Verified Document

Socrates And Gorgias By Plato, Essay

Related Topics:

This is really the extent of Gorgias attempting to remove himself from Socrates' argument, but instead, pulls him deeper into the intellectual trap, for Gorgias has only one misgiving about the entire situation . . . he fears that the crowd of onlookers might be disinterested in two men trying to outdo each other in being wrong (458b-c). Thus, Gorgias proves two things: he cannot intellectually handle a multi-layered discussion and he needs an audience in order to perform -- the basics of dialog and intellectual discourse are lost upon him. If then, Gorgias needs an audience, Socrates must be correct in that rhetoric is a craft -- designed not for serious intellectual combat, but for pure entertainment value. 2.Explain and critically evaluate Socrates reasoning for the apparently preposterous claim that tyrants like orators have no great power (Gorgias 466a-468e). You should make sure that you take into account Socrates distinction between doing what one wants and doing what one sees fit. How does Socrates argue for this distinction? How crucial to Socrates argument is it? Is there any such distinction or is Socrates simply mistaken? or, even worse, is Socrates merely playing word games.

One of the primary claims within the entire dialog focuses on Socrates' view of the wielding of real power. He advances the idea that "orators and tyrants have the very least power in any of our cities" (466d). By putting rulers (tyrants) and practitioners of rhetoric into the same category, Socrates indicates that both groups, think they are doing what is in the best interest of themselves to further their means, but in fact...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

Doing what is morally rights, however, may be unpopular, may be grounds for the mob turning, but it is still right. Rhetoric, then, is window dressing, comparable to pastry baking and cosmetics as opposed to medicine and gymnastics -- one is a quick fix and a surface dressing; not long lasting, not moral, not real; the other takes time, effort and work (464c-465d). This difference between the wants of humans and the needs of humans juxtaposed between the surface thought of rhetoric opposed to intellectual philosophy, forms the basis for Socrates' entire argument.
At times, one could read into the work that Socrates was playing word games. For instance, when Socrates agrees to asking and answering his own questions because there seems to be an intellectual stalemate (505d). Yet, when one steps back to view the methodology of Socrates within the structure of this set of dialogs, Socrates does posit that there are true and verifiable differences between base instincts and morals. In showing that he is both a good sport and sees the value of comedic self-deprecation, the reiterates that he was serious about the best use of rhetoric -- best used against one's self. A man who has done evil is wretched, but a man who does evil and is never caught is worse off (509b).

REFERENCES

Plato. Translated and revised by E.R. Dodds. (2003). Gorgias. Oxford University Press.

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

Plato. Translated and revised by E.R. Dodds. (2003). Gorgias. Oxford University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Gymnastics Is a Sport That
Words: 2000 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Of course competition at the major university level, and in the Olympic Games, is also important in terms of national pride and individual achievements for elite athletes. But at the community level, gymnastics is also important because it provides a way for young people to learn about -- and pursue -- practices that promote healthy living. The correlation between components of physical fitness and gymnastics: an article in the Journal

Gymnastics
Words: 2422 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Evolution of Gymnastics: From Ancient Greece to the Modern Olympics:     This essay could explore the transformation of gymnastics from its origins as a formative discipline in Ancient Greece to its current form as a highly competitive sport with various disciplines in the modern Olympics. It could include an examination of how the rules, apparatus, and presentation have changed over time and the factors that have contributed to

Gymnastics
Words: 1816 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Evolution of Gymnastics:     Explore how gymnastics has evolved from ancient times to the modern Olympic sport, detailing changes in equipment, rules, and the inclusion of new events. 2. The Physical and Mental Demands of Gymnastics:     Discuss the rigorous physical training and mental preparation required for gymnasts, including the impact on their health and psychological well-being. 3. Gymnastics and Gender Equality:     Analyze how gymnastics has historically been perceived as a female-dominated sport

Fall of US Womens Gymnastics
Words: 1988 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Larry Nassar and the Risks of US Women’s Gymnastics American gymnastics, particularly women’s gymnastics, has been one of the most popular summer Olympic sports for many decades. Even during non-Olympic years, it has a large following among young girls and their families. Many young girls dream of being the next Shannon Miller or Mary Lou Retton. Unfortunately, pursuit of these high athletic goals comes at a high price for some children.

Boost for Women's Athletics but
Words: 3098 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Secondly, the report alluded to by CSC asserts that in "gender symmetric" sports there are "far more scholarships available for women (32,656) than for men (20,206)." The third bullet point in the CSC press release points out that men's volleyball is the "by far the most difficult" scholarship at the Division I level; there are reportedly 489 high school athletes for every full ride NCAA scholarship. The "underlying" data that CSC

Philosophy: Plato, Socrates, and Zen
Words: 1460 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

He believes that fear of punishment for injustice is all that maintains our praise of justice. Gyges was willing to discard all sense of justice and nobility once the opportunity to act freely presented itself. 5. Socrates' use of the city as metaphor in his discussion of justice is the long way of describing the usefulness of justice and its application in human life. His description of a good city

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now