Verified Document

Singin' In The Rain Live Essay

Extended detours into pure ballet notwithstanding, the "stage-oriented" economy of Singin' in the Rain does not permit it to linger on the outright repetition of any shot or sequence. However, allied techniques allow it to achieve a certain degree of formal and sentimental unity. In terms of large-scale structure, the decision to bookend the film's action between two theatrical premieres is extraordinary. Unlike a more explicitly flashback-driven story like Sunset Boulevard (a near-contemporaneous but darker meditation on Hollywood's transition to sound), the trajectory here is less circular than spiral in form: The gala debut of the film-within-a-film that closes Singin' in the Rain echoes the launch of the Royal Rascal that began it, but the superficial similarities only demonstrate how much the characters (and our understanding of them) have evolved in the meantime.

This "shot and echo" structure also gives viewers a chance to reflect on the film's awareness of its own illusionistic nature. We enter the world of Singin' in the Rain as moviegoers, as fans lined up for a glimpse of the stars "in real life." We leave as industry insiders well schooled in the way the film's vision of Hollywood behind the curtain functions, having spent time on the soundstages as well as the stars' mansions. When that "curtain" rises to expose the gap between backstage realities (embodied by Kathy, "the girl whose voice you heard and loved tonight") and the glamour propagated by the fan magazines, we (and Don Lockwood) have been prepared for it and know where to place our loyalties.

On a smaller scale, Singin' in the Rain provides some repetitive cues by returning to the production of the film-within-a-film at various points in its evolution...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

We see the same scene played out in the silent idiom, then with sound, and, after the disastrous test screening, in its final form. This approach is not so much literal as implicitly musical: a "theme" is stated and then tested in its variations. First, the failure of the silent film as a mirror of reality is demonstrated through the silent camera's failure to capture anything but Lockwood and Lamont's romantic mummery. Then, the technical realities of sound production are introduced as a possible solution, but its failures (and Lamont's) are only exploited for comic effect at the test screening. While a hybrid solution is explored, it too is unsuccessful, ultimately allowing the film to make one last argument for legitimate theatrical talent as the ground of authenticity.
And for Singin' in the Rain, authenticity is the hallmark of joy. Kathy is loveable to the extent to which she is real: She dances, she expresses independent viewpoints and an interest in "live" (unmediated) theatre, and most of all, the character has vocal talent. Lina Lamont may look "refined" on film, but significantly can't sing or dance; her career depended on the constraints inherent in the silent form and the advance of cinematic technology only reveals her limitations. But those who can perform in a relatively unmediated environment manage to not only adapt to technological innovation but also connect with other human beings. Their cinematic output -- Kelly's output, O'Connor's, Charisse's -- is what Singin' in the Rain means to me that a Royal Rascal does not. Film only preserved their personality and their talent for generations like mine to enjoy. That's the breathtaking thing, and it's what we remember.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Silent Film and Its Effect
Words: 2636 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Silent films were caught in the cross-hairs of all this. Buster Keaton: Silent Film Visionary -- Too Much Imagination Yet, that sort of nightmare world of industrialization both inspired and was depicted in silent film. The Lumiere brothers were innovative geniuses who devised a portable camera, better equipped for transfer than Edison's bulky machine, and photographed technological marvels (like that train engine) to entertain audiences. One of the great comics of

Silent Film and How Critical Reception Shifts Over Time
Words: 2850 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

Silent Film And How Critical Reception Shifts Over Time The objective of this study is to examine the film Das Cabinet Des Dr. Caligari or 'The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari" and to examine silent film and how critical reception shifts over time. The film Das Cabinet Des Dr. Caligari or 'The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari" echoed the German psychological warfare that had been waged against the people by Hitler and throughout the

Silent Film Nanook of the North by Robert Flaherty
Words: 2202 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Silent Film: Robert Flaherty and Nanook of the North Robert Flaherty is one of the most renowned filmmakers of all time. He was born in 1883 and died in 1951, so that his life and work encompassed what is frequently referred to as the Golden Age of cinema. Although Flaherty was an American, he lived near the U.S./Canadian border, and went to Toronto for his schooling. His early work experience was

Silent Film Critic One Cannot
Words: 968 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

The first scene of The Great Train Robbery takes place inside the railroad telegraph office when two masked bandits are able to force the telegraph operator stop a train that is approaching the station so that they can climb aboard. After getting the telegraph operator to lie about a water stop, the next scene finds the train at the water tower by the station where the bandits will sneak onto

Silent Film When "The Jazz
Words: 1693 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

For approximately three quarters of the film it is without dialogue but, "It was for the clink of plates, the rattle of ice cubes, the sound of a man singing, of two people talking, that silent films died." (Eyman 76). The lively exuberance of Al Jolson was truly what made this film an instant classic and demanded the continuation of Warner Brothers and the talkies. For the first time,

Silent Film Melodrama, Race, and the Oppression
Words: 1689 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Silent Film Melodrama, Race, and the Oppression of Missionary Idealism: "Broken Blossoms" (1919) and "The Color Purple" (1985) Both Steven Spielberg's rendition of Alice Walker's novel "The Color Purple" and the 1919 silent film directed by D.W. Griffith entitled "Broken Blossoms" function as melodramas of racial misunderstandings. This silent film tells the story of an opium-addicted Chinese man who fosters an illegitimate Cockney waif, played by Lillian Gish. The young

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now