Verified Document

Stakeholder Assessment Of Legislation To Place Fluoride In Water Essay

Policy Assessment of a Fluoridation Policy from the Perspective of Different Stakeholders

When examining the different potential; perspectives of different stakeholders, it is important to note that many of the concerns and issues are not mutually exclusive to the different stakeholders and different perspectives. The following matrix presents some of the potential views of different stakeholders from different perspectives.

Stakeholders:

Possible perspectives held by these stakeholders:

Conservative

Liberal

Legal

Religious

Ethical

Cultural

Societal

Economic

Legislators

Legislation is needed to enforce what has been a voluntary measure in the past, as many communities have not yet adopted the practice. The benefits outweigh the cost, and it is cost effective to add fluoride to the water; saving between $8 and $49 for each $1 spent (CDC, 2013).

Individual freedoms should be protected; placing fluoride in the water forces all those who use the water to consume the fluoride, without any choice or autonomy, and possibly without their knowledge.

There may be concern for the potential of a legal challenge to legislation forcing fluoridation from the opponents. Other legislation, such as Obamacare has faced legal challenges. There may be concerns that it may be seen as unconstitutional under the 14th amendment, undermining personal liberty in terms of freedom of choice over bodily health...

However, this is not complete liberty and reasonable regulation is allowed (Strong, 1967)
The act may be seen as breaching the first amendment where there is no law to be passed which breaches the free exercise of religion. Some religions believe that there should not be interference, for example the Christian Science Church, where there is meant to be sole reliance on God for health (Strong, 1967). Claims for this have failed in the past but it does not prevent the potential belief by some in the legislature.

It is ethical to impose a measure that will provide a greater benefit than the associated cost, and fluoridation will create significant benefits.

Legislators to pass bills they believe their electorate will support, if they pass unpopular legislation they are unlikely to be elected in the following terms. Legislators must believe it is in the benefits of their electorate and has sufficient support to pass the bill, or that if it is not popular, it will not be sufficiently unpopular to result in failure to be re-elected.

Society needs to be protected form itself, especially as the state is bearing the cost of bad choices through healthcare costs. Imposing fluoridation will be a benefit to society.

Legislator consider budgets,…

Sources used in this document:
The firm should be able to respond to market needs; if the customers want fluoride in the water they will demand it, and water companies will need to provide it, it should be left to market forces.

May be concern regarding potential liability is it is later proven there are health risks associated with fluoride. May also have concerns regarding specific risks / liabilities to high risk individuals, such as those on dialysis (National Kidney Foundation, 2008).

There may also be concerns regarding the issue of compliance, how it will be checked and
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Stakeholders International Business the Business World Has
Words: 1475 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Stakeholders International Business The business world has seen many evolutions over the centuries. One constant, however, remains that the central premise of business has always been to provide in a perceived need; whether this need has been somewhat created and artificially perceived, or manifests itself as an actual need. Businesses have also always had stakeholders. The way in which businesses have managed their relationships with stakeholders have, however, also significantly evolved.

Stakeholders in Home Health Care
Words: 994 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Stakeholders in Home Health Care Stakeholders In thinking about the info set out in the previous researches we have to keep in mind that the overarching rationale for the participation of any of the stakeholders is the advantageous results that their participation gives them or to those they stand for, instances of these results are set out in the table. When it come to governments this could well be renovations in hygienics,

Stakeholders Is Any Company Too Big to
Words: 1073 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Stakeholders Is any company too big to fail? That was the question of the day facing political leaders in September 2008 as the market was rocked by a series of announcements from AIG and other companies concerning what some experts would call catastrophic losses from mortgage-backed securities. AIG happened to be the ringleader of those companies as it announced that it lost nearly $25 billion in one quarter. The U.S. government

Stakeholders in Clinical Research Trials There Are
Words: 678 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Stakeholders in Clinical Research Trials There are various stakeholders involved in clinical trials. These include, but they are not limited to, funding agencies, the patient, the government, regulatory and oversight boards, the general public, insurers (if any), and the industry. In essence, these stakeholders not only influence, but also contribute to the process as well as outcome of clinical trials in a variety of ways. Below, I concern myself with three

Stakeholders the Topic at Hand Is Whether
Words: 1018 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Stakeholders The topic at hand is whether businesses can rely on the premise that profit alone is the end-all be-all of what drives a business and what its endgame should be or whether it should focus at least somewhat on social and corporate responsibility even if it's at the expense of some or many dollars of profit. The author will compare these two disparate viewpoints and offer an overall viewpoint that

Stakeholders Research Project
Words: 1483 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Stakeholders Research Project Introduction Preliminary stakeholder identification around any natural resource proves vital to carrying out meaningful trans- disciplinary researches with regard to managing that particular resource. Stakeholders may be defined as all players capable of impacting, or being impacted by, any action or decision (after Freeman 1984). Natural resource management research scholars (e.g. Grimble and Wellard 1997; Dougill et al. 2006; Ravnborg and Westermann 2002) constantly report that the inclusion of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now