¶ … strengths of job control unionism? The major weaknesses? Has job control unionism outlived its usefulness?
Before unions were legal and powerful in the United States, workers were often subject to horrific abuses at the hands of factory owners. Workers labored for long hours and little pay, and were often fired if they were injured. Workers had little bargaining power or leverage. Unions have had great influence in ensuring workers are fairly compensated for their time, including overtime, and that worker's long-term service to companies is rewarded. Unions also reduce wage inequality between white and blue-collar workers. Unionized workers have higher wages, more benefits, and more vacation time than non-unionized workers in similar types of employment (Mishel & Walters 2003).
Unfortunately, many powerful companies such as GM are feeling the burden of agreeing to overly generous benefits for retired workers, including extensive medical benefits and pensions. Unions can extract such a high price from employers that the company is hurt, and past and present employees suffer as the company's fortunes flag. Additionally, there is also the contention that unions, such as teacher's unions, favor workers who are in the union or are loyal to the union rather than competent at their jobs. The teacher's union defends the practice of tenure, which makes teachers difficult to fire after a certain number of years, while a younger and untenured individual might be superior in the position.
Today, in America, a non-unionized company is more likely to provide extensive benefits to workers to attract the best employees. There is a less adversarial relationship between management and labor: the most desirable companies to work for in America, such as Google, Facebook, and Starbucks boast how their nonunionized workforces have everything from vision care to free or discounted food. Traditional, blue-collar or skilled assembly line work has been outsourced to cheaper and nonunionized workforces overseas. While the benefits of unionization had a positive impact upon American history, with the exception of a few industries and professions, such as auto workers and teachers, the traditional trade union seems to have become a thing of the past for a larger and larger percentage of American workers.
Work Cited
Mishel, Lawrence & Matthew Walters. How unions help all workers.
The Economic Policy Institute. August 26, 2003. February 16, 2010. http://www.epi.org/publications/entry/briefingpapers_bp143/
During that time he was director of labour market policies, coordinated technical work in eastern Europe following the collapse of the Berlin wall and was director of the ILO's Socio-Economic Security Program. In 1998-99, he served as a member of the transition team of the new Director General Juan Somavia. It would be fair to say that he knows the ILO inside out. Now Professor of Economic Security at
Emotional Labor Implications on a Call Centre During the last two decades Contact or call centers have emerged as the answer to cost effectiveness for all sort of businesses that require back end customer services (Boreham et al., 2007). These call centers hailing from different countries are very similar with respect to markets, offered services, structure of the organization and type of workforce. This industry has flourished very quickly but usually these
This amount of leverage is rare in more standardized industries where management can break pickets with contract labor. We see them affecting public opinion through their press releases and media control, which portrays management as derisive. This attempts to pinch off donations, which is a battle of attrition that will hurt the musicians in the end, but they are willing to sacrifice this in order to win the race to
Public Sector Unions Public-Sector Unions in United States HISTORY OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS COSTS OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS OVER THEIR BENEFITS DEMOGRAPHICS OF LABOR IN AMERICA EDGE OF PUBLIC-SECTOR UNIONS OVER PRIVATE ONES THE HIDDEN COSTS OF PUBLIC UNIONS THE DISTORTION OF DEMOCRATIC POLITICS STATE UNIONS VS. FEDERAL UNIONS THE FUTURE OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONIZATION HISTORY OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS Labor unions are seen as the representatives of the labor employed in our industries and are known as the advocates of
The internal split amongst major union movements, however, has not helped. Both major groups have essentially the same goals, but clearly differ on the best ways to achieve those goals. Critics contend, however, that the movement needs solidarity in the face of declining relevance. The split, despite the ideological differences, also had a personal component to it, and this weakness at the top levels of union leadership inhibits their ability
Women and the Home Front in Western North Carolina and Eastern Tennessee during the Civil War This paper examines the living conditions and attitudes that shaped the lives of the women in western North Carolina and eastern Tennessee during and after the American Civil War. The thesis statement should deal with the breakdown of long standing ties between the people of the mountains as they chose to fight for the
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now