Verified Document

Situation When Doing Good Is Wrong Essay

Related Topics:

ACTING OUT OF A SENSE OF ONE’S DUTY CAN BE WRONG 3 Acting Out of a Sense of One’s Duty Can Be Wrong

An example to illustrate how one can be acting out of duty and they end up causing more harm than if they had not done anything is in assisting accident victims. When an accident occurs, people will rush and they will attempt to assist the injured persons, however, there are situations where the good samaritan assisting the injured could cause more harm than if they had left the victims and waited for paramedics or firefighters. If an accident victim is pulled or moved from the car without proper care being taken, it could result in the victim suffering more and increasing their injuries. Although the act of kindness being shown by assisting the victim is out of duty the victim could become paralyzed, suffer severe bleeding, or aggravate spinal injuries.

Looking at Kant’s moral philosophy, assisting the accident victim would be done out of duty and not gain anything in return. Therefore, the person assisting the accident victim would be doing what they consider to be morally right (Köllen, 2016). However,...

The individual helping an injured person is doing this from duty. This is because they are not inclined to do so and they do not gain any pleasure from assisting the victim. However, if the individual is assisting the individual so that they can be considered to be a hero then they are doing it in accordance with duty. This should not be confused with one gaining fame or publicity after they have assisted the victim. According to Kant (2017), it is the motive that determines the worth of an action. Therefore, the consequences of the action should not be used to assess the moral worth of the action. It is only the motive that can be used to assess the moral worth of the action (Korsgaard, 2014). If the good samaritan gains publicity after they have done their duty, then they cannot be accused of having done the action with the motive of gaining publicity.
When a person is assisting another…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Legal Precedent for a Situation Gone Wrong
Words: 1120 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Legal Precedent for a Situation Gone Wrong Influence of the courts over child custody arrangements in the case of a divorce is low to non-existent. There is a persistent expectation that the parents will come to an agreement about matters related to children, and it is generally not considered beneficial to engage the courts. It is important for disputing married couples to understand that there are three separate issues embedded in

Good Country People by Flannery O'Connor Is
Words: 2745 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Good Country People by Flannery O'Connor is a story that illustrates how deceptive appearances can be and what errors are made when people hide behind their own cliched perceptions instead of thinking clearly about situations. The main plot of the story involving Hulga illustrates this theme. As well as this, O'Connor offers many other references to the theme via the other characters, the events and symbols in the work. An

Good and Evil Aristotle Bases
Words: 2990 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

.. The superior man is broad and fair; the inferior man takes sides and is petty... A superior man shapes the good in man; he does not shape the bad in him. It is said that a disciple once asked Confucius to define the conduct of one's entire life with a single word. The Chinese philosopher replied: "Is not reciprocity such a word? What you do not want done to yourself

Wrong Moves and Analyzes the Decision-Making Process
Words: 1153 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Wrong Moves" and analyzes the decision-making process of Nutrorim CEO Don Rifkin and his management team. The essay also makes recommendations regarding improvements, including changes to management styles and the use of decision tools. Analysis of Key Issues The key issues in the case involve deciding whether to recall ChargeUp after a health inspector made allegations that the drink was responsible for causing illness among 11 people. During the process of

Wrong for the Applicants to Take an
Words: 906 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

wrong for the applicants to take an unauthorized peek at their application files. The intent of the school was clearly to have those files closed, so the viewing of those files was a breach of the school's intentions. There is an implicit duty on the part of the applicant to avoid looking at those files, even if the opportunity presents itself. Many of the candidates in question apply a consequentialist

Wrong With Strategy Is Focused
Words: 1812 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Patience is required, and that is also difficult for many people. By building well-researched insight into a business, a leader can come up with tactics that will help that business. From that point, the leader can also come up with strategies that allow the company to address the tactics. That sounds easy, but it is a difficult process that will take time. However, when it is done correctly it is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now