Verified Document

States Power And The 17th Amendment Why States Lost Essay

17th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution was ratified in 1913. It altered the way in which Senators of the Congress were elected. Previously, under Article 1 of the Constitution, it was the state legislature's responsibility to elect senators to Congress. With the 17th Amendment, however, the voting power was placed directly into the hands of the public. The Amendment also provided a way for states to allow governors to fill vacancies in their state's appointed seats in Congress by temporarily appointing a senator until a time in which a special election could be conducted. The text of the Amendment states specifically that "two Senators from each State, elected by the people thereof, for six years" shall be the manner in which senators are now voted into office. This effectively made the process of electing senators more democratic and less representational, in the sense that that the voting public had the power to choose its congressional representative directly as opposed to having the state legislature act as a middle man between the voting public and its representatives in Congress.

What was the effect of this new Amendment on American politics? First it is necessary to understand how the political scene was established prior to the passing of the Amendment. Under the original draft of the Constitution, the state legislature was empowered with the ability to determine the state's elected senators for a six-year term. One of the advantages of this order was that with the states recognizing a central government to which each was bound (rather than all the states acting as a loose federation, which was the case prior to the adoption of the Constitution), anti-federalists (who were a strong and adamant group of citizens opposed to a central government) could breathe more easily believing that the states could have some degree...

The state legislature thus retained a degree of autonomy from both the populist form of government (represented by the House of Representatives, the other wing of the bicameral Congress) and from the encroachment of federal authorities. Thus, the original method of electing senators was simply an exercise that afford state legislatures more authority than they otherwise would have -- and at a time when anti-federalist sentiment was strong, this idea was a positive one in terms of ensuring that individual states retained some strength.
However, as time wore on, objections were made that state legislatures were susceptible to corruption and could not be trusted to pick senators -- that the election process should be placed directly into the hands of citizens. The other problem with states being allowed to vote senators into office was the issue of electoral deadlocks (Bybee 538). These two problems went together and created an atmosphere of distrust among the public, which began to believe that rather than helping the states to maintain some autonomy in the face of the central government, the Constitution as it was written on this matter was actually undermining the authority of the people, who believed they were now being manipulated and controlled by corrupt officials within the state legislature.

Examples of this suspicion were evident in the fact that in the latter half of the 19th century, there were three Senate investigations into corruption related charges over elections. In the very first year of the 20th century, in fact, William Clark's election to the Senate by his state legislature was overturned and ruled null because the investigatory committee found that his election had been the result of purchased votes…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Bybee, Jahy. "Ulysees at the Mast." Northwestern University Law Review, vol. 91, no. 1

(1997): 530-564.

Zwicki, Todd. "Beyond the Shell and Husk of History." Cleveland State Law Review, vol. 45, no. 1 (1997): 1021-1034.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Catholic Church in Spain and the United States
Words: 12567 Length: 40 Document Type: Term Paper

Catholic Church in Spain and the United States The Catholic Church has been a very significant religious and political institution in the Europe. Its origins can be traced to a thousand years when Christianity was itself in its infancy. It was a symbol of colossal authority and was much regarded as an institution that was as similar to the installed governmental mechanism of any nation state. Its power and influence spread

European Union Member States Relations With Their Overseas Territories...
Words: 17554 Length: 50 Document Type: Thesis

political framework of EU and OCT European Union (EU) and Overseas Countries and Territories (OCTs) are in association with each other via a system which is based on the provisions of part IV of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU), consisting of detailed rules and measures which are laid down in the document issued on 27th November 2001 title Oversees Association Decision. The expiry date of this

United States Is the Diversity
Words: 5913 Length: 18 Document Type: Assessment

Because of the newer mobility of a significant amount of suburban America, driving to national parks was even more an option. The more people visited the Parks, it seemed, the more of a synergistic effect upon their funding and use (Jensen and Guthrie, 2006). By the Johnson Administration in the 1960s, coupled with more media attention, there was increased public awareness of America's natural treasures. This was now that "Parks

How Did the Constitution Satisfy Complaints
Words: 2341 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

United States Constitution concentrates on. It will address how it treated the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and the complaints in the Declaration of Independence. How the Constitution Deals with Weaknesses in the Articles of Confederation One key factor that has helped keep the constitution of the United States alive is the processes involved in its amendment. These processes require 2/3 majority votes from the two houses of Congress or

Territorial Expansion How Did the U.S. Acquire
Words: 1300 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Territorial Expansion How did the U.S. acquire the territory in question? On the auspicious date of April 30, 1803, the United States of America bought eight hundred and twenty eight thousand square miles worth of land from the French government of Napoleon Bonaparte. Thomas Jefferson, the President of America, wanted to secure this deal. Wars were rampaging overseas in the continent of Europe and Napoleon had intentions to safeguard what he had acquired

Illegal Immigrants in the U.S.
Words: 2196 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

So who is an American and what an America can or cannot do are questions which are critical to the issue of legalizing immigrants. Does being an American mean you cannot show allegiance to any other country? The images of people raising and waving Mexican flag had enraged many but it need not have. It should be accepted that people who come from different countries would forever hold in their

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now