Verified Document

Special Needs Students High Stakes Thesis

While some suggest that high-stakes testing is an inadequate way of measuring the academic achievement and learning of most students, many also agree that high-stakes testing has severe disadvantages for special education students. Kymes points out that high-stakes testing may be a discriminatory assessment method for special needs students, placing an "unfair burden" on these students. The scholar argues that testing plans cannot be created for each and every student, and even when they can, these testing plans are not always put into practice (Kymes). In addition, Ralabate notes the importance of finding alternate testing methods that allow students with disabilities to perform to their highest ability.

Determining that high-stakes testing is not a correct method of assessment for special needs students, however, is just half of the task at hand. In fact, significant information exists to argue that students with disabilities, in addition to schools, can be seriously harmed by these assessment methods. First, Kymes notes that special needs students who are assessed using a high-stakes testing method may feel like failures, suffer from low self-esteem and other emotional health problems, and even drop out of school. Instead of focusing on leaving no child behind, therefore, this type of testing may actually encourage students to leave themselves behind -- for good. Second, Kymes also writes that students "often feel personally responsible for their district's failure to receive...awards" because such awards are based on test scores. Similarly, as test scores determine what schools are penalized and which are rewarded, schools with high populations of special education students may be the unfair recipients of such penalties. This could lead schools to encourage special...

Bush in order to reform education. Unfortunately, its prime assessment tool is high-stakes testing, upon which schools can receive either rewards or penalties. Because this testing has been long questioned as to its validity, students, parents, and teachers cannot be sure that the assessment is accurate for any student. Furthermore, the problem is compounded for special education students, who often cannot perform to the best of their ability on these tests. The use of the tests not only penalizes the school districts, therefore, but also the students, who may suffer from emotional problems and guilt due to the assessment model. Thus, as Ralabate suggests, different assessment models must be perused in order to make NCLB more inclusive and fair to special education students.
Works Cited

Fact Sheet: No Child Left Behind. 8 January 2002. The White House. 19 November 2008. http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/01/20020108.html

Kymes, Nancy. "The No Child Left Behind Act: A Look at Provisions, Philosophies, and Compromises." Journal of Industrial Teacher Education. 41.2 (2004) 19 November 2008. http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/JITE/v41n2/kymes.html

Marlow, Ediger. Assessment and High Stakes Testing. Speech, 2001. Educational

Resource Information Center. ED449234.

Ralabate, Patti. Statement of Patti Ralabate Submitted by NEA to Aspen Institute's

Commission on No Child Left Behind. 2 August 2006. National Education Association. 19 November 2008. http://www.nea.org/lac/esea/080206testi.html

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Fact Sheet: No Child Left Behind. 8 January 2002. The White House. 19 November 2008. http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/01/20020108.html

Kymes, Nancy. "The No Child Left Behind Act: A Look at Provisions, Philosophies, and Compromises." Journal of Industrial Teacher Education. 41.2 (2004) 19 November 2008. http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/JITE/v41n2/kymes.html

Marlow, Ediger. Assessment and High Stakes Testing. Speech, 2001. Educational

Resource Information Center. ED449234.
Commission on No Child Left Behind. 2 August 2006. National Education Association. 19 November 2008. http://www.nea.org/lac/esea/080206testi.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Service Providers on Special Student Achievement Students
Words: 6882 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

Service Providers on Special student Achievement Students all over the world face the problem of getting low grades in their educational career. There are various factors which play a significant role in student achievement. Certain entities which play a role in student achievement includes, but not limited to, ELL teachers, counselors, occupational therapists, speech therapists and physical therapists. For the purpose of this study, we have selected Sto-Lo Youth Healing

Special Education Teacher's Impressions of
Words: 8246 Length: 30 Document Type: Term Paper

Thus, efforts aimed at helping teachers to avoid harmful stereotyping of students often begin with activities designed to raise teachers' awareness of their unconscious biases." (1989) Cotton goes on the relate that there are specific ways in which differential expectations are communicated to students according to the work of: "Brookover, et al. (1982); Brophy (1983); Brophy and Evertson (1976); Brophy and Good (1970); Cooper and Good (1983); Cooper and

Special Education - Inclusion the
Words: 12387 Length: 45 Document Type: Term Paper

In their study, "Thinking of Inclusion for All Special Needs Students: Better Think Again," Rasch and his colleagues (1994) report that, "The political argument in favor of inclusion is based on the assumption that the civil rights of students, as outlined in the 1954 decision handed down in Brown v. Board of Education, which struck down the concept of 'separate but equal,' can also be construed as applying to special

Student Centered Teaching Progressivism, Social
Words: 6624 Length: 21 Document Type: Term Paper

Now we have examined two extremes in educational thought that have developed over the past century. Teacher centered and student centered philosophies differ significantly in their approach to the student-teacher relationship. Teacher centered philosophy does not depend on the student's wants and needs at all. Teacher centered philosophy uses antiquated methods, such as rote learning. However, these methods are quickly being replaced by a more student-centered approach. Student centered approaches

Special Education Assessment Has Played
Words: 989 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

"By the 1980s, the field had moved to a functional skills model. As the evidence for this approach mounted, the field refocused on age appropriate skills and knowledge performed in authentic settings and the functional life skills curriculum became best practice. The functional, age-appropriate curricular focus resulted in these students demonstrating skills and knowledge not thought possible earlier" (Quenemoen, 2008). In the 1990s, added significant new practices were acknowledged as

Special Education Director Leadership Styles
Words: 11099 Length: 40 Document Type: Thesis

More importantly, our appreciative and participatory stance with our co-researchers has allowed us to witness and learn about the cutting edge of leadership work in such a way that is and feels qualitatively different from other research traditions we have used in the past, because it is built on valuing. Even though it is challenging at times (Ospina et al. 2002), our inquiry space is enhanced by our collaboration

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now