Verified Document

Single-Payer Vs. Private Solutions In Healthcare Research Paper

Federal Role in Healthcare There are two very entrenched camps in the universal health care debate as well as regarding what the federal role in healthcare should be. It is clear that the private and employer-based system is not serving the American public as well as it should be but scandals and problems with the Veteran's Administration (VA) and Medicare are proof positive that the government cannot be the driving force either. While both of the major suggested approaches to solving the crisis of uncovered people and the lack of portability of employer-based healthcare are both problematic each in their own way and a more balanced approach is necessary to give people the assistance they need but without toying with the private market for insurance in too protracted a way.

Analysis

The federal role of healthcare has probably been an issue on some level or another since the 1930's when Social Security came about and it got ramped a lot more with the inception of Medicare during the Lyndon Johnson administration. Further still did the vitriol extend during the "Hillary Care" debates of the 1990's and now the United States is still within the aftermath of the contentious passage of the Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as ObamaCare, in 2010. The debate seems to be raging...

One extreme suggest that "single payer" healthcare, otherwise commonly known as universal health care and the common approach on one level or another of Canada and Western Europe. The other extreme is a purely market-based solution, with perhaps only Medicare and Medicaid being the only government sources of healthcare, that is typified by the healthcare market that is almost entirely employer-based.
Of course, neither extreme is the proper answer in the grand scheme of things. It is indeed true that racial minorities in the United States face challenges that most other Americans do not (Snowden, 2012). Specialists need to be full part of any governmental solution even if the importance of primary care is ramped up a good deal (Nash, 2009). Further, some of the points driven home by "propagandists" seemingly have been proven at least in part since the passage of ObamaCare (Knoblauch, 2014). However, a public insurance policy is already in place (Medicare/Medicaid) and other is not the real solution needed (Gottschalk, 2011). Also, keeping the burden on corporations is not the proper way to go (Corbett & Kappagoda, 2013).

Instead, a healthcare exchange ran and populated by the private sector and that removes the stubborn linkage between employment and healthcare is the way to go. Rather than making employment the necessary precursor, an affordable premium alone would be better and a…

Sources used in this document:
References

Corbett, J., & Kappagoda, M. (2013). Doing Good and Doing Well: Corporate Social

Responsibility in Post Obamacare America. Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 4117-21. doi:10.1111/jlme.12032

An assessment of what businesses could or should be responsible for after the passage of the Affordable Care Act, aka ObamaCare.

Gottschalk, M. (2011). They're Back: The Public Plan, the Reincarnation of Harry and Louise, and the Limits of Obamacare. Journal Of Health Politics, Policy & Law, 36(3), 393-400. doi:10.1215/03616878-1271009
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Health Care in the U.S. and Spain
Words: 7032 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Health Care in the U.S. And Spain What Can the U.S. Learn About Health Care from Spain? In 2009, Spain's single-payer health care system was ranked the seventh best in the world by the World Health Organization (Socolovsky, 2009). By comparison, the U.S. health care system ranted at 37 (Satiroglou, 2009). The Spanish system offers coverage as a right of citizenship that is constitutionally guaranteed. Spanish residents pay no expenses out-of-pocket, with

Universal Health Care This Project
Words: 8619 Length: 30 Document Type: Capstone Project

Chapter 2: Review of Related Literature Chapter Introduction This chapter provides the background and an overview of the debate concerning national health insurance and the issues surrounding the provision of universal health care in the United States. A discussion of the implications of universal health care for private insurance carriers and other stakeholders is followed by a review of the criticisms being directed at current efforts to reform health care in the

Healthcare Reform Ways the Healthcare
Words: 7972 Length: 29 Document Type: Thesis

Transparency empowers consumers to become better shoppers. Economists assert that transparency stimulates productivity, for example, in exchange for money, one individual obtaining fair value. In every aspect, except healthcare, Davis points out, transparency, is supported. The contemporary dearth of transparency in healthcare has led to many Americans not being able to effectively shop for the best quality of service at acute care hospitals. Davis argues that transparency permits consumers,

Health Care Delivery System
Words: 640 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Reform: Recommendations and Analysis Wells Fargo Small Business Roundup vs. The Physicians Working Group (PWG) According to the privately-run bank Wells Fargo's website that supports small business interests, universal single-payer health insurance is not feasible in the United States. Unsurprisingly, the bank wants as little government intervention as possible. "To the greatest extent possible, Americans should receive their health insurance and health care through the private sector. One-size-fits-all insurance and care

Healthcare Issues With the Provision
Words: 1180 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

In their move from a completely government-paid and -- operated healthcare system to a fees-based approach, the Chinese have greatly improved the efficiency, availability, and efficacy of their healthcare system (Wan & Wan 2010). This suggests that a combination of perspectives, rather than the market or single-payer perspectives that form so many healthcare systems, is most effective. There are also, of course, healthcare systems that have developed in the same

Health Care Disparity in Maryland
Words: 18449 Length: 67 Document Type: Dissertation

Figure 1 portrays the state of Maryland, the location for the focus of this DRP. Figure 1: Map of Maryland, the State (Google Maps, 2009) 1.3 Study Structure Organization of the Study The following five chapters constitute the body of Chapter I: Introduction Chapter II: Review of the Literature Chapter III: Methods and Results Chapter IV: Chapter V: Conclusions, Recommendations, and Implications Chapter I: Introduction During Chapter I, the researcher presents this study's focus, as it relates to the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now