Verified Document

Socio-Economic System: The Distributive Justice Essay

Rawls is not against equality but he assumes that most socio-economic systems will allow for some inequities, and thus outlines his second principle to deal with those inequities. In this system, the state is powerful enough to provide security for its people on a basic level, but also strives to ensure that no class in society becomes so marginalized and disenfranchised economically that it becomes impossible for any person on the bottom rungs of society to engage in self-improvement. Rawls famously suggested that all societies should be created under what he calls a 'veil of ignorance,' or that rules and regulations should be constructed blindly when creating a society, without any knowledge of what the status of the decision-maker would be in the hypothetical world. In other words, when creating an ideal nation, would you be willing to live under the rules and conditions of the least-privileged members and regard them as fair (Storelli 50)? There is also a certain assumption of moral 'good' on behalf of the decision-maker in this scenario, though, given that Rawls states that governing principles of justice are "that rational and free persons concerned to further their own interests would accept in an initial position of equality as defining the fundamentals of the terms of their association" (Storelli 50). In other words, Rawls assumes that his ideal, objective decision-maker would not want to disenfranchise members of society, even if he or she knew his or her own future position would not be that of the most disenfranchised member."Rawls believed that his principles would be accepted freely by rational egoists in a 'contractual state of nature' or 'contract situation'" and presumes a degree of rationalism on the part of members of society not only to protect their own interest, but to acknowledge the interests of others (Storelli 56)

Although the ways in which constitutional liberties are conceptualized may vary from society to society, most of the major, Western democracies assume that the values of freedom, voting, and the right to certain property protections are...

More controversial, however, is Rawls' notion of how and when redistribution should occur. Without some redistribution of wealth and opportunities, the poorest citizens will not be able to run for office, and may even have difficulty accessing voting booths. If entire classes of citizens' health is poor, if they are denied education, and they lack basic social support services to enable them to transition to a new job, their condition will deteriorate and they will lack basic democratic liberties. This is why the principle of redistributing wealth to favor the least-advantaged members of society is sometimes necessary, according to Rawls (Storelli 50).
One of the most common critiques of Rawls is that he does not sufficiently account for the importance of individual will and effort in attaining a particular social status, and too much redistribution of wealth can cause persons not to take adequate responsibility for their economic decisions (Lamont & Favor 2011). However, Rawls points out that prejudice can cause economic disenfranchisement, or historical circumstances that have nothing to do with the actions of the individual. Wealth can also be the result of forces not pertaining to the individual, like inheritance. For a good society to provide liberty, it cannot allow opportunities to be restricted. A lack of regulation can allow those with unfair advantages that are not the result of merit to prosper.

References

Lamont, Julian & Christian Favor. "Distributive Justice." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2007. [18 Nov 2011] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-distributive/

Piccard, Dick. "A Theory of Justice." 2005. [18 Nov 2011]

http://www.ohio.edu/people/piccard/entropy/rawls.html

Storelli, Christopher. "John Rawls Theory of Justice." In M.P. Wolf and L. Musselman (eds.)

Voicing Ideas, vol 3, pp. 49-57. Fresno, CA: California State University, Fresno.

[18 Nov 2011] http://www.cupr.org/VI3/Storelli-VI3.pdf

Sources used in this document:
References

Lamont, Julian & Christian Favor. "Distributive Justice." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2007. [18 Nov 2011] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-distributive/

Piccard, Dick. "A Theory of Justice." 2005. [18 Nov 2011]

http://www.ohio.edu/people/piccard/entropy/rawls.html

Storelli, Christopher. "John Rawls Theory of Justice." In M.P. Wolf and L. Musselman (eds.)
[18 Nov 2011] http://www.cupr.org/VI3/Storelli-VI3.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Justice and Children
Words: 3432 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

He then went to work for the family business, lived in a nice home and drove a nice car, but had no reported income. Since the birth of their child, who is now a teenager, he has contributed virtually nothing to the child's support, though his mother has established a college fund for the child. Research One area of research that has influenced my view of social justice is the research

Criminal Justice Gaetz, S. July 2004 . Safe
Words: 2782 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Criminal Justice Gaetz, S. (July 2004). Safe streets for whom? Homeless youth, social exclusion, and criminal victimization. Canadian Journal of Criminology & Criminal Justice. This journal article reports the researcher's survey findings regarding the prevalence of victimization among street youths compared to domiciled youths. Gaetz defines the street youth operatively as "people up to the age of 24 who are 'absolutely periodically, or temporarily without shelter, as well as those who are

Discretionary Situations for a Police Chief Discretion
Words: 3257 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Discretionary Situations for a Police Chief Discretion in the Police Department Discretionary Situations in Criminal Arrests: "Stop" and "Frisk," Racial Profiling The expectation is that public administrators apply a balancing act in the decision making process. Focus for this study is on law enforcement administrators, especially police chiefs, on their responses to their officers' discretion to criminal arrests. The argument put forth is that police discretion is limited by managerial and information technology

Fault: An Alternative to the Current Tort-Based
Words: 30263 Length: 110 Document Type: Thesis

Fault: An Alternative to the Current Tort-Based System in England and Wales The United Kingdom statistics regarding claims THE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM OBSTACLES TO DUE PROCESS THE CASE FOR REFORM THE REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT THE RISING COST OF LITIGATION LORD WOOLF'S REFORMS MORE COST CONTROLS THE UNITED STATES PAUL'S PULLOUT THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY TORT REFORM IN AMERICA FLEEING PHYSICIANS STATISTICS FOR ERROR, INJURY AND DEATH THE CALL FOR REFORM IN 2003: A FAMILIAR REFRAIN THE UNITED STATES SITUATION, IN SUMMARY NEW ZEALAND CASE STUDIES THE SWEDISH SCHEME COMPARISON: WHICH SYSTEM IS

Australia As an International Citizen
Words: 2786 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

One of Kilby's contentions, however, was that Australia's hypothesis that increased economic growth would result to poverty reduction is a framework that is not responsive to the realities of poor, developing countries, which are almost always the recipients of AusAID's aid program. The author's claim is that AusAID's thrust -- that economic growth will result to reduced poverty -- is developed from a neoliberalist framework, which is not as responsive

Catholic Church in Spain and the United States
Words: 19318 Length: 70 Document Type: Thesis

Catholic church and public policy have remarked that the members of American clergy in general, without even excepting those who do not admit religious liberty, are all in favour of civil freedom; but they do not support any particular political system. They keep aloof from parties, and from public affairs. In the United States religion exercises but little influence upon laws, and upon the details of public opinion; but it

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now