Verified Document

Social Media Policies Case Study

Social Media Recently, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) made its first social media-related ruling. The board adjudicated a case against Costco, and in this case the NLRB struck down Costco's social media policy as standing in violation of the workers' right to free speech (Little, 2012). The Board found that Costco's policy on social media usage was overly broad. The policy held that employees were prohibited from posting statements that "damage" the company and the policy was incorporated into the Costco Employment Agreement. The NLRB held that this policy was too broad. Specifically, some forms of speech by workers are considered to be protected speech. Protected speech includes work-related complaints, which are given this protection so that they can communicate their grievances both to other employees and to the company. This protection is related to the workers' legal right to organize.

The NLRB applies the same standards to protected labor speech as judges do to First Amendment cases. This interpretation is explained in the following passage: "Costco's policy had a reasonable tendency to inhibit employees' protected activity" (Godard, 2012). Essentially, if an employee cannot reasonably understand the difference between punishable and unpunishable speech, the employee is likely to avoid engaging in...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

That outcome appears to have been a key motivation for Costco. However, if there is a chance that an employee will feel uncomfortable making protected speech for fear of punishment under vague rules, those rules are in violation of the applicable code that protects the speech. The doctrine of "no infringement," meaning real, perceived or potential, is being applied here by the NLRB.
2. I agree with the NLRB on this decision. The wording in Costco's employee agreement was far too vague. The wording seemed as though the employee could be subject to punishment for any statement on social media that a Costco manager could construe as negative or damaging to the company. Such rules are not allowed to be vague and subjective, because subjective application of the rule could see employees being punished for protected speech. Even the legal definition of protected speech in this instance is somewhat vague. Thus, neither Costco nor the National Labor Relations Act can clearly differentiate between protected and unprotected speech in all instances. As a result, neither can employees. Given that there can be no infringement of any sort on protected labor speech, Costco's blanket statement in the employment agreement thus violates the NLRA.

It is important for workers to have specific rights,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

Little, L. (2012). Fired for FB, tweets? NLRB ruling draws lines. ABC News. Retrieved November 11, 2012 from http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/business/2012/10/fired-for-fb-tweets-nlrb-rulings-draw-lines/

Godard, L. (2012). Does your social media policy pass muster with the NLRB? Social Media Today. Retrieved November 11, 2012 from http://socialmediatoday.com/lggodard/866571/does-your-social-media-policy-pass-muster-nlrb-take-test
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Media's Massive Influence on Society Does
Words: 1540 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Social Media's Massive Influence On Society Does Media-Based Relationship and Communities Have a Damaging Effect on Society Social Media's Massive Influence on Society Current mass media enduringly influence people. People undergo exposure to this impact, which they are unable to shun since mass and social media exists in all dispensations. Modern media are a crucial element of the contemporary culture, and they fashion cultural characteristics and viewpoints of people. In this situation and

Social Media and Emergency Communications Social Media
Words: 1003 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Social Media and Emergency Communications Social Media Emergency Communications Social media popular crucial crisis emergency communications. Responders communicating public social media outlets, public communicating, responders. Individuals provide important information disaster The pros and cons Social media has allowed people to communicate with a large group of people in real time. The integration of social media in mobile devices has also spread its reach, which has allowed for ease of communication between individuals. In

Social Media Issues in Law Enforcement
Words: 1780 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Social Media and Law Enforcement Social Media Issues in law Enforcement Social media and law enforcement: Boon or bane? Social media is a fact of everyday modern life. For law enforcement personnel, it has created new opportunities to share resources with the public, including as 'tweeting' information about a possible suspect or releasing safety information to the public about terrorist incidents or natural disasters. At first, in the Internet age, police departments were

Social Media - A New Kind of
Words: 2405 Length: 6 Document Type: Dissertation

Social Media - a New Kind of Security Problem in Business The Newest Threat to any Business: Social Media Social media is one of the most significant changes that has come about in communication today. However, it can also have serious implications for business and for the privacy and protection of businesses and employees. Overall, social media is not something that can be ignored by businesses today, because it can offer worries

Social Media Marketing Risk in Social Media
Words: 1644 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Social Media Marketing Risk in Social Media Marketing Role of Federal Government in Managing Cross Country Transactions Regulation of Customer Transactions through Government Branches Agency Relationship in Social Media Sites Social Media marketing is increasing at fast pace and giving business organizations an opportunity to offer their products to diverse market located all over the world. Likewise, customers are getting unlimited product varieties to choose from according to their need and preference. There are certain

Social Media the "United Breaks Guitars" Phenomenon
Words: 1523 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Social Media The "United Breaks Guitars" phenomenon spawned a new era in consumer empowerment. As Kaufman (2012) states, "until very recently, there seemed to be fewer and fewer ways for ordinary people to fight back against powerful corporations." Now, consumers have a range of possible ways to get other consumers to change their purchasing behaviors -- hitting companies where it hurts the most. A friend recently posted on Facebook about a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now