Verified Document

Spanglish: Positives And Negatives Term Paper

Related Topics:

Spanglish Is the use of Spanglish seen as a term of "disparagement," as linguistics Professor Ricardo Otheguy asserts? Or is the mixing of English into Spanish "helpful" and "…as normal as breathing and as natural as life itself" to the ethnic mix of Latinos and Anglos in Southern California and elsewhere, as journalist Kimberly Ortiz insists? This paper presents both sides of the issue; some say that using Spanglish as a hybrid language is a bastardized version of English and Spanish; others believe Spanglish, besides being here to stay, is perfectly legitimate as an alternative kind of language.

The Positives Relating to Spanglish

PBS NewsHour host Ray Suarez interviewed author Ilan Stavans about Stavans' book, Spanglish: The Making of a New American Language. Stavans is the president of Latin America and Latino culture at Amherst College and he steadfastly defends Spanglish as a "…way of communication where one starts in one language, switches to the other" and goes back and forth or "perhaps coins a few new words…" along the way (PBS). Stavans adds that Spanglish is "a very creative jazzy way of being Latino in the U.S. today" (PBS).

Host Suarez questions whether Spanglish is truly a language, and to that Stavans answers that Spanglish may be in the "process" of becoming a language. And Stavans adds that there is really not one single version of Spanglish because Cuban Americans in Miami have their own particular version and Mexican-Americans have theirs as well. He equates the different versions of Spanglish with the dramatic differences within the Latino community: there are "…a number of different Latinos" including those of Puerto Ricans heritage, of Mexican heritage, the Cubans and Venezuelans as well (PBS, p. 2).

Stavans makes a good point when he says that every time another immigrant group arrives in the U.S., that group in time "wants to become part of the so-called melting pot" and hence there is a "period of transition" between the immigrants' native language and the acquisition of English -- and the two become blended in some fashion unique...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

2).
In his book, mentioned on the first page, Stavans agrees that "Yes, it is the tongue of the uneducated," and "Yes, it's a hodgepodge," but the professor goes on to say that the evolution of Spanglish is legitimate, and moreover it reminds him of how jazz got started (Stavans, 2004, 3). African-American musicians who hadn't necessarily been to music school and learned the hardcore basics they nonetheless began creating improvisations with their music -- hence, jazz evolved. Stavans references a comment by iconic jazz legend Herbie Hancock, who was asked to explain jazz, and replied: "It is something very hard to define, but very easy to recognize" (5).

Kimberly Ortiz writing in the Southwestern College publication, The Sun, says some purists see Spanglish as "unprofessional" and they claim it reflects "a loss of culture." But she explains that it is hard to always transition from one language to another, and some words simply don't "translate well or at all in English and vice versa" (Ortiz, 2014). Ortiz believes rather than "ruining and disrespecting English and Spanish," she believes that Spanglish "honors both"; and besides, she goes on, it is used "primarily in casual settings with friends and family" (p. 1).

Moreover, she does not accept that Spanglish is "slang," and in fact Spanglish is used in English courses at Southwestern College, including English 116 -- a class called "The Latino Reader," in which Latino writers use Spanglish to "further express their feelings in their poems and stories" (Ortiz, p. 1).

The Negatives Related to Spanglish

Linguistics Professor Ricardo Otheguy insists that there should be a "rejection" of the term "Spanglish" because "…there is no objective justification for the team" (Otheguy, 2010). The professor goes on, saying Spanglish expresses "an ideology of exceptionalism and scorn" that he believed "deprives" Latinos in North America of a "major resource," which is the "mastery of a world language" (85).

As was mentioned in the Introduction to this paper, Otheguy finds Spanglish a…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Chappell, Sharon, and Faltis, Christian. "Spanglish, Bilingualism, Culture and Identity in Latino

Children's Literature." Children's Literature in Education, 38.4, 253-262. 2007.

Jover-Cirillo, Silvina. "Spanglish: Identity Preservation or Language destruction?" New

Generation Latino Consortium. Retrieved April 16, 2014, from http://nglc.biz 2011.
from http://www.theswsun.com. 2014.
PBS NewsHour. "American Varieties: Spanglish!" Retrieved April 16, 2014, from http://www.pbs.org.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

American Exceptionalism
Words: 704 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

American Exceptionalism When the American electorate re-elected George W. Bush as their President in November 2004, the rest of the world shook its head in collective amazement. They could not understand how someone the world 'loved to hate' and who, in their opinion, had committed 'monumental blunders' in his four years in office, could be chosen by so many Americans as their leader. They need not have been surprised having been

American Exceptionalism Refers to Allegedly
Words: 1214 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

When we speak of Puritanical values, however, some events in America's history seriously clash with its "pure values" or its belief that it's a world liberator. The first one was slavery. No where in the world have we witnessed just harsh case of slavery as in the United States. To this day, African-Americans have been unable to liberate themselves completely from the ugly history of slavery that had seriously marred

American Exceptionalism Is a Concept
Words: 1870 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

" This view appears to be excessively negative, not least because of its lack of balance. It fails to acknowledge balance and uses all arguments to the contrary to perpetuate itself. Neither the view of American exceptionalism being wholly good or wholly bad is therefore entirely realistic. Much more realistic is perhaps Koh's view, although it still tends towards the somewhat negative side. I do agree with this author in terms

American Exceptionalism Is a Matter of Perspective
Words: 689 Length: 2 Document Type: Chapter

American Exceptionalism While some believe that America is truly exceptional, others believe that it is just another country in history that has many of the same problems that other countries have. Furthermore, some people even go further towards the opposite end of the spectrum, against the idea of the U.S. being exceptional in any way, and believe that its actions and its presence are largely counterproductive among world affairs. For example,

American Exceptionalism A Debate
Words: 1318 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The Myth of American Exceptionalism The myth of American exceptionalism is a familiar one to Americans and non-Americans alike. It suggest that America, as the home of the free and the brave, is unique in its allowance of freedom and social mobility, in contrast to Europe, Asia, and other, much older civilizations. Yet as noted by Stephen M. Walt in his essay, “The Myth of American Exceptionalism,” perhaps one of the

American and European Values How
Words: 1192 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

To wit, "half of Americans deem religion very important in their lives; fewer than a quarter in Spain (22%) feel this way, and in Germany (21%), Britain (17%) and France (13%), even fewer say religion is "very important" to their lives (PEW). Fifty-three percent of Americans are more apt to agree that it is vital to believe in God prior to having good morals and values while just 33% of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now