kind of funding they will receive and whether or not they will be subjected to more federal control in their schools. Further, standardized tests may carry high stakes for the students. They may be responsible for a student's graduation or movement to the next grade level. These kinds of issues encourage teachers and students to think about the test and only the test. Thus, an appreciation for learning or for the subjects at hand is almost completely ignored by the use of teacher-based assessments such as these. In addition, in the classroom, when students know they are being graded through teacher-based assessment tools, such as exams, they engage in practices such as cramming, in which they attempt to learn as much as they can for the test itself and forget it promptly after. All of these practices do not have the benefits associated with student-centered assessment. While student-centered assessment prepares students for a world in which they will face more challenging assessments, assessments from their bosses or family members, assessments in which they will be expected to consult others and finally make a choice, teacher-based assessment methods prepare students for one thing only -- taking more tests.

This being said, there are clearly benefits to teacher-based assessment, as student-based assessments cannot provide the kind of data that teacher-based assessments can. Further, teacher-based assessments allow students to understand the importance of the standards that the teacher has identified before the beginning of the lesson. The importance of these standards is emphasized for the student, as he or she begins to realize they are the most important items on the test. This allows students, who are presented with a great deal of information each day, to begin to prioritize. Thus, teacher-based assessments surely have their place. It is important that standardized tests be continually used as a means through which to gain relevant data. Teachers can continue to use them in the classroom in order to determine the makeup...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

This way, teachers can address those issues that their students are having the most trouble with. Standardized tests alone should not, however, be used as a means of obtaining information for high stakes. Students who perform poorly on this kind of teacher-based assessment may be responding to the assessment rather than the material itself. This is especially true if the students' teacher was using a student-based method of instruction. Thus, like methods of instruction, methods of assessment should consist of a mixture of student-based and teacher-based assessment with high stakes resting on a combination of both assessments and a focus on teacher-based assessments simply for data collection.
In conclusion, the subject of assessments in the elementary grades has been one of great debate since the No Child Left Behind Act. Currently, there are two trends in teacher assessment -- student-based assessment and teacher-based assessment. While student-based assessments are superior in gauging learning and helping students continue on a journey of learning throughout their lives, student-based assessments are superior when it comes to collecting data and seeing where the class as a whole stands on a certain set of material. For this reason, it is important to conduct assessments using both teacher-based and student-based methods. However, teachers must use caution when conducting these sorts of assessments. For instance, they must be sure that external variables, such as grant money and state recognition do not result in their "teaching the test" to students. On the other hand, teachers must also be sure that their assessment methods actually assess the material they have been presenting to students in the way that they have been presenting it. As these trends continue to develop, one can hope that they will learn how to complement each other in order to make assessment a learning process for students and teachers.

References

Chall, J.S. & Adams, M.J. (2002). The Academic Achievement Challenge: What Really

Works in the Classroom. New York: Guilford.

Flood, J. et al. (2003). The Handbook of Research on Teaching the English Language

Arts 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Kern, A. (2009 February 4). Benefits of Standardized Testing. Retrieved June 19, 2009,

from Quiddity. Web Site: http://quidditycirce.wordpress.com/2009/02/04/benefits-of-standardized-testing/

LaLopa, M. (2005-2006). Using Student-Centered Assessment to Enhance Learning.

Retrieved June 18, 2009, from Essays on Teaching Excellence. Web Site:: / / thunder1.cudenver.edu/CFD/publications/teaching_excellence/17_student_centered_assessment.html

"Strategy/Implicit Instruction in Mathematics." (n.d.). Retrieved June 18, 2009, from The

Access Center. Web Site: http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/Strategy_ImplicitInstructionandMath.asp

UCD Centre for Teaching and Learning. (n.d.) International trends in Assessment.

Retrieved June 18, 2009, from the University College Dublin. Web Site: http://www.ucd.ie/teaching/goodPracticeAssessment_sub/Assessment%20Trendshtml

Wortham, S.C. (2008). Current Issues and Trends in Assessment in Early Childhood

Education. Retrieved June 18, 2009, from Education.com Web Site: http://www.education.com/reference/article/current-issues-assessment-early-childhood/

Sources used in this document:
References

Chall, J.S. & Adams, M.J. (2002). The Academic Achievement Challenge: What Really

Works in the Classroom. New York: Guilford.

Flood, J. et al. (2003). The Handbook of Research on Teaching the English Language

Arts 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lawrence Erlbaum.
from Quiddity. Web Site: http://quidditycirce.wordpress.com/2009/02/04/benefits-of-standardized-testing/
Access Center. Web Site: http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/Strategy_ImplicitInstructionandMath.asp
Retrieved June 18, 2009, from the University College Dublin. Web Site: http://www.ucd.ie/teaching/goodPracticeAssessment_sub/Assessment%20Trendshtml
Education. Retrieved June 18, 2009, from Education.com Web Site: http://www.education.com/reference/article/current-issues-assessment-early-childhood/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Pesticde Assessment Methods Community Health Board of
Words: 1773 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Pesticde Assessment Methods Community Health Board of Directors FROM: John E. Brown, Commissioner on Agriculture The Assessment of the Use of Pesticides on the Human Population Food safety is multidimensional especially as it pertains to the use of industrial chemicals in food production. There are a variety of chemicals used directly in food production including fertilizers being added to soil to promote growth of food and flavorings used to enhance food appeal. Stabilizers

Ineffective Assessment Methods for a Test to
Words: 1430 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Ineffective Assessment Methods For a test to be accepted within the academic community, it must be both reliable and valid. A reliable test produces consistent results. A valid tests measures what it purports to measure. A good example of reliability is the 'kitchen scale' example. If you weigh the same cup of flour and it is 4 ounces, then 4.25 ounces, then 4.5 ounces on various attempts to use the

Staffing Organizations-Assessment Methods Various Techniques
Words: 671 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This critical test analyses an applicant's aptitude in solving job related problems through providing details about their mental abilities like mathematical and verbal reasoning. This includes speed in recognizing alphabetical letters. This test would be useful because it has proved to elicit valid inferences for numerous organizational benefits (Heneman, Judge & Kammeyer-Mueller, 2012). Personal characteristics inventory In my selection process, I will be measuring traits in working settings such as conscientiousness,

Assessment Methods Discrimination
Words: 621 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Gale, S.F. (April - 2003). "Putting job candidates to the test." Workforce Today, 64-68. Retrieved 30, November 2004: http://www.workforce.com/archive/feature/23/42/11/index.php The article Putting Job Candidates to the Test by Sarah Fister Gale discusses accurate assessments for job candidates. Gale suggests that accurate assessments will reduce interviewing time and ensure that corporations do everything possible to hire quality candidates rather than unproductive one. The article provides an analysis of three company's pre-employment screening measures.

Assessment and Special Education
Words: 1334 Length: 4 Document Type: Article Review

Special Education Assessment Options There were a number of eminent points and observations regarding the methodology of assessment utilized within Maryellen Weimer's article, "Making exams more about learning," which initially appeared in The Teaching Professor in 2011. This article essentially functions as a case study in which an undergraduate instructor, Thomas Smith, employed a number of unusual methods to assist his students with the process of assessment. Among the measures that

Assessment Center Approach
Words: 1832 Length: 6 Document Type: Business Proposal

CEO who asked for a short report on strategic human resource management was impressed with the report. Following the reading of the research on strategic human resource management and considering how senior individuals in the organization are selected the Assessment Center Approach caught the attention of the CEO. The objective of this work is to prepare a proposal that includes a description of this approach as well as methods

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now