The human factor is often not taken into consideration. Elements such as empowerment, communication and recognition play an important role in determining the success of the Six Sigma methodology, according to the result of the study.
Implementation in sectors like finance and sales were unsuccessful, due to the very nature of the concept, which was developed and is still mainly applied in manufacturing organizations (especially mass-manufacturing). The very basis of Six Sigma, the defect measure approach was simply ineffective in other areas of the economy. The opinion which rises from the literature review above coincides with the result of the study conducted by McAdam and Lafferty: outside a mass manufacturing environment, the Six Sigma methodology is unsuccessful.
The data gathered from this research reveals that empowerment of the employees in a sense that they are allowed to chose how and which tools to use in the performance of their jobs is essential to an increase in the general profitability of the organization. People are logical beings that need to establish a connection between cause and effect. Six Sigma bases itself on the belief in the all-mighty technology and methodology, which ultimately leads to failure.
The current preoccupations regarding the Six Sigma phenomenon appeared as an effect of the development of Total Quality Management, which evolved from a simple mechanistic approach to a more complex mechanistic and organic model. This model is based on the needs of business and employees and is not intended to be a replacement for TQM, but instead a "means of refocusing the need for business deliverables on the mechanized side of TQM." The conclusion to which the study arrives is that each and every organization that intends on implementing a Six Sigma methodology needs to carefully evaluate the existing culture within the business. A special attention must be paid to this issue by managers of companies which have previously implemented a TQM program. One advantage of Six Sigma, according to the authors of the study is a renewed focus in regard to process output.
Concerning research methodology, McAdam and Lafferty emphasize the need for additional exploration, using both the inductive and the deductive methods in order for the amount of literature available to be increased. Their study is intended to be the corner stone of a new approach toward the relation between mechanistic and people variables in the Six Sigma concept.
References
Antony, J. And Banuelas, R. (2001) 'A strategy for survival', Manufacturing Engineer, Vol. 80, No.3, pp.119-121.
Antony, J. And Banuelas, R. (2002) 'Critical success factors for the successful implementation...
The results retrieved by Victor, Boynton and Stephens-Jang point out to a necessity to find a balance between standardized work and continuous learning process. They also indicate that employees who have managed to find this balance reveal higher levels of on-the-job satisfaction, as well as lower levels of stress. A crucial approach to total quality management is taken by Mohamed Zairi (2002), who looks at quality management in the context
Management Comparison A Comparison of Six Sigma to Lean Manufacturing, Strategic Quality Management, and Total Quality Management There are a plethora of management strategies and perspectives that are being employed in operations and supply chain management in the modern business environment. Among the various theories being implemented, Six Sigma, Lean Manufacturing, Strategic Quality Management, and Total Quality Management are among the most popular. This paper will compare and contrast some of the
It is a comprehensive approach that certainly includes the optimization of operational processes emphasized in the Six Sigma framework, but operational processes represent only one small component part of the much broader focus of TQM. If there is a disadvantage to TQM, it would be in connection with the types of businesses or industries in which the standardization and optimization of operational processes is extremely important. In principle, those
Sigma This best-selling book by Mikel Harry and Richard Schroeder has been held in high esteem for more than twenty years. Indeed the reputation earned by Six Sigma: The Breakthrough Management Strategy Revolutionizing the World's Top Corporations has for the most part been excellent, especially in the corporate industry. The authors are highly qualified to write a book about Six Sigma since they basically founded the organization. Mikel Harry is
3. The Six Sigma tools are basically concepts and tools used to improve the outcomes of the business operations. Their subjectivity derives from two sources: the person applying the tools and the subjectivity of the tools. First of all, the individual is implementing the tool; therefore he is likely to be subjective in judging the tool, implementing it and analyzing the results. Secondly, the tool itself is subjective as it
Second, greater education about the values and benefit of this approach to managing projects needs to be completed (Brady, Maylor, 2010). Third, the inertia and lack of motivation to change needs to be quantified and shown to managers to see how their lack of commitment and urgency are hurting their businesses. All of these factors center on the value of time and its precious nature as a resource (Brady,
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now