Verified Document

Silence Broken Almost Invariably, It Essay

Furthermore, there is little by way of denial by representatives of the Japanese side. When the film as representation of reality is taken into account, it is interesting to consider the tension between the presentations of the present as opposed to the past. The present is represented as the reality that it is; with the women displaying the current state of their injuries and explaining the effect of the events upon them. Since no footage remains of the events in questions, actors must necessarily reenact the events of the past, which casts some uncertainty over verisimilitude. Also, the events being related could be the result of distorted memory or the desire to create a shock effect that resembles the shock and horror the women experienced when being abducted from their homes and their lives.

While it appears plausible, therefore, that many of these women were lured from their homes and schools by promises of work and money, other accounts might be somewhat embellished. Some of the more outlandish accounts include how the women were forced to bayonet Chinese civilians and even eat human flesh. Interestingly, the past is also represented by archival film, still black and white photographs, and footage of soldiers and the dead. This relieves some of the tension created by credibility concerns.

It is highly unlikely that any of the women openly lied, or even embellished their stories. Indeed, there is as little evidence to suggest this as there is to suggest that they are speaking the truth. However, the way in which the film is set up as representative of the suffering that occurred during the war, suggests some challenges to its verisimilitude. This challenge might be met by arguing that the first-person accounts are provided individually, without coaching and without any external influence. Furthermore it might also be argued that the impenetrable Japanese culture would do little to divulge helpful information to lend more balance to the film. The filmmaker therefore...

255) confirms this view. According to the author, the representation of the past, even in historical fashion, does not as such mean that it is an accurate or precise depiction. On the other hand, this does not mean either that the memory presented is invalid. Certainly, the memories of the women who speak during the film appear sincere enough, especially when supported by evidence such as wounds and even death.
When drawing a conclusion about the appropriate presentations of the past in Kim-Gibson's film, the most valid view is possibly that it is a "hypothesis" of the past, where there is no denial that materials are limited and memories could fade. The hypothesis is not, however, invalid for this reason. Because the filmmaker acknowledges her limitations, she uses the materials that she does have to the best of her ability. Archival footage and photographs supplement the enacted material to provide substance to the testimonies of the women.

In conclusion then, it is suggested that the film provides a valid view of the past, where personal memories are used to describe a devastating war crime that ruined hundreds of thousands of lives. As the film's title suggests, the silence is now broken by showing the audience the depths to which the human spirit can sink as a result of either power or powerlessness. The women found themselves in a dispossessed state, where all their power of decision making is removed, and they are trapped by Japanese soldiers who care nothing for their well-being beyond what they could provide physically. In this sense, the film does its work with great sensitivity and validity.

References

Benjamin, W. (1968). Illuminations. New York: Schocken Books.

Levi, L. (1986). The Drowned and the Saved. Translated by Raymond Rosenthal. New York: Summit Books.

Sources used in this document:
References

Benjamin, W. (1968). Illuminations. New York: Schocken Books.

Levi, L. (1986). The Drowned and the Saved. Translated by Raymond Rosenthal. New York: Summit Books.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Henry Thomas Buckle's Original 1858
Words: 12518 Length: 50 Document Type: Dissertation

As activists in women's liberation, discussing and analyzing the oppression and inequalities they experienced as women, they felt it imperative to find out about the lives of their foremothers -- and found very little scholarship in print" (Women's history, 2012, para. 3). This dearth of scholarly is due in large part to the events and themes that are the focus of the historical record. In this regard, "History was

Colombia Is the Third-Largest Recipient
Words: 19788 Length: 58 Document Type: Research Proposal

During this penultimate period of violence under Rojas, the violence that wracked Colombia assumed a number of different characteristics that included an economic quality as well as a political one with numerous assassinations taking place. These were literally contract killings there were sponsored by opposition forms. There were also horrendous genocidal acts that were carried out by gangs combined with authentic revolutionary fighting in some regions of the country. The fourth

Jesus' Teachings, Prayer, & Christian Life He
Words: 35411 Length: 109 Document Type: Dissertation

Jesus' Teachings, Prayer, & Christian Life "He (Jesus) Took the Bread. Giving Thanks Broke it. And gave it to his Disciples, saying, 'This is my Body, which is given to you.'" At Elevation time, during Catholic Mass, the priest establishes a mandate for Christian Living. Historically, at the Last Supper, Christ used bread and wine as a supreme metaphor for the rest of our lives. Jesus was in turmoil. He was

Ben Jonson Intertextualities: The Influence
Words: 22973 Length: 80 Document Type: Essay

" James a.S. McPeek further blames Jonson for this corruption: "No one can read this dainty song to Celia without feeling that Jonson is indecorous in putting it in the mouth of such a thoroughgoing scoundrel as Volpone." Shelburne asserts that the usual view of Jonson's use of the Catullan poem is distorted by an insufficient understanding of Catullus' carmina, which comes from critics' willingness to adhere to a conventional -- yet incorrect

Fall Camus's Story, the Fall
Words: 2138 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

.. Anyone who has considerably meditated on man, by profession or vocation, is led to feel nostalgia for the primates. They at least don't have any ulterior motives." (Camus, 4) Passion as well might make one authentic, or a true and mindless embrace of any aspect of life. Truthfully, the story does little to present us with true authenticity, because the narrator himself never discovers it. The meaning of this story

Protestant Devotion to the Virgin
Words: 24041 Length: 75 Document Type: Dissertation

However, certain elements of traditional Christian theology are centered on Mary, and the degree of emphasis that those elements receive can be very telling about Mary's actual role in the religion. For example, the connection between female chastity and religious observance seems to have been established by God's choice of a Virgin to carry his son. God did not have to choose a virgin to bear his child, but

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now